Combining Earthquake Ground Motion and Ambient Vibration Recordings to Evaluate a Local High-Resolution Amplification Model—Insight From the Lucerne Area, Switzerland

Amplification factors are often estimated using empirical methods based on earthquake ground motion; however, especially in low-seismicity urban areas, recording a statistically representative number of high-quality signals may take years. Hence, the attempts to use ambient vibration instead have pr...

詳細記述

書誌詳細
出版年:Frontiers in Earth Science
主要な著者: Paulina Janusz, Vincent Perron, Christoph Knellwolf, Donat Fäh
フォーマット: 論文
言語:英語
出版事項: Frontiers Media S.A. 2022-05-01
主題:
オンライン・アクセス:https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/feart.2022.885724/full
_version_ 1851932456446328832
author Paulina Janusz
Vincent Perron
Christoph Knellwolf
Donat Fäh
author_facet Paulina Janusz
Vincent Perron
Christoph Knellwolf
Donat Fäh
author_sort Paulina Janusz
collection DOAJ
container_title Frontiers in Earth Science
description Amplification factors are often estimated using empirical methods based on earthquake ground motion; however, especially in low-seismicity urban areas, recording a statistically representative number of high-quality signals may take years. Hence, the attempts to use ambient vibration instead have progressed. This includes the development of the hybrid site-to-reference spectral ratio (SSRh) method that combines earthquake and ambient vibration recordings. We applied the method in the Lucerne area in central Switzerland that is characterized by low-to-moderate seismicity but was struck by several strong earthquakes in historical times (i.e., Mw 5.9 in 1,601) and is located in a glacial basin filled with unconsolidated deposits prone to significant amplification. To develop the high-resolution local site amplification model for the city of Lucerne using the SSRh method, we took advantage of a small seismic monitoring network installed in the Lucerne area in total for about a year and the stations of the Swiss Strong Motion Network (SSMNet). In addition, we performed two extensive surveys to record ambient vibrations and used dozens of measurements performed in the area since 2001. The resulting amplification model referring to the Swiss reference bedrock conditions indicates high-amplification factors (up to 10-fold) for a broad range of frequencies. The model is consistent with geological data and site response proxies such as f0 values. The direct comparison of our results with the SSR amplification functions for several sites shows good agreement. However, the model is characterized by high uncertainty and influenced by daily variation of the noise wavefield, as well as the spatial distribution of the stations of the seismic network. We also discussed the extent of the applicability of the method, concluding that the main factor influencing its performance is not the distance but the similarity of the site condition between the stations.
format Article
id doaj-art-e8c0d8c8cf2c4755a2c896d7d087cbf6
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 2296-6463
language English
publishDate 2022-05-01
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-e8c0d8c8cf2c4755a2c896d7d087cbf62025-08-19T21:53:50ZengFrontiers Media S.A.Frontiers in Earth Science2296-64632022-05-011010.3389/feart.2022.885724885724Combining Earthquake Ground Motion and Ambient Vibration Recordings to Evaluate a Local High-Resolution Amplification Model—Insight From the Lucerne Area, SwitzerlandPaulina Janusz0Vincent Perron1Christoph Knellwolf2Donat Fäh3Swiss Seismological Service, ETH Zürich, Zürich, SwitzerlandSwiss Seismological Service, ETH Zürich, Zürich, SwitzerlandVerkehr und Infrastruktur, Abteilung Naturgefahren, Kanton Luzern, Kriens, SwitzerlandSwiss Seismological Service, ETH Zürich, Zürich, SwitzerlandAmplification factors are often estimated using empirical methods based on earthquake ground motion; however, especially in low-seismicity urban areas, recording a statistically representative number of high-quality signals may take years. Hence, the attempts to use ambient vibration instead have progressed. This includes the development of the hybrid site-to-reference spectral ratio (SSRh) method that combines earthquake and ambient vibration recordings. We applied the method in the Lucerne area in central Switzerland that is characterized by low-to-moderate seismicity but was struck by several strong earthquakes in historical times (i.e., Mw 5.9 in 1,601) and is located in a glacial basin filled with unconsolidated deposits prone to significant amplification. To develop the high-resolution local site amplification model for the city of Lucerne using the SSRh method, we took advantage of a small seismic monitoring network installed in the Lucerne area in total for about a year and the stations of the Swiss Strong Motion Network (SSMNet). In addition, we performed two extensive surveys to record ambient vibrations and used dozens of measurements performed in the area since 2001. The resulting amplification model referring to the Swiss reference bedrock conditions indicates high-amplification factors (up to 10-fold) for a broad range of frequencies. The model is consistent with geological data and site response proxies such as f0 values. The direct comparison of our results with the SSR amplification functions for several sites shows good agreement. However, the model is characterized by high uncertainty and influenced by daily variation of the noise wavefield, as well as the spatial distribution of the stations of the seismic network. We also discussed the extent of the applicability of the method, concluding that the main factor influencing its performance is not the distance but the similarity of the site condition between the stations.https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/feart.2022.885724/fullseismic site effectsseismic hazardurban areasmicrozonationambient vibrationearthquake ground motion
spellingShingle Paulina Janusz
Vincent Perron
Christoph Knellwolf
Donat Fäh
Combining Earthquake Ground Motion and Ambient Vibration Recordings to Evaluate a Local High-Resolution Amplification Model—Insight From the Lucerne Area, Switzerland
seismic site effects
seismic hazard
urban areas
microzonation
ambient vibration
earthquake ground motion
title Combining Earthquake Ground Motion and Ambient Vibration Recordings to Evaluate a Local High-Resolution Amplification Model—Insight From the Lucerne Area, Switzerland
title_full Combining Earthquake Ground Motion and Ambient Vibration Recordings to Evaluate a Local High-Resolution Amplification Model—Insight From the Lucerne Area, Switzerland
title_fullStr Combining Earthquake Ground Motion and Ambient Vibration Recordings to Evaluate a Local High-Resolution Amplification Model—Insight From the Lucerne Area, Switzerland
title_full_unstemmed Combining Earthquake Ground Motion and Ambient Vibration Recordings to Evaluate a Local High-Resolution Amplification Model—Insight From the Lucerne Area, Switzerland
title_short Combining Earthquake Ground Motion and Ambient Vibration Recordings to Evaluate a Local High-Resolution Amplification Model—Insight From the Lucerne Area, Switzerland
title_sort combining earthquake ground motion and ambient vibration recordings to evaluate a local high resolution amplification model insight from the lucerne area switzerland
topic seismic site effects
seismic hazard
urban areas
microzonation
ambient vibration
earthquake ground motion
url https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/feart.2022.885724/full
work_keys_str_mv AT paulinajanusz combiningearthquakegroundmotionandambientvibrationrecordingstoevaluatealocalhighresolutionamplificationmodelinsightfromthelucerneareaswitzerland
AT vincentperron combiningearthquakegroundmotionandambientvibrationrecordingstoevaluatealocalhighresolutionamplificationmodelinsightfromthelucerneareaswitzerland
AT christophknellwolf combiningearthquakegroundmotionandambientvibrationrecordingstoevaluatealocalhighresolutionamplificationmodelinsightfromthelucerneareaswitzerland
AT donatfah combiningearthquakegroundmotionandambientvibrationrecordingstoevaluatealocalhighresolutionamplificationmodelinsightfromthelucerneareaswitzerland