Comparing Spatial Ability of Male and Female Students Completing Humanities vs. Technical Degrees
Background. Spatial ability (SA) has long been the focus of research in psychology, because it is associated with performance in science, technologies, engineering, and mathematics (STEM). Research has shown that males consistently outperform females in most aspects of SA, which may partially explai...
Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University
2018-12-01
|
Series: | Psychology in Russia: State of Art |
Subjects: |
id |
doaj-3bd956319dfd44219874c085de6cbf48 |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-3bd956319dfd44219874c085de6cbf482020-11-25T02:38:16ZengM.V. Lomonosov Moscow State UniversityPsychology in Russia: State of Art2074-68572307-22022018-12-01114374910.11621/pir.2018.0403Comparing Spatial Ability of Male and Female Students Completing Humanities vs. Technical DegreesElena A. Esipenko0Ekaterina P. Maslennikova1Anna V. Budakova2Kseniya R. Sharafeva3Viсtoria I. Ismatullina4Inna V. Feklicheva5Nadezhda A. Chipeeva6Elena L. Soldatova7Zhanna E. Borodaeva8Kaili Rimfeld9Nikolas G. Shakeshaf10Margherita Malanchini11Sergey B. Malykh12International Centre for Research in Human Development, Tomsk State University, Tomsk, RussiaSouth Ural State University, Chelyabinsk, RussiaInternational Centre for Research in Human Development, Tomsk State University, Tomsk, RussiaInternational Centre for Research in Human Development, Tomsk State University, Tomsk, RussiaPsychological Institute of Russian Academy of Education, Moscow, RussiaSouth Ural State University, Chelyabinsk, RussiaSouth Ural State University, Chelyabinsk, RussiaSouth Ural State University, Chelyabinsk, RussiaInternational Centre for Research in Human Development, Tomsk State University, Tomsk, RussiaKing’s College, University of London, UKKing’s College, University of London, UKDepartment of Psychology, University of Texas at Austin, USAPsychological Institute of Russian Academy of Education, Moscow, RussiaBackground. Spatial ability (SA) has long been the focus of research in psychology, because it is associated with performance in science, technologies, engineering, and mathematics (STEM). Research has shown that males consistently outperform females in most aspects of SA, which may partially explain the observed overrepresentation of male students seeking STEM degrees. Objective. Tis study examines sex and feld of study (degree) diferences in diferent aspects of spatial ability and its structure. Design. We assessed SA by using an on-line gamifed battery, which included 10 spatial tests capturing 10 dimensions of spatial ability, among which were mental rotation, spatial visualization, spatial scanning, spatial reasoning, perspective-taking, and mechanical reasoning. Te sample consisted of 882 STEM (55% males) and Humanities (20% males) university students in Russia. Results. Males outperformed females on all assessed components of SA with a small efect size (1–11%). We also found that students from STEM felds outperformed Humanities students on all SA subtests (efect size ranged from 0.2 to 7%). Tese diferences by study choice were not fully explained by the observed over-representation of males in the STEM group. Te results of the study suggested no interaction between sex and degree. In other words, on average, males outperformed females, irrespective of whether they were STEM or humanities students; and the STEM advantage was observed for both males and females. Te same unifactorial structure of SA was observed in the STEM and Humanities groups. Conclusion. Our results are consistent with previous research, suggesting sex and study feld diferences in SA. Longitudinal research is needed to explore the causal mechanisms underscoring these diferences.Spatial ability (SA)degree (feld of study)gender diferencesindividual differencesSTEM |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Elena A. Esipenko Ekaterina P. Maslennikova Anna V. Budakova Kseniya R. Sharafeva Viсtoria I. Ismatullina Inna V. Feklicheva Nadezhda A. Chipeeva Elena L. Soldatova Zhanna E. Borodaeva Kaili Rimfeld Nikolas G. Shakeshaf Margherita Malanchini Sergey B. Malykh |
spellingShingle |
