Estimating Land Use and Land Cover Change in North Central Georgia: Can Remote Sensing Observations Augment Traditional Forest Inventory Data?

Throughout the last three decades, north central Georgia has experienced significant loss in forest land and tree cover. This study revealed the temporal patterns and thematic transitions associated with this loss by augmenting traditional forest inventory data with remotely sensed observations. In...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Gretchen G. Moisen, Kelly S. McConville, Todd A. Schroeder, Sean P. Healey, Mark V. Finco, Tracey S. Frescino
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2020-08-01
Series:Forests
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/11/8/856
id doaj-a245cfaddd6948ec8ebc3c8ff97aff1c
record_format Article
spelling doaj-a245cfaddd6948ec8ebc3c8ff97aff1c2020-11-25T02:54:35ZengMDPI AGForests1999-49072020-08-011185685610.3390/f11080856Estimating Land Use and Land Cover Change in North Central Georgia: Can Remote Sensing Observations Augment Traditional Forest Inventory Data?Gretchen G. Moisen0Kelly S. McConville1Todd A. Schroeder2Sean P. Healey3Mark V. Finco4Tracey S. Frescino5USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Forest Inventory and Analysis, 507 25th Street, Ogden, UT 84401, USADepartment of Mathematics, Reed College, 3203 SE Woodstock Blvd, Portland, OR 97202, USAUSDA Forest Service, Southern Research Station, Forest Inventory and Analysis, 4700 Old Kingston Pike, Knoxville, TN 37919, USAUSDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Forest Inventory and Analysis, 507 25th Street, Ogden, UT 84401, USARedCastle Resources, Inc., Geospatial Technology and Applications Center, 125 South State Street, Suite 7105, Salt Lake City, UT 84138, USAUSDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Forest Inventory and Analysis, 507 25th Street, Ogden, UT 84401, USAThroughout the last three decades, north central Georgia has experienced significant loss in forest land and tree cover. This study revealed the temporal patterns and thematic transitions associated with this loss by augmenting traditional forest inventory data with remotely sensed observations. In the US, there is a network of field plots measured consistently through time from the USDA Forest Service’s Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) Program, serial photo-based observations collected through image-based change estimation (ICE) methodology, and historical Landsat-based observations collected through TimeSync. The objective here was to evaluate how these three data sources could be used to best estimate land use and land cover (LULC) change. Using data collected in north central Georgia, we compared agreement between the three data sets, assessed the ability of each to yield adequately precise and temporally coherent estimates of land class status as well as detect net and transitional change, and we evaluated the effectiveness of using remotely sensed data in an auxiliary capacity to improve detection of statistically significant changes. With the exception of land cover from FIA plots, agreement between paired data sets for land use and cover was nearly 85%, and estimates of land class proportion were not significantly different for overlapping time intervals. Only the long time series of TimeSync data revealed significant change when conducting analyses over five-year intervals and aggregated land categories. Using ICE and TimeSync data through a two-phase estimator improved precision in estimates but did not achieve temporal coherence. We also show analytically that using auxiliary remotely sensed data for post-stratification for binary responses must be based on maps that are extremely accurate in order to see gains in precision. We conclude that, in order to report LULC trends in north central Georgia with adequate precision and temporal coherence, we need data collected on all the FIA plots each year over a long time series and broadly collapsed LULC classes.https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/11/8/856forest trendsmodel-assisted estimationpost-stratificationimage-based change estimation (ICE)TimeSync
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Gretchen G. Moisen
Kelly S. McConville
Todd A. Schroeder
Sean P. Healey
Mark V. Finco
Tracey S. Frescino
spellingShingle Gretchen G. Moisen
Kelly S. McConville
Todd A. Schroeder
Sean P. Healey
Mark V. Finco
Tracey S. Frescino
Estimating Land Use and Land Cover Change in North Central Georgia: Can Remote Sensing Observations Augment Traditional Forest Inventory Data?
