An image-based assay to quantify changes in proliferation and viability upon drug treatment in 3D microenvironments

Abstract Background Every biological experiment requires a choice of throughput balanced against physiological relevance. Most primary drug screens neglect critical parameters such as microenvironmental conditions, cell-cell heterogeneity, and specific readouts of cell fate for the sake of throughpu...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Vasanth S. Murali, Bo-Jui Chang, Reto Fiolka, Gaudenz Danuser, Murat Can Cobanoglu, Erik S. Welf
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: BMC 2019-05-01
Series:BMC Cancer
Subjects:
Online Access:http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12885-019-5694-1
id doaj-ce01fffca20842278247ccf00a0ded08
record_format Article
spelling doaj-ce01fffca20842278247ccf00a0ded082020-11-25T03:26:55ZengBMCBMC Cancer1471-24072019-05-0119111710.1186/s12885-019-5694-1An image-based assay to quantify changes in proliferation and viability upon drug treatment in 3D microenvironmentsVasanth S. Murali0Bo-Jui Chang1Reto Fiolka2Gaudenz Danuser3Murat Can Cobanoglu4Erik S. Welf5Department of Cell Biology, UT Southwestern Medical CenterDepartment of Cell Biology, UT Southwestern Medical CenterDepartment of Cell Biology, UT Southwestern Medical CenterDepartment of Cell Biology, UT Southwestern Medical CenterLyda Hill Department of Bioinformatics, UT Southwestern Medical CenterDepartment of Cell Biology, UT Southwestern Medical CenterAbstract Background Every biological experiment requires a choice of throughput balanced against physiological relevance. Most primary drug screens neglect critical parameters such as microenvironmental conditions, cell-cell heterogeneity, and specific readouts of cell fate for the sake of throughput. Methods Here we describe a methodology to quantify proliferation and viability of single cells in 3D culture conditions by leveraging automated microscopy and image analysis to facilitate reliable and high-throughput measurements. We detail experimental conditions that can be adjusted to increase either throughput or robustness of the assay, and we provide a stand alone image analysis program for users who wish to implement this 3D drug screening assay in high throughput. Results We demonstrate this approach by evaluating a combination of RAF and MEK inhibitors on melanoma cells, showing that cells cultured in 3D collagen-based matrices are more sensitive than cells grown in 2D culture, and that cell proliferation is much more sensitive than cell viability. We also find that cells grown in 3D cultured spheroids exhibit equivalent sensitivity to single cells grown in 3D collagen, suggesting that for the case of melanoma, a 3D single cell model may be equally effective for drug identification as 3D spheroids models. The single cell resolution of this approach enables stratification of heterogeneous populations of cells into differentially responsive subtypes upon drug treatment, which we demonstrate by determining the effect of RAK/MEK inhibition on melanoma cells co-cultured with fibroblasts. Furthermore, we show that spheroids grown from single cells exhibit dramatic heterogeneity to drug response, suggesting that heritable drug resistance can arise stochastically in single cells but be retained by subsequent generations. Conclusion In summary, image-based analysis renders cell fate detection robust, sensitive, and high-throughput, enabling cell fate evaluation of single cells in more complex microenvironmental conditions.http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12885-019-5694-1Drug screenHigh throughputImage analysisSpheroidOrganoidCell fate
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Vasanth S. Murali
Bo-Jui Chang
Reto Fiolka
Gaudenz Danuser
Murat Can Cobanoglu
Erik S. Welf
spellingShingle Vasanth S. Murali
Bo-Jui Chang
Reto Fiolka
Gaudenz Danuser
Murat Can Cobanoglu
Erik S. Welf
An image-based assay to quantify changes in proliferation and viability upon drug treatment in 3D microenvironments
BMC Cancer
Drug screen
High throughput
Image analysis
Spheroid
Organoid
Cell fate
author_facet Vasanth S. Murali
Bo-Jui Chang
Reto Fiolka
Gaudenz Danuser
Murat Can Cobanoglu
Erik S. Welf
author_sort Vasanth S. Murali
title An image-based assay to quantify changes in proliferation and viability upon drug treatment in 3D microenvironments
title_short An image-based assay to quantify changes in proliferation and viability upon drug treatment in 3D microenvironments
title_full An image-based assay to quantify changes in proliferation and viability upon drug treatment in 3D microenvironments
title_fullStr An image-based assay to quantify changes in proliferation and viability upon drug treatment in 3D microenvironments
title_full_unstemmed An image-based assay to quantify changes in proliferation and viability upon drug treatment in 3D microenvironments
title_sort image-based assay to quantify changes in proliferation and viability upon drug treatment in 3d microenvironments
publisher BMC
series BMC Cancer
issn 1471-2407
publishDate 2019-05-01
description Abstract Background Every biological experiment requires a choice of throughput balanced against physiological relevance. Most primary drug screens neglect critical parameters such as microenvironmental conditions, cell-cell heterogeneity, and specific readouts of cell fate for the sake of throughput. Methods Here we describe a methodology to quantify proliferation and viability of single cells in 3D culture conditions by leveraging automated microscopy and image analysis to facilitate reliable and high-throughput measurements. We detail experimental conditions that can be adjusted to increase either throughput or robustness of the assay, and we provide a stand alone image analysis program for users who wish to implement this 3D drug screening assay in high throughput. Results We demonstrate this approach by evaluating a combination of RAF and MEK inhibitors on melanoma cells, showing that cells cultured in 3D collagen-based matrices are more sensitive than cells grown in 2D culture, and that cell proliferation is much more sensitive than cell viability. We also find that cells grown in 3D cultured spheroids exhibit equivalent sensitivity to single cells grown in 3D collagen, suggesting that for the case of melanoma, a 3D single cell model may be equally effective for drug identification as 3D spheroids models. The single cell resolution of this approach enables stratification of heterogeneous populations of cells into differentially responsive subtypes upon drug treatment, which we demonstrate by determining the effect of RAK/MEK inhibition on melanoma cells co-cultured with fibroblasts. Furthermore, we show that spheroids grown from single cells exhibit dramatic heterogeneity to drug response, suggesting that heritable drug resistance can arise stochastically in single cells but be retained by subsequent generations. Conclusion In summary, image-based analysis renders cell fate detection robust, sensitive, and high-throughput, enabling cell fate evaluation of single cells in more complex microenvironmental conditions.
topic Drug screen
High throughput
Image analysis
Spheroid
Organoid
Cell fate
url http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12885-019-5694-1
work_keys_str_mv AT vasanthsmurali animagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT bojuichang animagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT retofiolka animagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT gaudenzdanuser animagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT muratcancobanoglu animagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT erikswelf animagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT vasanthsmurali imagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT bojuichang imagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT retofiolka imagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT gaudenzdanuser imagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT muratcancobanoglu imagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
AT erikswelf imagebasedassaytoquantifychangesinproliferationandviabilityupondrugtreatmentin3dmicroenvironments
_version_ 1724590488819859456