A Lymph Node Staging System for Gastric Cancer: A Hybrid Type Based on Topographic and Numeric Systems.

Although changing a lymph node staging system from an anatomically based system to a numerically based system in gastric cancer offers better prognostic performance, several problems can arise: it does not offer information on the anatomical extent of disease and cannot represent the extent of lymph...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:PLoS ONE
Main Authors: Yoon Young Choi, Ji Yeong An, Hitoshi Katai, Yasuyuki Seto, Takeo Fukagawa, Yasuhiro Okumura, Dong Wook Kim, Hyoung-Il Kim, Jae-Ho Cheong, Woo Jin Hyung, Sung Hoon Noh
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2016-01-01
Online Access:https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0149555&type=printable
_version_ 1849484718236499968
author Yoon Young Choi
Ji Yeong An
Hitoshi Katai
Yasuyuki Seto
Takeo Fukagawa
Yasuhiro Okumura
Dong Wook Kim
Hyoung-Il Kim
Jae-Ho Cheong
Woo Jin Hyung
Sung Hoon Noh
author_facet Yoon Young Choi
Ji Yeong An
Hitoshi Katai
Yasuyuki Seto
Takeo Fukagawa
Yasuhiro Okumura
Dong Wook Kim
Hyoung-Il Kim
Jae-Ho Cheong
Woo Jin Hyung
Sung Hoon Noh
author_sort Yoon Young Choi
collection DOAJ
container_title PLoS ONE
description Although changing a lymph node staging system from an anatomically based system to a numerically based system in gastric cancer offers better prognostic performance, several problems can arise: it does not offer information on the anatomical extent of disease and cannot represent the extent of lymph node dissection. The purpose of this study was to discover an alternative lymph node staging system for gastric cancer. Data from 6025 patients who underwent gastrectomy for primary gastric cancer between January 2000 and December 2010 were reviewed. The lymph node groups were reclassified into lesser-curvature, greater-curvature, and extra-perigastric groups. Presence of any metastatic lymph node in one group was considered positive. Lymph node groups were further stratified into four (new N0-new N3) according to the number of positive lymph node groups. Survival outcomes with this new N staging were compared with those of the current TNM system. For validation, two centers in Japan (large center, n = 3443; medium center, n = 560) were invited. Even among the same pN stages, the more advanced new N stage showed worse prognosis, indicating that the anatomical extent of metastatic lymph nodes is important. The prognostic performance of the new staging system was as good as that of the current TNM system for overall advanced gastric cancer as well as lymph node-positive gastric cancer (Harrell C-index was 0.799, 0.726, and 0.703 in current TNM and 0.799, 0.727, and 0.703 in new TNM stage). Validation sets supported these outcomes. The new N staging system demonstrated prognostic performance equal to that of the current TNM system and could thus be used as an alternative.
format Article
id doaj-art-059d28122b4e4e27873fa46594f01a79
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 1932-6203
language English
publishDate 2016-01-01
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-059d28122b4e4e27873fa46594f01a792025-08-20T03:10:59ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032016-01-01113e014955510.1371/journal.pone.0149555A Lymph Node Staging System for Gastric Cancer: A Hybrid Type Based on Topographic and Numeric Systems.Yoon Young ChoiJi Yeong AnHitoshi KataiYasuyuki SetoTakeo FukagawaYasuhiro OkumuraDong Wook KimHyoung-Il KimJae-Ho CheongWoo Jin HyungSung Hoon NohAlthough changing a lymph node staging system from an anatomically based system to a numerically based system in gastric cancer offers better prognostic performance, several problems can arise: it does not offer information on the anatomical extent of disease and cannot represent the extent of lymph node dissection. The purpose of this study was to discover an alternative lymph node staging system for gastric cancer. Data from 6025 patients who underwent gastrectomy for primary gastric cancer between January 2000 and December 2010 were reviewed. The lymph node groups were reclassified into lesser-curvature, greater-curvature, and extra-perigastric groups. Presence of any metastatic lymph node in one group was considered positive. Lymph node groups were further stratified into four (new N0-new N3) according to the number of positive lymph node groups. Survival outcomes with this new N staging were compared with those of the current TNM system. For validation, two centers in Japan (large center, n = 3443; medium center, n = 560) were invited. Even among the same pN stages, the more advanced new N stage showed worse prognosis, indicating that the anatomical extent of metastatic lymph nodes is important. The prognostic performance of the new staging system was as good as that of the current TNM system for overall advanced gastric cancer as well as lymph node-positive gastric cancer (Harrell C-index was 0.799, 0.726, and 0.703 in current TNM and 0.799, 0.727, and 0.703 in new TNM stage). Validation sets supported these outcomes. The new N staging system demonstrated prognostic performance equal to that of the current TNM system and could thus be used as an alternative.https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0149555&type=printable
spellingShingle Yoon Young Choi
Ji Yeong An
Hitoshi Katai
Yasuyuki Seto
Takeo Fukagawa
Yasuhiro Okumura
Dong Wook Kim
Hyoung-Il Kim
Jae-Ho Cheong
Woo Jin Hyung
Sung Hoon Noh
A Lymph Node Staging System for Gastric Cancer: A Hybrid Type Based on Topographic and Numeric Systems.
title A Lymph Node Staging System for Gastric Cancer: A Hybrid Type Based on Topographic and Numeric Systems.
title_full A Lymph Node Staging System for Gastric Cancer: A Hybrid Type Based on Topographic and Numeric Systems.
title_fullStr A Lymph Node Staging System for Gastric Cancer: A Hybrid Type Based on Topographic and Numeric Systems.
title_full_unstemmed A Lymph Node Staging System for Gastric Cancer: A Hybrid Type Based on Topographic and Numeric Systems.
title_short A Lymph Node Staging System for Gastric Cancer: A Hybrid Type Based on Topographic and Numeric Systems.
title_sort lymph node staging system for gastric cancer a hybrid type based on topographic and numeric systems
url https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/file?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0149555&type=printable
work_keys_str_mv AT yoonyoungchoi alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT jiyeongan alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT hitoshikatai alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT yasuyukiseto alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT takeofukagawa alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT yasuhirookumura alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT dongwookkim alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT hyoungilkim alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT jaehocheong alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT woojinhyung alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT sunghoonnoh alymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT yoonyoungchoi lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT jiyeongan lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT hitoshikatai lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT yasuyukiseto lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT takeofukagawa lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT yasuhirookumura lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT dongwookkim lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT hyoungilkim lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT jaehocheong lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT woojinhyung lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems
AT sunghoonnoh lymphnodestagingsystemforgastriccancerahybridtypebasedontopographicandnumericsystems