Forests
forest trends
model-assisted estimation
post-stratification
image-based change estimation (ICE)
TimeSync
author_facet Gretchen G. Moisen
Kelly S. McConville
Todd A. Schroeder
Sean P. Healey
Mark V. Finco
Tracey S. Frescino
author_sort Gretchen G. Moisen
title Estimating Land Use and Land Cover Change in North Central Georgia: Can Remote Sensing Observations Augment Traditional Forest Inventory Data?
title_short Estimating Land Use and Land Cover Change in North Central Georgia: Can Remote Sensing Observations Augment Traditional Forest Inventory Data?
title_full Estimating Land Use and Land Cover Change in North Central Georgia: Can Remote Sensing Observations Augment Traditional Forest Inventory Data?
title_fullStr Estimating Land Use and Land Cover Change in North Central Georgia: Can Remote Sensing Observations Augment Traditional Forest Inventory Data?
title_full_unstemmed Estimating Land Use and Land Cover Change in North Central Georgia: Can Remote Sensing Observations Augment Traditional Forest Inventory Data?
title_sort estimating land use and land cover change in north central georgia: can remote sensing observations augment traditional forest inventory data?
publisher MDPI AG
series Forests
issn 1999-4907
publishDate 2020-08-01
description Throughout the last three decades, north central Georgia has experienced significant loss in forest land and tree cover. This study revealed the temporal patterns and thematic transitions associated with this loss by augmenting traditional forest inventory data with remotely sensed observations. In the US, there is a network of field plots measured consistently through time from the USDA Forest Service’s Forest Inventory and Analysis (FIA) Program, serial photo-based observations collected through image-based change estimation (ICE) methodology, and historical Landsat-based observations collected through TimeSync. The objective here was to evaluate how these three data sources could be used to best estimate land use and land cover (LULC) change. Using data collected in north central Georgia, we compared agreement between the three data sets, assessed the ability of each to yield adequately precise and temporally coherent estimates of land class status as well as detect net and transitional change, and we evaluated the effectiveness of using remotely sensed data in an auxiliary capacity to improve detection of statistically significant changes. With the exception of land cover from FIA plots, agreement between paired data sets for land use and cover was nearly 85%, and estimates of land class proportion were not significantly different for overlapping time intervals. Only the long time series of TimeSync data revealed significant change when conducting analyses over five-year intervals and aggregated land categories. Using ICE and TimeSync data through a two-phase estimator improved precision in estimates but did not achieve temporal coherence. We also show analytically that using auxiliary remotely sensed data for post-stratification for binary responses must be based on maps that are extremely accurate in order to see gains in precision. We conclude that, in order to report LULC trends in north central Georgia with adequate precision and temporal coherence, we need data collected on all the FIA plots each year over a long time series and broadly collapsed LULC classes.
topic forest trends
model-assisted estimation
post-stratification
image-based change estimation (ICE)
TimeSync
url https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4907/11/8/856
work_keys_str_mv AT gretchengmoisen estimatinglanduseandlandcoverchangeinnorthcentralgeorgiacanremotesensingobservationsaugmenttraditionalforestinventorydata
AT kellysmcconville estimatinglanduseandlandcoverchangeinnorthcentralgeorgiacanremotesensingobservationsaugmenttraditionalforestinventorydata
AT toddaschroeder estimatinglanduseandlandcoverchangeinnorthcentralgeorgiacanremotesensingobservationsaugmenttraditionalforestinventorydata
AT seanphealey estimatinglanduseandlandcoverchangeinnorthcentralgeorgiacanremotesensingobservationsaugmenttraditionalforestinventorydata
AT markvfinco estimatinglanduseandlandcoverchangeinnorthcentralgeorgiacanremotesensingobservationsaugmenttraditionalforestinventorydata
AT traceysfrescino estimatinglanduseandlandcoverchangeinnorthcentralgeorgiacanremotesensingobservationsaugmenttraditionalforestinventorydata
_version_ 1724720155072659456