Experience obtaining legal abortion in Uruguay: knowledge, attitudes, and stigma among abortion clients

Abstract Background The abortion law in Uruguay changed in 2012 to allow first trimester abortion on request. Implementation of the law in Uruguay has been lauded, but barriers to care, including abortion stigma, remain. This study aimed to assess women’s experiences seeking abortion services and re...

وصف كامل

التفاصيل البيبلوغرافية
الحاوية / القاعدة:BMC Women's Health
المؤلفون الرئيسيون: Shelly Makleff, Ana Labandera, Fernanda Chiribao, Jennifer Friedman, Roosbelinda Cardenas, Eleuthera Sa, Sarah E. Baum
التنسيق: مقال
اللغة:الإنجليزية
منشور في: BMC 2019-12-01
الموضوعات:
الوصول للمادة أونلاين:https://doi.org/10.1186/s12905-019-0855-6
_version_ 1852733683864174592
author Shelly Makleff
Ana Labandera
Fernanda Chiribao
Jennifer Friedman
Roosbelinda Cardenas
Eleuthera Sa
Sarah E. Baum
author_facet Shelly Makleff
Ana Labandera
Fernanda Chiribao
Jennifer Friedman
Roosbelinda Cardenas
Eleuthera Sa
Sarah E. Baum
author_sort Shelly Makleff
collection DOAJ
container_title BMC Women's Health
description Abstract Background The abortion law in Uruguay changed in 2012 to allow first trimester abortion on request. Implementation of the law in Uruguay has been lauded, but barriers to care, including abortion stigma, remain. This study aimed to assess women’s experiences seeking abortion services and related attitudes and knowledge following implementation of the law in Uruguay. Methods We interviewed 207 eligible women seeking abortion services at a high-volume public hospital in Montevideo in 2014. We generated univariate frequencies to describe women’s experiences in care. We conducted regression analysis to examine variations in experiences of stigma by women’s age and number of abortions. Results Most of the women felt that abortion was a right, were satisfied with the services they received, and agreed with the abortion law. However, 70% found the five-day waiting period unnecessary. Women experienced greater self-judgement than worries about being judged by others. Younger women in the sample (ages 18–21) reported being more worried about judgment than women 22 years or older (1.02 vs. 0.71 on the ILAS sub-scale). One quarter of participants reported feeling judged while obtaining services. Women with more than one abortion had nearly three times the odds of reporting feeling judged. Conclusions These findings highlight the need to address abortion stigma even after the law is changed. Some considerations from Uruguay that may be relevant to other jurisdictions reforming abortion laws include: the need for strategies to reduce judgmental behavior from staff and clinicians towards women seeking abortions, including training in counseling skills and empathic communication; addressing stigmatizing attitudes about abortion through community outreach or communications campaigns; mitigating the potential stigma that may be perpetuated through policies to prevent “repeat” abortions; ensuring that younger women and those with more than one abortion feel welcome and are not mistreated during care; and assessing the necessity of a waiting period. The rapid implementation of legal, voluntary abortion services in Uruguay can serve in many ways as an exemplar, and these findings may inform the process of abortion law reform in other countries.
format Article
id doaj-art-e518eae83099433db3631b8d7a36012d
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 1472-6874
language English
publishDate 2019-12-01
publisher BMC
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-e518eae83099433db3631b8d7a36012d2025-08-19T21:07:30ZengBMCBMC Women's Health1472-68742019-12-0119111010.1186/s12905-019-0855-6Experience obtaining legal abortion in Uruguay: knowledge, attitudes, and stigma among abortion clientsShelly Makleff0Ana Labandera1Fernanda Chiribao2Jennifer Friedman3Roosbelinda Cardenas4Eleuthera Sa5Sarah E. Baum6International Planned Parenthood Federation/Western Hemisphere RegionIniciativas Sanitarias, Hospital Pereira RossellIniciativas Sanitarias, Hospital Pereira RossellInternational Planned Parenthood Federation/Western Hemisphere RegionInternational Planned Parenthood Federation/Western Hemisphere RegionInternational Planned Parenthood Federation/Western Hemisphere RegionIbis Reproductive