Patients’ Perspectives towards Bedside Teaching of Medical Students: an Analytical Cross Sectional Study in Tertiary Care Hospitals

Objective: To determine patients’ perspectives about medical students’ involvement in bedside teachings and its effect on the quality of consultation.   Study Design and setting: An analytical cross-sectional study conducted in Combined Military and Pak Emirates Military Hospital Rawalpindi fr...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Journal of Bahria University Medical and Dental College
Main Authors: Samreen Misbah, Maryam Shakeel, Aleena Mazhar, Hamza Jamshaid, Asad Tariq, Sagheer Ahmad
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Bahria Univerisy Health Sciences, Campus Karachi 2024-01-01
Subjects:
Online Access:https://jbumdc.bahria.edu.pk/index.php/ojs/article/view/1354
_version_ 1849840464952295424
author Samreen Misbah
Maryam Shakeel
Aleena Mazhar
Hamza Jamshaid
Asad Tariq
Sagheer Ahmad
author_facet Samreen Misbah
Maryam Shakeel
Aleena Mazhar
Hamza Jamshaid
Asad Tariq
Sagheer Ahmad
author_sort Samreen Misbah
collection DOAJ
container_title Journal of Bahria University Medical and Dental College
description Objective: To determine patients’ perspectives about medical students’ involvement in bedside teachings and its effect on the quality of consultation.   Study Design and setting: An analytical cross-sectional study conducted in Combined Military and Pak Emirates Military Hospital Rawalpindi from 1-September-2019, to 1-April-2020.   Methodology: Data were collected by convenience sampling using self-structured questionnaire. With a response rate of 91%, sample of 294 from medicine and surgery departments were included who had or not consultations in presence of students, excluding patients with decreased mental functioning. Kruskal-wallis and Mann-Whitney-U tests were applied to compare mean scores considering statistically significant difference at <0.05.   Results: Among participants (mean age 30.8 ± 8.51) almost 138(47%) patients thought benefitted interaction with students, 191(65%) expressed disagreement to discomfort during history, which decreased towards discussing sensitive information and examination in absence of senior. Among seven domains of questionnaire, positive attitude towards students and preference of local language received the highest mean score, discomfort during the examination and students’ acceptability received the lowest. A significant difference was found among participants with higher education regarding permission for students’ presence (p-value 0.009).   Conclusion: Majority of participants considered students’ interaction beneficial, but shared discomfort feeling during examination. Students’ involvement was considered imperative for their training, thinking that they are serving the community. Participants with high education reflected upon permission prior to encounter and those with less education shared that all discussion in their presence must be in understandable language
format Article
id doaj-art-259928b5bcea42e7bf5644d4eacf8750
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 2220-7562
2617-9482
language English
publishDate 2024-01-01
publisher Bahria Univerisy Health Sciences, Campus Karachi
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-259928b5bcea42e7bf5644d4eacf87502025-08-20T01:23:01ZengBahria Univerisy Health Sciences, Campus KarachiJournal of Bahria University Medical and Dental College2220-75622617-94822024-01-011401727710.51985/JBUMDC20232641354Patients’ Perspectives towards Bedside Teaching of Medical Students: an Analytical Cross Sectional Study in Tertiary Care HospitalsSamreen MisbahMaryam ShakeelAleena MazharHamza JamshaidAsad TariqSagheer AhmadObjective: To determine patients’ perspectives about medical students’ involvement in bedside teachings and its effect on the quality of consultation.   Study Design and setting: An analytical cross-sectional study conducted in Combined Military and Pak Emirates Military Hospital Rawalpindi from 1-September-2019, to 1-April-2020.   Methodology: Data were collected by convenience sampling using self-structured questionnaire. With a response rate of 91%, sample of 294 from medicine and surgery departments were included who had or not consultations in presence of students, excluding patients with decreased mental functioning. Kruskal-wallis and Mann-Whitney-U tests were applied to compare mean scores considering statistically significant difference at <0.05.   Results: Among participants (mean age 30.8 ± 8.51) almost 138(47%) patients thought benefitted interaction with students, 191(65%) expressed disagreement to discomfort during history, which decreased towards discussing sensitive information and examination in absence of senior. Among seven domains of questionnaire, positive attitude towards students and preference of local language received the highest mean score, discomfort during the examination and students’ acceptability received the lowest. A significant difference was found among participants with higher education regarding permission for students’ presence (p-value 0.009).   Conclusion: Majority of participants considered students’ interaction beneficial, but shared discomfort feeling during examination. Students’ involvement was considered imperative for their training, thinking that they are serving the community. Participants with high education reflected upon permission prior to encounter and those with less education shared that all discussion in their presence must be in understandable languagehttps://jbumdc.bahria.edu.pk/index.php/ojs/article/view/1354cross-sectional studies, hospitals, humans, medical, students, surveys and questionnaires
spellingShingle Samreen Misbah
Maryam Shakeel
Aleena Mazhar
Hamza Jamshaid
Asad Tariq
Sagheer Ahmad
Patients’ Perspectives towards Bedside Teaching of Medical Students: an Analytical Cross Sectional Study in Tertiary Care Hospitals
cross-sectional studies, hospitals, humans, medical, students, surveys and questionnaires
title Patients’ Perspectives towards Bedside Teaching of Medical Students: an Analytical Cross Sectional Study in Tertiary Care Hospitals
title_full Patients’ Perspectives towards Bedside Teaching of Medical Students: an Analytical Cross Sectional Study in Tertiary Care Hospitals
title_fullStr Patients’ Perspectives towards Bedside Teaching of Medical Students: an Analytical Cross Sectional Study in Tertiary Care Hospitals
title_full_unstemmed Patients’ Perspectives towards Bedside Teaching of Medical Students: an Analytical Cross Sectional Study in Tertiary Care Hospitals
title_short Patients’ Perspectives towards Bedside Teaching of Medical Students: an Analytical Cross Sectional Study in Tertiary Care Hospitals
title_sort patients perspectives towards bedside teaching of medical students an analytical cross sectional study in tertiary care hospitals
topic cross-sectional studies, hospitals, humans, medical, students, surveys and questionnaires
url https://jbumdc.bahria.edu.pk/index.php/ojs/article/view/1354
work_keys_str_mv AT samreenmisbah patientsperspectivestowardsbedsideteachingofmedicalstudentsananalyticalcrosssectionalstudyintertiarycarehospitals
AT maryamshakeel patientsperspectivestowardsbedsideteachingofmedicalstudentsananalyticalcrosssectionalstudyintertiarycarehospitals
AT aleenamazhar patientsperspectivestowardsbedsideteachingofmedicalstudentsananalyticalcrosssectionalstudyintertiarycarehospitals
AT hamzajamshaid patientsperspectivestowardsbedsideteachingofmedicalstudentsananalyticalcrosssectionalstudyintertiarycarehospitals
AT asadtariq patientsperspectivestowardsbedsideteachingofmedicalstudentsananalyticalcrosssectionalstudyintertiarycarehospitals
AT sagheerahmad patientsperspectivestowardsbedsideteachingofmedicalstudentsananalyticalcrosssectionalstudyintertiarycarehospitals