Elena A. Esipenko Ekaterina P. Maslennikova Anna V. Budakova Kseniya R. Sharafeva Viсtoria I. Ismatullina Inna V. Feklicheva Nadezhda A. Chipeeva Elena L. Soldatova Zhanna E. Borodaeva Kaili Rimfeld Nikolas G. Shakeshaf Margherita Malanchini Sergey B. Malykh Comparing Spatial Ability of Male and Female Students Completing Humanities vs. Technical Degrees Psychology in Russia: State of Art Spatial ability (SA) degree (feld of study) gender diferences individual differences STEM |
author_facet |
Elena A. Esipenko Ekaterina P. Maslennikova Anna V. Budakova Kseniya R. Sharafeva Viсtoria I. Ismatullina Inna V. Feklicheva Nadezhda A. Chipeeva Elena L. Soldatova Zhanna E. Borodaeva Kaili Rimfeld Nikolas G. Shakeshaf Margherita Malanchini Sergey B. Malykh |
author_sort |
Elena A. Esipenko |
title |
Comparing Spatial Ability of Male and Female Students Completing Humanities vs. Technical Degrees |
title_short |
Comparing Spatial Ability of Male and Female Students Completing Humanities vs. Technical Degrees |
title_full |
Comparing Spatial Ability of Male and Female Students Completing Humanities vs. Technical Degrees |
title_fullStr |
Comparing Spatial Ability of Male and Female Students Completing Humanities vs. Technical Degrees |
title_full_unstemmed |
Comparing Spatial Ability of Male and Female Students Completing Humanities vs. Technical Degrees |
title_sort |
comparing spatial ability of male and female students completing humanities vs. technical degrees |
publisher |
M.V. Lomonosov Moscow State University |
series |
Psychology in Russia: State of Art |
issn |
2074-6857 2307-2202 |
publishDate |
2018-12-01 |
description |
Background. Spatial ability (SA) has long been the focus of research in psychology, because it is associated with performance in science, technologies, engineering, and mathematics (STEM). Research has shown that males consistently outperform females in most aspects of SA, which may partially explain the observed overrepresentation of male students seeking STEM degrees.
Objective. Tis study examines sex and feld of study (degree) diferences in diferent aspects of spatial ability and its structure.
Design. We assessed SA by using an on-line gamifed battery, which included 10 spatial tests capturing 10 dimensions of spatial ability, among which were mental rotation, spatial visualization, spatial scanning, spatial reasoning, perspective-taking, and
mechanical reasoning. Te sample consisted of 882 STEM (55% males) and Humanities (20% males) university students in Russia.
Results. Males outperformed females on all assessed components of SA with a small efect size (1–11%). We also found that students from STEM felds outperformed Humanities students on all SA subtests (efect size ranged from 0.2 to 7%). Tese diferences
by study choice were not fully explained by the observed over-representation of males in the STEM group. Te results of the study suggested no interaction between sex and degree. In other words, on average, males outperformed females, irrespective of whether
they were STEM or humanities students; and the STEM advantage was observed for both males and females. Te same unifactorial structure of SA was observed in the STEM and
Humanities groups.
Conclusion. Our results are consistent with previous research, suggesting sex and study feld diferences in SA. Longitudinal research is needed to explore the causal mechanisms underscoring these diferences. |
topic |
Spatial ability (SA) degree (feld of study) gender diferences individual differences STEM |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT elenaaesipenko comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT ekaterinapmaslennikova comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT annavbudakova comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT kseniyarsharafeva comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT vistoriaiismatullina comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT innavfeklicheva comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT nadezhdaachipeeva comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT elenalsoldatova comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT zhannaeborodaeva comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT kailirimfeld comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT nikolasgshakeshaf comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT margheritamalanchini comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees AT sergeybmalykh comparingspatialabilityofmaleandfemalestudentscompletinghumanitiesvstechnicaldegrees |
_version_ |
1724791757760102400 |