HealthAbstract Background The abortion law in Uruguay changed in 2012 to allow first trimester abortion on request. Implementation of the law in Uruguay has been lauded, but barriers to care, including abortion stigma, remain. This study aimed to assess women’s experiences seeking abortion services and related attitudes and knowledge following implementation of the law in Uruguay. Methods We interviewed 207 eligible women seeking abortion services at a high-volume public hospital in Montevideo in 2014. We generated univariate frequencies to describe women’s experiences in care. We conducted regression analysis to examine variations in experiences of stigma by women’s age and number of abortions. Results Most of the women felt that abortion was a right, were satisfied with the services they received, and agreed with the abortion law. However, 70% found the five-day waiting period unnecessary. Women experienced greater self-judgement than worries about being judged by others. Younger women in the sample (ages 18–21) reported being more worried about judgment than women 22 years or older (1.02 vs. 0.71 on the ILAS sub-scale). One quarter of participants reported feeling judged while obtaining services. Women with more than one abortion had nearly three times the odds of reporting feeling judged. Conclusions These findings highlight the need to address abortion stigma even after the law is changed. Some considerations from Uruguay that may be relevant to other jurisdictions reforming abortion laws include: the need for strategies to reduce judgmental behavior from staff and clinicians towards women seeking abortions, including training in counseling skills and empathic communication; addressing stigmatizing attitudes about abortion through community outreach or communications campaigns; mitigating the potential stigma that may be perpetuated through policies to prevent “repeat” abortions; ensuring that younger women and those with more than one abortion feel welcome and are not mistreated during care; and assessing the necessity of a waiting period. The rapid implementation of legal, voluntary abortion services in Uruguay can serve in many ways as an exemplar, and these findings may inform the process of abortion law reform in other countries.https://doi.org/10.1186/s12905-019-0855-6Legal abortionAbortion servicesAbortion stigmaUruguayDecriminalizationMultiple abortions
spellingShingle Shelly Makleff
Ana Labandera
Fernanda Chiribao
Jennifer Friedman
Roosbelinda Cardenas
Eleuthera Sa
Sarah E. Baum
Experience obtaining legal abortion in Uruguay: knowledge, attitudes, and stigma among abortion clients
Legal abortion
Abortion services
Abortion stigma
Uruguay
Decriminalization
Multiple abortions
title Experience obtaining legal abortion in Uruguay: knowledge, attitudes, and stigma among abortion clients
title_full Experience obtaining legal abortion in Uruguay: knowledge, attitudes, and stigma among abortion clients
title_fullStr Experience obtaining legal abortion in Uruguay: knowledge, attitudes, and stigma among abortion clients
title_full_unstemmed Experience obtaining legal abortion in Uruguay: knowledge, attitudes, and stigma among abortion clients
title_short Experience obtaining legal abortion in Uruguay: knowledge, attitudes, and stigma among abortion clients
title_sort experience obtaining legal abortion in uruguay knowledge attitudes and stigma among abortion clients
topic Legal abortion
Abortion services
Abortion stigma
Uruguay
Decriminalization
Multiple abortions
url https://doi.org/10.1186/s12905-019-0855-6
work_keys_str_mv AT shellymakleff experienceobtaininglegalabortioninuruguayknowledgeattitudesandstigmaamongabortionclients
AT analabandera experienceobtaininglegalabortioninuruguayknowledgeattitudesandstigmaamongabortionclients
AT fernandachiribao experienceobtaininglegalabortioninuruguayknowledgeattitudesandstigmaamongabortionclients
AT jenniferfriedman experienceobtaininglegalabortioninuruguayknowledgeattitudesandstigmaamongabortionclients
AT roosbelindacardenas experienceobtaininglegalabortioninuruguayknowledgeattitudesandstigmaamongabortionclients
AT eleutherasa experienceobtaininglegalabortioninuruguayknowledgeattitudesandstigmaamongabortionclients
AT sarahebaum experienceobtaininglegalabortioninuruguayknowledgeattitudesandstigmaamongabortionclients