A geospatial analysis of local intermediate snail host distributions provides insight into schistosomiasis risk within under-sampled areas of southern Lake Malawi

Abstract Background Along the southern shoreline of Lake Malawi, the incidence of schistosomiasis is increasing with snails of the genera Bulinus and Biomphalaria transmitting urogenital and intestinal schistosomiasis, respectively. Since the underlying distribution of snails is partially known, oft...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Parasites & Vectors
Main Authors: Amber L. Reed, Mohammad H. Al-Harbi, Peter Makaula, Charlotte Condemine, Josie Hesketh, John Archer, Sam Jones, Sekeleghe A. Kayuni, Janelisa Musaya, Michelle C. Stanton, J. Russell Stothard, Claudio Fronterre, Christopher Jewell
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: BMC 2024-06-01
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1186/s13071-024-06353-y
_version_ 1850137491765460992
author Amber L. Reed
Mohammad H. Al-Harbi
Peter Makaula
Charlotte Condemine
Josie Hesketh
John Archer
Sam Jones
Sekeleghe A. Kayuni
Janelisa Musaya
Michelle C. Stanton
J. Russell Stothard
Claudio Fronterre
Christopher Jewell
author_facet Amber L. Reed
Mohammad H. Al-Harbi
Peter Makaula
Charlotte Condemine
Josie Hesketh
John Archer
Sam Jones
Sekeleghe A. Kayuni
Janelisa Musaya
Michelle C. Stanton
J. Russell Stothard
Claudio Fronterre
Christopher Jewell
author_sort Amber L. Reed
collection DOAJ
container_title Parasites & Vectors
description Abstract Background Along the southern shoreline of Lake Malawi, the incidence of schistosomiasis is increasing with snails of the genera Bulinus and Biomphalaria transmitting urogenital and intestinal schistosomiasis, respectively. Since the underlying distribution of snails is partially known, often being focal, developing pragmatic spatial models that interpolate snail information across under-sampled regions is required to understand and assess current and future risk of schistosomiasis. Methods A secondary geospatial analysis of recently collected malacological and environmental survey data was undertaken. Using a Bayesian Poisson latent Gaussian process model, abundance data were fitted for Bulinus and Biomphalaria. Interpolating the abundance of snails along the shoreline (given their relative distance along the shoreline) was achieved by smoothing, using extracted environmental rainfall, land surface temperature (LST), evapotranspiration, normalised difference vegetation index (NDVI) and soil type covariate data for all predicted locations. Our adopted model used a combination of two-dimensional (2D) and one dimensional (1D) mapping. Results A significant association between normalised difference vegetation index (NDVI) and abundance of Bulinus spp. was detected (log risk ratio − 0.83, 95% CrI − 1.57, − 0.09). A qualitatively similar association was found between NDVI and Biomphalaria sp. but was not statistically significant (log risk ratio − 1.42, 95% CrI − 3.09, 0.10). Analyses of all other environmental data were considered non-significant. Conclusions The spatial range in which interpolation of snail distributions is possible appears < 10km owing to fine-scale biotic and abiotic heterogeneities. The forthcoming challenge is to refine geospatial sampling frameworks with future opportunities to map schistosomiasis within actual or predicted snail distributions. In so doing, this would better reveal local environmental transmission possibilities. Graphical Abstract
format Article
id doaj-art-e9fe7643952f4313bc0b9372fdfdabb6
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 1756-3305
language English
publishDate 2024-06-01
publisher BMC
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-e9fe7643952f4313bc0b9372fdfdabb62025-08-19T23:50:29ZengBMCParasites & Vectors1756-33052024-06-0117111310.1186/s13071-024-06353-yA geospatial analysis of local intermediate snail host distributions provides insight into schistosomiasis risk within under-sampled areas of southern Lake MalawiAmber L. Reed0Mohammad H. Al-Harbi1Peter Makaula2Charlotte Condemine3Josie Hesketh4John Archer5Sam Jones6Sekeleghe A. Kayuni7Janelisa Musaya8Michelle C. Stanton9J. Russell Stothard10Claudio Fronterre11Christopher Jewell12Lancaster Medical School, Lancaster UniversityTropical Disease Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical MedicineMalawi Liverpool Wellcome Trust Programme of Clinical Tropical Research, Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital, College of MedicineTropical Disease Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical MedicineTropical Disease Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical MedicineTropical Disease Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical MedicineTropical Disease Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical MedicineTropical Disease Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical MedicineMalawi Liverpool Wellcome Trust Programme of Clinical Tropical Research, Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital, College of MedicineVector Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical MedicineTropical Disease Biology, Liverpool School of Tropical MedicineLancaster Medical School, Lancaster UniversityMathematics and Statistics, Lancaster UniversityAbstract Background Along the southern shoreline of Lake Malawi, the incidence of schistosomiasis is increasing with snails of the genera Bulinus and Biomphalaria transmitting urogenital and intestinal schistosomiasis, respectively. Since the underlying