Linking a rapid throughput plate-assay with high-sensitivity stable-isotope label LCMS quantification permits the identification and characterisation of low β-L-ODAP grass pea lines

Abstract Background Grass pea (Lathyrus sativus) is an underutilised crop with high tolerance to drought and flooding stress and potential for maintaining food and nutritional security in the face of climate change. The presence of the neurotoxin β-L-oxalyl-2,3-diaminopropionic acid (β-L-ODAP) in ti...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:BMC Plant Biology
Main Authors: Peter M. F. Emmrich, Martin Rejzek, Lionel Hill, Paul Brett, Anne Edwards, Abhimanyu Sarkar, Rob A. Field, Cathie Martin, Trevor L. Wang
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: BMC 2019-11-01
Subjects:
Online Access:http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12870-019-2091-5
_version_ 1857087185231020032
author Peter M. F. Emmrich
Martin Rejzek
Lionel Hill
Paul Brett
Anne Edwards
Abhimanyu Sarkar
Rob A. Field
Cathie Martin
Trevor L. Wang
author_facet Peter M. F. Emmrich
Martin Rejzek
Lionel Hill
Paul Brett
Anne Edwards
Abhimanyu Sarkar
Rob A. Field
Cathie Martin
Trevor L. Wang
author_sort Peter M. F. Emmrich
collection DOAJ
container_title BMC Plant Biology
description Abstract Background Grass pea (Lathyrus sativus) is an underutilised crop with high tolerance to drought and flooding stress and potential for maintaining food and nutritional security in the face of climate change. The presence of the neurotoxin β-L-oxalyl-2,3-diaminopropionic acid (β-L-ODAP) in tissues of the plant has limited its adoption as a staple crop. To assist in the detection of material with very low neurotoxin toxin levels, we have developed two novel methods to assay ODAP. The first, a version of a widely used spectrophotometric assay, modified for increased throughput, permits rapid screening of large populations of germplasm for low toxin lines and the second is a novel, mass spectrometric procedure to detect very small quantities of ODAP for research purposes and characterisation of new varieties. Results A plate assay, based on an established spectrophotometric method enabling high-throughput ODAP measurements, is described. In addition, we describe a novel liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LCMS)-based method for β-L-ODAP-quantification. This method utilises an internal standard (di-13C-labelled β-L-ODAP) allowing accurate quantification of β-L-ODAP in grass pea tissue samples. The synthesis of this standard is also described. The two methods are compared; the spectrophotometric assay lacked sensitivity and detected ODAP-like absorbance in chickpea and pea whereas the LCMS method did not detect any β-L-ODAP in these species. The LCMS method was also used to quantify β-L-ODAP accurately in different tissues of grass pea. Conclusions The plate-based spectrophotometric assay allows quantification of total ODAP in large numbers of samples, but its low sensitivity and inability to differentiate α- and β-L-ODAP limit its usefulness for accurate quantification in low-ODAP samples. Coupled to the use of a stable isotope internal standard with LCMS that allows accurate quantification of β-L-ODAP in grass pea samples with high sensitivity, these methods permit the identification and characterisation of grass pea lines with a very low ODAP content. The LCMS method is offered as a new ‘gold standard’ for β-L-ODAP quantification, especially for the validation of existing and novel low- and/or zero-β-L-ODAP genotypes.
format Article
id doaj-art-98f7c08145104f8e8b1daa61ba3afa37
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 1471-2229
language English
publishDate 2019-11-01
publisher BMC
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-98f7c08145104f8e8b1daa61ba3afa372025-08-19T19:20:21ZengBMCBMC Plant Biology1471-22292019-11-0119111410.1186/s12870-019-2091-5Linking a rapid throughput plate-assay with high-sensitivity stable-isotope label LCMS quantification permits the identification and characterisation of low β-L-ODAP grass pea linesPeter M. F. Emmrich0Martin Rejzek1Lionel Hill2Paul Brett3Anne Edwards4Abhimanyu Sarkar5Rob A. Field6Cathie Martin7Trevor L. Wang8John Innes Centre, Norwich Research ParkJohn Innes Centre, Norwich Research ParkJohn Innes Centre, Norwich Research ParkJohn Innes Centre, Norwich Research ParkJohn Innes Centre, Norwich Research ParkJohn Innes Centre, Norwich Research ParkJohn Innes Centre, Norwich Research ParkJohn Innes Centre, Norwich Research ParkJohn Innes Centre, Norwich Research ParkAbstract Background Grass pea (Lathyrus sativus) is an underutilised crop with high tolerance to drought and flooding stress and potential for maintaining food and nutritional security in the face of climate change. The presence of the neurotoxin β-L-oxalyl-2,3-diaminopropionic acid (β-L-ODAP) in tissues of the plant has limited its adoption as a staple crop. To assist in the detection of material with very low neurotoxin toxin levels, we have developed two novel methods to assay ODAP. The first, a version of a widely used spectrophotometric assay, modified