What Will Count?—Evidence for the Global Recognition of Other Effective area–based Conservation Measures

ABSTRACT Other effective area–based conservation measures (OECMs) are anticipated to play an important role in progress towards global protection targets, with progress being judged on the basis of the areas reported to the World Database on Other Effective area‐based Conservation Measures (WD‐OECM)...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Conservation Letters
Main Authors: Carly N Cook, Christopher J. Lemieux, Hedley S. Grantham, Madhu Rao, Peter J. Clyne, Vanessa Rathbone, Roshan Sharma
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Wiley 2025-09-01
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.13150
_version_ 1848665944803508224
author Carly N Cook
Christopher J. Lemieux
Hedley S. Grantham
Madhu Rao
Peter J. Clyne
Vanessa Rathbone
Roshan Sharma
author_facet Carly N Cook
Christopher J. Lemieux
Hedley S. Grantham
Madhu Rao
Peter J. Clyne
Vanessa Rathbone
Roshan Sharma
author_sort Carly N Cook
collection DOAJ
container_title Conservation Letters
description ABSTRACT Other effective area–based conservation measures (OECMs) are anticipated to play an important role in progress towards global protection targets, with progress being judged on the basis of the areas reported to the World Database on Other Effective area‐based Conservation Measures (WD‐OECM). Given concerns that OECMs may be designated inappropriately, in this study we asked what evidence has been provided to show that sites have been assessed against the criteria to be OECMs. We found <5% of the 6,482 sites in the dataset provide supporting information of any kind, and 2.2% of sites have features that conflict with the definition of an OECM. Although our results cannot determine if sites genuinely meet the criteria to be recognized as OECMs, they reveal a significant issue with the ability to verify whether sites should be in the WD‐OECM. To increase the credibility of OECMs, we recommend sites be classed as unconfirmed until they can demonstrate they meet the relevant criteria.
format Article
id doaj-art-e351b574d8564e90825aaa93a1f4bb63
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 1755-263X
language English
publishDate 2025-09-01
publisher Wiley
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-e351b574d8564e90825aaa93a1f4bb632025-10-29T14:42:50ZengWileyConservation Letters1755-263X2025-09-01185n/an/a10.1111/conl.13150What Will Count?—Evidence for the Global Recognition of Other Effective area–based Conservation MeasuresCarly N Cook0Christopher J. Lemieux1Hedley S. Grantham2Madhu Rao3Peter J. Clyne4Vanessa Rathbone5Roshan Sharma6School of Biological Sciences Monash University Melbourne AustraliaDepartment of Geography & Environmental Studies Wilfrid Laurier University Waterloo Ontario CanadaBush Heritage Australia Melbourne AustraliaWorld Commission on Protected Areas, International Union for Conservation of Nature Gland SwitzerlandWildlife Conservation Society New York New York USAWildlife Conservation Society New York New York USASchool of Biological Sciences Monash University Melbourne AustraliaABSTRACT Other effective area–based conservation measures (OECMs) are anticipated to play an important role in progress towards global protection targets, with progress being judged on the basis of the areas reported to the World Database on Other Effective area‐based Conservation Measures (WD‐OECM). Given concerns that OECMs may be designated inappropriately, in this study we asked what evidence has been provided to show that sites have been assessed against the criteria to be OECMs. We found <5% of the 6,482 sites in the dataset provide supporting information of any kind, and 2.2% of sites have features that conflict with the definition of an OECM. Although our results cannot determine if sites genuinely meet the criteria to be recognized as OECMs, they reveal a significant issue with the ability to verify whether sites should be in the WD‐OECM. To increase the credibility of OECMs, we recommend sites be classed as unconfirmed until they can demonstrate they meet the relevant criteria.https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.1315030 × 30 | area‐based conservation | CADDD | Kunming‐Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework | PA conversion | protected and conserved areas | Target 3
spellingShingle Carly N Cook
Christopher J. Lemieux
Hedley S. Grantham
Madhu Rao
Peter J. Clyne
Vanessa Rathbone
Roshan Sharma
What Will Count?—Evidence for the Global Recognition of Other Effective area–based Conservation Measures
30 × 30 | area‐based conservation | CADDD | Kunming‐Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework | PA conversion | protected and conserved areas | Target 3
title What Will Count?—Evidence for the Global Recognition of Other Effective area–based Conservation Measures
title_full What Will Count?—Evidence for the Global Recognition of Other Effective area–based Conservation Measures
title_fullStr What Will Count?—Evidence for the Global Recognition of Other Effective area–based Conservation Measures
title_full_unstemmed What Will Count?—Evidence for the Global Recognition of Other Effective area–based Conservation Measures
title_short What Will Count?—Evidence for the Global Recognition of Other Effective area–based Conservation Measures
title_sort what will count evidence for the global recognition of other effective area based conservation measures
topic 30 × 30 | area‐based conservation | CADDD | Kunming‐Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework | PA conversion | protected and conserved areas | Target 3
url https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.13150
work_keys_str_mv AT carlyncook whatwillcountevidencefortheglobalrecognitionofothereffectiveareabasedconservationmeasures
AT christopherjlemieux whatwillcountevidencefortheglobalrecognitionofothereffectiveareabasedconservationmeasures
AT hedleysgrantham whatwillcountevidencefortheglobalrecognitionofothereffectiveareabasedconservationmeasures
AT madhurao whatwillcountevidencefortheglobalrecognitionofothereffectiveareabasedconservationmeasures
AT peterjclyne whatwillcountevidencefortheglobalrecognitionofothereffectiveareabasedconservationmeasures
AT vanessarathbone whatwillcountevidencefortheglobalrecognitionofothereffectiveareabasedconservationmeasures
AT roshansharma whatwillcountevidencefortheglobalrecognitionofothereffectiveareabasedconservationmeasures