Visual and radiographic caries detection: a tailored meta-analysis for two different settings, Egypt and Germany
Abstract Background Diagnostic meta-analyses on caries detection methods should assist practitioners in their daily practice. However, conventional meta-analysis estimates may be inapplicable due to differences in test conduct, applied thresholds and assessed population between settings. Our aim was...
Main Authors: | , , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
BMC
2018-06-01
|
Series: | BMC Oral Health |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12903-018-0561-z |
id |
doaj-57d014d0741f42f490c19a8ccde033d0 |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-57d014d0741f42f490c19a8ccde033d02020-11-25T01:15:05ZengBMCBMC Oral Health1472-68312018-06-011811910.1186/s12903-018-0561-zVisual and radiographic caries detection: a tailored meta-analysis for two different settings, Egypt and GermanyFalk Schwendicke0Karim Elhennawy1Osama El Shahawy2Reham Maher3Thais Gimenez4Fausto M. Mendes5Brian H. Willis6Department of Operative and Preventive Dentistry, Charité – Universitätsmedizin BerlinDepartment of Operative and Preventive Dentistry, Charité – Universitätsmedizin BerlinDepartment of Pediatric Dentistry, Cairo UniversityDepartment of Pediatric Dentistry, Cairo UniversityDepartment of Pediatric Dentistry, School of Dentistry, University of São PauloDepartment of Pediatric Dentistry, School of Dentistry, University of São PauloInstitute of Applied Health Research, University of BirminghamAbstract Background Diagnostic meta-analyses on caries detection methods should assist practitioners in their daily practice. However, conventional meta-analysis estimates may be inapplicable due to differences in test conduct, applied thresholds and assessed population between settings. Our aim was to demonstrate the impact of tailored meta-analysis of visual and radiographic caries detection to different settings using setting-specific routine data. Methods Published systematic reviews and meta-analyses on the accuracy of visual and radiographic caries detection were used. In two settings (a private practice in Germany and a public health clinic in Egypt), routine data of a total of 100 (n = 50/practice) consecutive 12–14 year-olds were collected. Test-positive rates of visual and radiographic detection for initial and advanced carious lesions on occlusal or proximal surfaces of molars were used to tailor meta-analyses. If prevalence data were available, these were also used for tailoring. Results From the original reviews, 210 and 100 heterogeneous studies on visual and radiographic caries detection were included in our meta-analyses. For radiographic detection, sensitivity and specificity estimates derived from conventional and tailored meta-analysis were similar. For visual detection of advanced occlusal carious lesions, the conventional meta-analysis yielded a sensitivity and specificity (95% CI) of 64.6% (57–71) and 90.9% (88–93), whereas the tailored estimates for Egypt were 75.1% (70–81) and 84.9% (82–89), respectively, and 43.7% (37–51) and 96.5% (95–97) for Germany, respectively. Conclusion Conventional test accuracy meta-analyses may yield aggregate estimates which are inapplicable to specific settings. Routine data may be used to produce a meta-analysis estimate which is tailored to the setting and thereby improving its applicability.http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12903-018-0561-zCaries detectionDecision makingDiagnostic accuracy studiesEvidence-based dentistryMedical informatics |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Falk Schwendicke Karim Elhennawy Osama El Shahawy Reham Maher Thais Gimenez Fausto M. Mendes Brian H. Willis |
spellingShingle |
Falk Schwendicke Karim Elhennawy Osama El Shahawy Reham Maher Thais Gimenez Fausto M. Mendes Brian H. Willis Visual and radiographic caries detection: a tailored meta-analysis for two different settings, Egypt and Germany BMC Oral Health Caries detection Decision making Diagnostic accuracy studies Evidence-based dentistry Medical informatics |
author_facet |
Falk Schwendicke Karim Elhennawy Osama El Shahawy Reham Maher Thais Gimenez Fausto M. Mendes Brian H. Willis |
author_sort |
Falk Schwendicke |
title |
Visual and radiographic caries detection: a tailored meta-analysis for two different settings, Egypt and Germany |
title_short |
Visual and radiographic caries detection: a tailored meta-analysis for two different settings, Egypt and Germany |
title_full |
Visual and radiographic caries detection: a tailored meta-analysis for two different settings, Egypt and Germany |
title_fullStr |
Visual and radiographic caries detection: a tailored meta-analysis for two different settings, Egypt and Germany |
title_full_unstemmed |
Visual and radiographic caries detection: a tailored meta-analysis for two different settings, Egypt and Germany |
title_sort |
visual and radiographic caries detection: a tailored meta-analysis for two different settings, egypt and germany |
publisher |
BMC |
series |
BMC Oral Health |
issn |
1472-6831 |
publishDate |
2018-06-01 |
description |
Abstract Background Diagnostic meta-analyses on caries detection methods should assist practitioners in their daily practice. However, conventional meta-analysis estimates may be inapplicable due to differences in test conduct, applied thresholds and assessed population between settings. Our aim was to demonstrate the impact of tailored meta-analysis of visual and radiographic caries detection to different settings using setting-specific routine data. Methods Published systematic reviews and meta-analyses on the accuracy of visual and radiographic caries detection were used. In two settings (a private practice in Germany and a public health clinic in Egypt), routine data of a total of 100 (n = 50/practice) consecutive 12–14 year-olds were collected. Test-positive rates of visual and radiographic detection for initial and advanced carious lesions on occlusal or proximal surfaces of molars were used to tailor meta-analyses. If prevalence data were available, these were also used for tailoring. Results From the original reviews, 210 and 100 heterogeneous studies on visual and radiographic caries detection were included in our meta-analyses. For radiographic detection, sensitivity and specificity estimates derived from conventional and tailored meta-analysis were similar. For visual detection of advanced occlusal carious lesions, the conventional meta-analysis yielded a sensitivity and specificity (95% CI) of 64.6% (57–71) and 90.9% (88–93), whereas the tailored estimates for Egypt were 75.1% (70–81) and 84.9% (82–89), respectively, and 43.7% (37–51) and 96.5% (95–97) for Germany, respectively. Conclusion Conventional test accuracy meta-analyses may yield aggregate estimates which are inapplicable to specific settings. Routine data may be used to produce a meta-analysis estimate which is tailored to the setting and thereby improving its applicability. |
topic |
Caries detection Decision making Diagnostic accuracy studies Evidence-based dentistry Medical informatics |
url |
http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12903-018-0561-z |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT falkschwendicke visualandradiographiccariesdetectionatailoredmetaanalysisfortwodifferentsettingsegyptandgermany AT karimelhennawy visualandradiographiccariesdetectionatailoredmetaanalysisfortwodifferentsettingsegyptandgermany AT osamaelshahawy visualandradiographiccariesdetectionatailoredmetaanalysisfortwodifferentsettingsegyptandgermany AT rehammaher visualandradiographiccariesdetectionatailoredmetaanalysisfortwodifferentsettingsegyptandgermany AT thaisgimenez visualandradiographiccariesdetectionatailoredmetaanalysisfortwodifferentsettingsegyptandgermany AT faustommendes visualandradiographiccariesdetectionatailoredmetaanalysisfortwodifferentsettingsegyptandgermany AT brianhwillis visualandradiographiccariesdetectionatailoredmetaanalysisfortwodifferentsettingsegyptandgermany |
_version_ |
1725154544070950912 |