Optimizing Parameter Estimation to Improve Evapotranspiration Calculation for Maize Fields

【Objective】 Evapotranspiration is an important factor in agricultural water management, but its calculation is not trial, especially in areas lacking weather stations where measured meteorological data are incomplete or unavailable. The purpose of this paper is to propose an optimal method to estima...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Guan'gai paishui xuebao
Main Authors: QIU Zhongqi, ZHOU Linlin, LIU Hongjuan, TIAN Qianglong, ZHAO Zijing, ZHANG Xiaomei, WEI Guoxiao
Format: Article
Language:Chinese
Published: Science Press 2022-01-01
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.ggpsxb.com/jgpxxben/ch/reader/view_abstract.aspx?file_no=20220105&flag=1
_version_ 1850040166223183872
author QIU Zhongqi
ZHOU Linlin
LIU Hongjuan
TIAN Qianglong
ZHAO Zijing
ZHANG Xiaomei
WEI Guoxiao
author_facet QIU Zhongqi
ZHOU Linlin
LIU Hongjuan
TIAN Qianglong
ZHAO Zijing
ZHANG Xiaomei
WEI Guoxiao
author_sort QIU Zhongqi
collection DOAJ
container_title Guan'gai paishui xuebao
description 【Objective】 Evapotranspiration is an important factor in agricultural water management, but its calculation is not trial, especially in areas lacking weather stations where measured meteorological data are incomplete or unavailable. The purpose of this paper is to propose an optimal method to estimate parameters which cannot be measured directly but required for estimating evapotranspiration. 【Method】 The analysis was based meteorological data measured from weather stations at Daman in the basin of Hei River We took corn fields in the basin as an example and assumed latent heat flux and sensible heat flux were the parameters. Differential evolution adaptive algorithms were compared to optimize the parameters in the evapotranspiration model by introducing an energy-unclosed-factor to the multi-objective function in the parameter estimation. The model was built on the Bayesian inference with the values of the parameters calculated by the Markov chain Markov chain Monte Carlo method. Based on traditional indexes including coefficient of determination (R2), linear regression slope, root mean square error (RMSE), consistency index (IA) and Nash coefficient (NSE), we evaluated the model against the original Shuttleworth-Wallace model. 【Result】 We separated the comparison into two phases: a calibration phase and a prediction phase. Comparing with the original Shuttleworth Wallace model showed the optimized model reduced the root mean square error by 52.46% and increased the consistency index by 17.3% in the calibration phase; the optimized model also improved the Nash coefficient of the latent heat flux to 0.82, though it did not show significant improvement over the original Shuttleworth Wallace model for estimating the sensible heat flux. For prediction, the optimized model reduced the root mean square error by 50.51% and increased the consistency index by 14.46%, compared with the original Shuttleworth Wallace model. The proposed model improved the Nash coefficient of the latent flux to 0.80, but it did not show significant difference from the original Shuttleworth Wallace model in other evaluation indexes. 【Conclusion】 We proposed a model to estimate parameters which are required for calculating evapotranspiration but cannot be measured or are missing. Tests against measured latent heat flux and sensible heat flux showed that the proposed model was superior to existing models for estimating the two parameters.
