Feedback sources in essay writing: peer-generated or AI-generated feedback?

Abstract Peer feedback is introduced as an effective learning strategy, especially in large-size classes where teachers face high workloads. However, for complex tasks such as writing an argumentative essay, without support peers may not provide high-quality feedback since it requires a high level o...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:	International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education
Main Authors:	Seyyed Kazem Banihashem, Nafiseh Taghizadeh Kerman, Omid Noroozi, Jewoong Moon, Hendrik Drachsler
Format:	Article
Language:	English
Published:	SpringerOpen 2024-04-01
Subjects:	AI-generated feedback ChatGPT Essay writing Feedback sources Higher education Peer feedback
Online Access:	https://doi.org/10.1186/s41239-024-00455-4

Similar Items

The Impact of Using ChatGPT and Grammarly on developing Iraqi EFL University Students' Academic Essay Writing
by: اسوان جاسم
Published: (2025-06-01)

UTILIZING PEER AND TEACHER FEEDBACK IN ACADEMIC WRITING CLASS
by: Taufiqulloh, et al.
Published: (2016-06-01)

Comparing ChatGPT Feedback and Peer Feedback in Shaping Students’ Evaluative Judgement of Statistical Analysis: A Case Study
by: Xiao Xie, et al.
Published: (2025-06-01)

Evaluating ChatGPT in Generating Feedback on Content and Organization Components of EFL Compare and Contrast Essays
by: Berkan Çelik, et al.
Published: (2024-12-01)

Focus and Effects of Peer and Machine Feedback on Chinese University EFL Learners’ Revisions of English Argumentative Essays
by: Meihua Liu
Published: (2021-01-01)

The value of GenAI for peer feedback provision: student perceptions and impacts
by: Omid Noroozi, et al.
Published: (2025-10-01)

How well can GenAI (GPT-4) provide written corrective feedback on English-language learners’ writing?
by: Austin Pack, et al.
Published: (2025-03-01)

MD Student Perceptions of ChatGPT for Reflective Writing Feedback in Undergraduate Medical Education
by: Nabil Haider, et al.
Published: (2025-07-01)

ChatGPT, Bard, Bing Chat, and Claude generate feedback for Chinese as foreign language writing: A comparative case study
by: Saleh Obaidoon, et al.
Published: (2024-09-01)

Synergizing collaborative writing and AI feedback: An investigation into enhancing L2 writing proficiency in wiki-based environments
by: Watcharapol Wiboolyasarin, et al.
Published: (2024-06-01)

STUDENTS’ PERCEPTIONS ON THE USE OF PAPERRATER FOR ESSAY WRITING FEEDBACK
by: Rohiidah Salsabila, et al.
Published: (2025-06-01)

Understanding the Difference Between Self-Feedback and Peer Feedback: A Comparative Study of Their Effects on Undergraduate Students' Writing Improvement
by: Qi Lu, et al.
Published: (2021-09-01)

STUDENTS’ PERCEPTIONS OF THEIR REFLECTIVE ESSAY WRITING EXPERIENCE AND TEACHER FEEDBACK COMMENTS
by: Asiah Mohd Sharif, et al.
Published: (2017-01-01)

Single online self-compassion writing intervention reduces anxiety: With the feedback of ChatGPT
by: Tomoko Kishimoto, et al.
Published: (2025-03-01)

From red ink to algorithms: investigating the use of large language models in academic writing feedback
by: Marina Jovic, et al.
Published: (2025-10-01)

Same assignment—two different feedback contexts: lower secondary students’ experiences with feedback during a three draft writing process
by: Synnøve Heggedal Moltudal, et al.
Published: (2025-03-01)

Impact of ChatGPT on ESL students’ academic writing skills: a mixed methods intervention study
by: Santosh Mahapatra
Published: (2024-02-01)

Using ChatGPT as an AWE tool: quality, precision, and accuracy of the feedback
by: Arsema Pérez Hernández
Published: (2025-09-01)

Editorial: Peer feedback in second/foreign language writing classrooms: educational psychology perspective
by: Xinghua Liu, et al.
Published: (2023-08-01)

Analyse des interactions d’apprenants de FLS avec ChatGPT pour la rétroaction corrective écrite
by: Taegan Holmes, et al.
Published: (2025-03-01)

Assessing the effect of giving and receiving written corrective feedback on improving L2 writing accuracy: does giving and receiving feedback have fair mutual benefit?
by: Afsar Rouhi, et al.
Published: (2020-07-01)

Turnitin peer feedback: controversial vs. non-controversial essays
by: Mohammed Abdullah Alharbi, et al.
Published: (2020-05-01)

The role and perception of peer and teacher feedback in multiple-draft feedback provision on foreign language learners’ writing
by: Blanka Pojslová
Published: (2024-04-01)

The Impact of Peer and Teacher Feedback Using Twitter on FFL Writing Class
by: Wulan Novita Haeriyati, et al.
Published: (2023-08-01)

The Role of Written Corrective Feedback in Enhancing Students’ Proficiency in Writing: Case of Second Year Students,University of Constantine 1
by: Amina ZEMIECHE
Published: (2018-12-01)

Feedback on feedback: Guiding student interpreter performance
by: Jieun Lee
Published: (2018-02-01)

Integrating Peer – Teacher Corrective Feedback in Writing Instruction in a Private Teachers College in Nagekeo – East Nusa Tenggara
by: Simon Petrus Kita Ngatu
Published: (2020-02-01)

Types and Nature of Oral Feedback Given by Teachers on Students’ Speech
by: Befikadu Lemma
Published: (2023-07-01)

Writing Feedback from a Research Perspective
by: Lilia Raitskaya, et al.
Published: (2022-12-01)

Valuing students’ mindsets in essay compositions: Active learning and feedback approaches
by: Aisah Apridayani, et al.
Published: (2025-01-01)

Adopting ChatGPT as a writing buddy in the advanced L2 writing class
by: Carola Strobl, et al.
Published: (2024-03-01)

The Effects of Classroom Peer-feedback on Advanced Students' Self- Confidence
by: Sara Feyli, et al.
Published: (2016-03-01)

Do teachers spot AI? Evaluating the detectability of AI-generated texts among student essays
by: Johanna Fleckenstein, et al.
Published: (2024-06-01)

Unheard and unused: why students reject teacher and peer feedback
by: Anastasiya A. Lipnevich, et al.
Published: (2025-05-01)

A Systematic Literature Review of Online Peer Feedback: Uncovering the Current Situation in EFL Setting
by: Sibakhul Milad Malik Hidayatulloh
Published: (2025-01-01)

The Effect of Peer Feedback and Formative Feedback on the Design and Production of the Instructional Project
by: Mohammad Shahalizade, et al.
Published: (2019-09-01)

One-Class Learning for AI-Generated Essay Detection
by: Roberto Corizzo, et al.
Published: (2023-07-01)

Teacher Candidates’ Perceptions of Peer and Instructor Feedback Through Video Annotations: Whose Advice Do They Prefer?
by: Michael Otieno Okumu, et al.
Published: (2024-12-01)

Effects of explicit corrective feedback on writing skill: A private middle school example
by: Orhan Kocaman, et al.
Published: (2022-06-01)

The Effectiveness of Using Peer Feedback on Students’ Writing Descriptive Text
by: Rossawati wati
Published: (2021-10-01)