distribution of snails is partially known, often being focal, developing pragmatic spatial models that interpolate snail information across under-sampled regions is required to understand and assess current and future risk of schistosomiasis. Methods A secondary geospatial analysis of recently collected malacological and environmental survey data was undertaken. Using a Bayesian Poisson latent Gaussian process model, abundance data were fitted for Bulinus and Biomphalaria. Interpolating the abundance of snails along the shoreline (given their relative distance along the shoreline) was achieved by smoothing, using extracted environmental rainfall, land surface temperature (LST), evapotranspiration, normalised difference vegetation index (NDVI) and soil type covariate data for all predicted locations. Our adopted model used a combination of two-dimensional (2D) and one dimensional (1D) mapping. Results A significant association between normalised difference vegetation index (NDVI) and abundance of Bulinus spp. was detected (log risk ratio − 0.83, 95% CrI − 1.57, − 0.09). A qualitatively similar association was found between NDVI and Biomphalaria sp. but was not statistically significant (log risk ratio − 1.42, 95% CrI − 3.09, 0.10). Analyses of all other environmental data were considered non-significant. Conclusions The spatial range in which interpolation of snail distributions is possible appears < 10km owing to fine-scale biotic and abiotic heterogeneities. The forthcoming challenge is to refine geospatial sampling frameworks with future opportunities to map schistosomiasis within actual or predicted snail distributions. In so doing, this would better reveal local environmental transmission possibilities. Graphical Abstracthttps://doi.org/10.1186/s13071-024-06353-yBulinusBiomphalariaSnail abundanceBayesian multilevel modelsGeospatial analysisGaussian latent process
spellingShingle Amber L. Reed
Mohammad H. Al-Harbi
Peter Makaula
Charlotte Condemine
Josie Hesketh
John Archer
Sam Jones
Sekeleghe A. Kayuni
Janelisa Musaya
Michelle C. Stanton
J. Russell Stothard
Claudio Fronterre
Christopher Jewell
A geospatial analysis of local intermediate snail host distributions provides insight into schistosomiasis risk within under-sampled areas of southern Lake Malawi
Bulinus
Biomphalaria
Snail abundance
Bayesian multilevel models
Geospatial analysis
Gaussian latent process
title A geospatial analysis of local intermediate snail host distributions provides insight into schistosomiasis risk within under-sampled areas of southern Lake Malawi
title_full A geospatial analysis of local intermediate snail host distributions provides insight into schistosomiasis risk within under-sampled areas of southern Lake Malawi
title_fullStr A geospatial analysis of local intermediate snail host distributions provides insight into schistosomiasis risk within under-sampled areas of southern Lake Malawi
title_full_unstemmed A geospatial analysis of local intermediate snail host distributions provides insight into schistosomiasis risk within under-sampled areas of southern Lake Malawi
title_short A geospatial analysis of local intermediate snail host distributions provides insight into schistosomiasis risk within under-sampled areas of southern Lake Malawi
title_sort geospatial analysis of local intermediate snail host distributions provides insight into schistosomiasis risk within under sampled areas of southern lake malawi
topic Bulinus
Biomphalaria
Snail abundance
Bayesian multilevel models
Geospatial analysis
Gaussian latent process
url https://doi.org/10.1186/s13071-024-06353-y
work_keys_str_mv AT amberlreed ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT mohammadhalharbi ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT petermakaula ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT charlottecondemine ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT josiehesketh ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT johnarcher ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT samjones ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT sekelegheakayuni ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT janelisamusaya ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT michellecstanton ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT jrussellstothard ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT claudiofronterre ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT christopherjewell ageospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT amberlreed geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT mohammadhalharbi geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT petermakaula geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT charlottecondemine geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT josiehesketh geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT johnarcher geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT samjones geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT sekelegheakayuni geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT janelisamusaya geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT michellecstanton geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT jrussellstothard geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT claudiofronterre geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi
AT christopherjewell geospatialanalysisoflocalintermediatesnailhostdistributionsprovidesinsightintoschistosomiasisriskwithinundersampledareasofsouthernlakemalawi