format Article
id doaj-art-e73d28dd6cec4d1886434cdaf93f2d82
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 1672-3317
language zho
publishDate 2022-01-01
publisher Science Press
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-e73d28dd6cec4d1886434cdaf93f2d822025-08-20T00:32:15ZzhoScience PressGuan'gai paishui xuebao1672-33172022-01-01411334010.13522/j.cnki.ggps.20212941672-3317(2022)01-0033-08Optimizing Parameter Estimation to Improve Evapotranspiration Calculation for Maize FieldsQIU Zhongqi0ZHOU Linlin1LIU Hongjuan2TIAN Qianglong3ZHAO Zijing4ZHANG Xiaomei5WEI Guoxiao6(College of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, China;(College of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, China;(College of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, China;(College of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, China;(College of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, China;Taipingdian Town People’s Government of Huining County, Agricultural Comprehensive Service Center, Baiyin 730799, China)(College of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, China;【Objective】 Evapotranspiration is an important factor in agricultural water management, but its calculation is not trial, especially in areas lacking weather stations where measured meteorological data are incomplete or unavailable. The purpose of this paper is to propose an optimal method to estimate parameters which cannot be measured directly but required for estimating evapotranspiration. 【Method】 The analysis was based meteorological data measured from weather stations at Daman in the basin of Hei River We took corn fields in the basin as an example and assumed latent heat flux and sensible heat flux were the parameters. Differential evolution adaptive algorithms were compared to optimize the parameters in the evapotranspiration model by introducing an energy-unclosed-factor to the multi-objective function in the parameter estimation. The model was built on the Bayesian inference with the values of the parameters calculated by the Markov chain Markov chain Monte Carlo method. Based on traditional indexes including coefficient of determination (R2), linear regression slope, root mean square error (RMSE), consistency index (IA) and Nash coefficient (NSE), we evaluated the model against the original Shuttleworth-Wallace model. 【Result】 We separated the comparison into two phases: a calibration phase and a prediction phase. Comparing with the original Shuttleworth Wallace model showed the optimized model reduced the root mean square error by 52.46% and increased the consistency index by 17.3% in the calibration phase; the optimized model also improved the Nash coefficient of the latent heat flux to 0.82, though it did not show significant improvement over the original Shuttleworth Wallace model for estimating the sensible heat flux. For prediction, the optimized model reduced the root mean square error by 50.51% and increased the consistency index by 14.46%, compared with the original Shuttleworth Wallace model. The proposed model improved the Nash coefficient of the latent flux to 0.80, but it did not show significant difference from the original Shuttleworth Wallace model in other evaluation indexes. 【Conclusion】 We proposed a model to estimate parameters which are required for calculating evapotranspiration but cannot be measured or are missing. Tests against measured latent heat flux and sensible heat flux showed that the proposed model was superior to existing models for estimating the two parameters.https://www.ggpsxb.com/jgpxxben/ch/reader/view_abstract.aspx?file_no=20220105&flag=1parameter optimizationevapotranspiration modelmarkov chain monte carlo
spellingShingle QIU Zhongqi
ZHOU Linlin
LIU Hongjuan
TIAN Qianglong
ZHAO Zijing
ZHANG Xiaomei
WEI Guoxiao
Optimizing Parameter Estimation to Improve Evapotranspiration Calculation for Maize Fields
parameter optimization
evapotranspiration model
markov chain monte carlo
title Optimizing Parameter Estimation to Improve Evapotranspiration Calculation for Maize Fields
title_full Optimizing Parameter Estimation to Improve Evapotranspiration Calculation for Maize Fields
title_fullStr Optimizing Parameter Estimation to Improve Evapotranspiration Calculation for Maize Fields
title_full_unstemmed Optimizing Parameter Estimation to Improve Evapotranspiration Calculation for Maize Fields
title_short Optimizing Parameter Estimation to Improve Evapotranspiration Calculation for Maize Fields
title_sort optimizing parameter estimation to improve evapotranspiration calculation for maize fields
topic parameter optimization
evapotranspiration model
markov chain monte carlo
url https://www.ggpsxb.com/jgpxxben/ch/reader/view_abstract.aspx?file_no=20220105&flag=1
work_keys_str_mv AT qiuzhongqi optimizingparameterestimationtoimproveevapotranspirationcalculationformaizefields
AT zhoulinlin optimizingparameterestimationtoimproveevapotranspirationcalculationformaizefields
AT liuhongjuan optimizingparameterestimationtoimproveevapotranspirationcalculationformaizefields
AT tianqianglong optimizingparameterestimationtoimproveevapotranspirationcalculationformaizefields
AT zhaozijing optimizingparameterestimationtoimproveevapotranspirationcalculationformaizefields
AT zhangxiaomei optimizingparameterestimationtoimproveevapotranspirationcalculationformaizefields
AT weiguoxiao optimizingparameterestimationtoimproveevapotranspirationcalculationformaizefields