The Effect of Uncertainty in Exposure Estimation on the Exposure-Response Relation between 1,3-Butadiene and Leukemia
Abstract: In a follow-up study of mortality among North American synthetic rubber industry workers, cumulative exposure to 1,3-butadiene was positively associated with leukemia. Problems with historical exposure estimation, however, may have distorted the association. To evaluate the impact of poten...
Main Authors: | , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
MDPI AG
2009-09-01
|
Series: | International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | http://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/6/9/2436/ |
id |
doaj-2b3057627c1743b6b9c8f7868edc7a71 |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-2b3057627c1743b6b9c8f7868edc7a712020-11-24T21:16:01ZengMDPI AGInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health1660-46012009-09-01692436245510.3390/ijerph6092436The Effect of Uncertainty in Exposure Estimation on the Exposure-Response Relation between 1,3-Butadiene and LeukemiaGeorge MaldonadoRobert MatthewsMaurizio MacalusoJohn J. GraffNalini SathiakumarElizabeth DelzellAbstract: In a follow-up study of mortality among North American synthetic rubber industry workers, cumulative exposure to 1,3-butadiene was positively associated with leukemia. Problems with historical exposure estimation, however, may have distorted the association. To evaluate the impact of potential inaccuracies in exposure estimation, we conducted uncertainty analyses of the relation between cumulative exposure to butadiene and leukemia. We created the 1,000 sets of butadiene estimates using job-exposure matrices consisting of exposure values that corresponded to randomly selected percentiles of the approximate probability distribution of plant-, work area/job group-, and year specific butadiene ppm. We then analyzed the relation between cumulative exposure to butadiene and leukemia for each of the 1,000 sets of butadiene estimates. In the uncertainty analysis, the point estimate of the RR for the first non zero exposure category (>0–<37.5 ppm-years) was most likely to be about 1.5. The rate ratio for the second exposure category (37.5–<184.7 ppm-years) was most likely to range from 1.5 to 1.8. The RR for category 3 of exposure (184.7–<425.0 ppm-years) was most likely between 2.1 and 3.0. The RR for the highest exposure category (425.0+ ppm-years) was likely to be between 2.9 and 3.7. This range off RR point estimates can best be interpreted as a probability distribution that describes our uncertainty in RR point estimates due to uncertainty in exposure estimation. After considering the complete probability distributions of butadiene exposure estimates, the exposure-response association of butadiene and leukemia was maintained. This exercise was a unique example of how uncertainty analyses can be used to investigate and support an observed measure of effect when occupational exposure estimates are employed in the absence of direct exposure measurements. http://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/6/9/2436/1,3-butadieneepidemiologymethodsleukemiaworkplace exposuresuncertainty analysis |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
George Maldonado Robert Matthews Maurizio Macaluso John J. Graff Nalini Sathiakumar Elizabeth Delzell |
spellingShingle |
George Maldonado Robert Matthews Maurizio Macaluso John J. Graff Nalini Sathiakumar Elizabeth Delzell The Effect of Uncertainty in Exposure Estimation on the Exposure-Response Relation between 1,3-Butadiene and Leukemia International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 1,3-butadiene epidemiology methods leukemia workplace exposures uncertainty analysis |
author_facet |
George Maldonado Robert Matthews Maurizio Macaluso John J. Graff Nalini Sathiakumar Elizabeth Delzell |
author_sort |
George Maldonado |
title |
The Effect of Uncertainty in Exposure Estimation on the Exposure-Response Relation between 1,3-Butadiene and Leukemia |
title_short |
The Effect of Uncertainty in Exposure Estimation on the Exposure-Response Relation between 1,3-Butadiene and Leukemia |
title_full |
The Effect of Uncertainty in Exposure Estimation on the Exposure-Response Relation between 1,3-Butadiene and Leukemia |
title_fullStr |
The Effect of Uncertainty in Exposure Estimation on the Exposure-Response Relation between 1,3-Butadiene and Leukemia |
title_full_unstemmed |
The Effect of Uncertainty in Exposure Estimation on the Exposure-Response Relation between 1,3-Butadiene and Leukemia |
title_sort |
effect of uncertainty in exposure estimation on the exposure-response relation between 1,3-butadiene and leukemia |
publisher |
MDPI AG |
series |
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health |
issn |
1660-4601 |
publishDate |
2009-09-01 |
description |
Abstract: In a follow-up study of mortality among North American synthetic rubber industry workers, cumulative exposure to 1,3-butadiene was positively associated with leukemia. Problems with historical exposure estimation, however, may have distorted the association. To evaluate the impact of potential inaccuracies in exposure estimation, we conducted uncertainty analyses of the relation between cumulative exposure to butadiene and leukemia. We created the 1,000 sets of butadiene estimates using job-exposure matrices consisting of exposure values that corresponded to randomly selected percentiles of the approximate probability distribution of plant-, work area/job group-, and year specific butadiene ppm. We then analyzed the relation between cumulative exposure to butadiene and leukemia for each of the 1,000 sets of butadiene estimates. In the uncertainty analysis, the point estimate of the RR for the first non zero exposure category (>0–<37.5 ppm-years) was most likely to be about 1.5. The rate ratio for the second exposure category (37.5–<184.7 ppm-years) was most likely to range from 1.5 to 1.8. The RR for category 3 of exposure (184.7–<425.0 ppm-years) was most likely between 2.1 and 3.0. The RR for the highest exposure category (425.0+ ppm-years) was likely to be between 2.9 and 3.7. This range off RR point estimates can best be interpreted as a probability distribution that describes our uncertainty in RR point estimates due to uncertainty in exposure estimation. After considering the complete probability distributions of butadiene exposure estimates, the exposure-response association of butadiene and leukemia was maintained. This exercise was a unique example of how uncertainty analyses can be used to investigate and support an observed measure of effect when occupational exposure estimates are employed in the absence of direct exposure measurements. |
topic |
1,3-butadiene epidemiology methods leukemia workplace exposures uncertainty analysis |
url |
http://www.mdpi.com/1660-4601/6/9/2436/ |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT georgemaldonado theeffectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT robertmatthews theeffectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT mauriziomacaluso theeffectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT johnjgraff theeffectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT nalinisathiakumar theeffectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT elizabethdelzell theeffectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT georgemaldonado effectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT robertmatthews effectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT mauriziomacaluso effectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT johnjgraff effectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT nalinisathiakumar effectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia AT elizabethdelzell effectofuncertaintyinexposureestimationontheexposureresponserelationbetween13butadieneandleukemia |
_version_ |
1726017471343755264 |