for increased throughput, permits rapid screening of large populations of germplasm for low toxin lines and the second is a novel, mass spectrometric procedure to detect very small quantities of ODAP for research purposes and characterisation of new varieties. Results A plate assay, based on an established spectrophotometric method enabling high-throughput ODAP measurements, is described. In addition, we describe a novel liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LCMS)-based method for β-L-ODAP-quantification. This method utilises an internal standard (di-13C-labelled β-L-ODAP) allowing accurate quantification of β-L-ODAP in grass pea tissue samples. The synthesis of this standard is also described. The two methods are compared; the spectrophotometric assay lacked sensitivity and detected ODAP-like absorbance in chickpea and pea whereas the LCMS method did not detect any β-L-ODAP in these species. The LCMS method was also used to quantify β-L-ODAP accurately in different tissues of grass pea. Conclusions The plate-based spectrophotometric assay allows quantification of total ODAP in large numbers of samples, but its low sensitivity and inability to differentiate α- and β-L-ODAP limit its usefulness for accurate quantification in low-ODAP samples. Coupled to the use of a stable isotope internal standard with LCMS that allows accurate quantification of β-L-ODAP in grass pea samples with high sensitivity, these methods permit the identification and characterisation of grass pea lines with a very low ODAP content. The LCMS method is offered as a new ‘gold standard’ for β-L-ODAP quantification, especially for the validation of existing and novel low- and/or zero-β-L-ODAP genotypes.http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12870-019-2091-5β-L-ODAPBOAAChickpeaGrass pea13C-internal standardLathyrus sativus
spellingShingle Peter M. F. Emmrich
Martin Rejzek
Lionel Hill
Paul Brett
Anne Edwards
Abhimanyu Sarkar
Rob A. Field
Cathie Martin
Trevor L. Wang
Linking a rapid throughput plate-assay with high-sensitivity stable-isotope label LCMS quantification permits the identification and characterisation of low β-L-ODAP grass pea lines
β-L-ODAP
BOAA
Chickpea
Grass pea
13C-internal standard
Lathyrus sativus
title Linking a rapid throughput plate-assay with high-sensitivity stable-isotope label LCMS quantification permits the identification and characterisation of low β-L-ODAP grass pea lines
title_full Linking a rapid throughput plate-assay with high-sensitivity stable-isotope label LCMS quantification permits the identification and characterisation of low β-L-ODAP grass pea lines
title_fullStr Linking a rapid throughput plate-assay with high-sensitivity stable-isotope label LCMS quantification permits the identification and characterisation of low β-L-ODAP grass pea lines
title_full_unstemmed Linking a rapid throughput plate-assay with high-sensitivity stable-isotope label LCMS quantification permits the identification and characterisation of low β-L-ODAP grass pea lines
title_short Linking a rapid throughput plate-assay with high-sensitivity stable-isotope label LCMS quantification permits the identification and characterisation of low β-L-ODAP grass pea lines
title_sort linking a rapid throughput plate assay with high sensitivity stable isotope label lcms quantification permits the identification and characterisation of low β l odap grass pea lines
topic β-L-ODAP
BOAA
Chickpea
Grass pea
13C-internal standard
Lathyrus sativus
url http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12870-019-2091-5
work_keys_str_mv AT petermfemmrich linkingarapidthroughputplateassaywithhighsensitivitystableisotopelabellcmsquantificationpermitstheidentificationandcharacterisationoflowblodapgrasspealines
AT martinrejzek linkingarapidthroughputplateassaywithhighsensitivitystableisotopelabellcmsquantificationpermitstheidentificationandcharacterisationoflowblodapgrasspealines
AT lionelhill linkingarapidthroughputplateassaywithhighsensitivitystableisotopelabellcmsquantificationpermitstheidentificationandcharacterisationoflowblodapgrasspealines
AT paulbrett linkingarapidthroughputplateassaywithhighsensitivitystableisotopelabellcmsquantificationpermitstheidentificationandcharacterisationoflowblodapgrasspealines
AT anneedwards linkingarapidthroughputplateassaywithhighsensitivitystableisotopelabellcmsquantificationpermitstheidentificationandcharacterisationoflowblodapgrasspealines
AT abhimanyusarkar linkingarapidthroughputplateassaywithhighsensitivitystableisotopelabellcmsquantificationpermitstheidentificationandcharacterisationoflowblodapgrasspealines
AT robafield linkingarapidthroughputplateassaywithhighsensitivitystableisotopelabellcmsquantificationpermitstheidentificationandcharacterisationoflowblodapgrasspealines
AT cathiemartin linkingarapidthroughputplateassaywithhighsensitivitystableisotopelabellcmsquantificationpermitstheidentificationandcharacterisationoflowblodapgrasspealines
AT trevorlwang linkingarapidthroughputplateassaywithhighsensitivitystableisotopelabellcmsquantificationpermitstheidentificationandcharacterisationoflowblodapgrasspealines