Short-term volunteer health trips: aligning host community preferences and organizer practices

• الحاوية / القاعدة: Global Health Action
• المؤلفون الرئيسيون: Michael D. Rozier, Judith N. Lasker, Bruce Compton
• التنسيق: مقال
• اللغة: الإنجليزية
• منشور في: Taylor & Francis Group 2017-01-01
• الموضوعات: medical missions; capacity building; partnership/collaboration; voluntourism
• الوصول للمادة أونلاين: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/16549716.2017.1267957

Background: Short-term medical missions (STMMs) are quite common and largely understood to be a response to health needs in low-income countries. Yet most information about STMM practices is anecdotal. Even less is known about the preferences of in-country host communities regarding STMMs. Objective: We aimed to gather enough quantitative and qualitative information from both STMM organizers and host community staff to compare dominant practices of organizers as well as preferences of host community staff. We use these data to discover differences between practices and preferences and suggest ways in which STMMs can be more responsive to the communities they serve. Methods: Researchers gathered online survey responses from 334 STMM organizers and conducted interviews to determine existing practices. Similar methods were used to collect 49 online survey responses from, and conduct 75 interviews with, host community staff. Results: Organizer practices and host community staff preferences are different in several areas. Organizers admit to minimal screening and preparation of volunteers whereas host staff have clear ideas of topics that should be covered in preparation, including culture and basic language skills. Organizers prioritize provision of clinical care during trips whereas host staff prioritize capacity building. Practices and preferences also differ in relation to the length of STMMs, the nature of the partnership itself, and the type of assessment and evaluation that is needed. Conclusions: The large amount of data gathered for this study allows us to confidently say that organizer practices are often not aligned with host community staff preferences. Several concrete changes can be made to STMMs to bring practices more in line with the desires of the communities they serve.