Review and Alignment of Domain-Level Ontologies for Materials Science

The growing complexity and interdisciplinary nature of Materials Science research demand efficient data management and exchange through structured knowledge representation. Domain-Level Ontologies (DLOs) for Materials Science have emerged as a valuable tool for describing materials properties, proce...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:IEEE Access
Main Authors: Anne De Baas, Pierluigi Del Nostro, Jesper Friis, Emanuele Ghedini, Gerhard Goldbeck, Ilaria Maria Paponetti, Andrea Pozzi, Arkopaul Sarkar, Lan Yang, Francesco Antonio Zaccarini, Daniele Toti
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: IEEE 2023-01-01
Subjects:
Online Access:https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/10296887/
_version_ 1850083528888287232
author Anne De Baas
Pierluigi Del Nostro
Jesper Friis
Emanuele Ghedini
Gerhard Goldbeck
Ilaria Maria Paponetti
Andrea Pozzi
Arkopaul Sarkar
Lan Yang
Francesco Antonio Zaccarini
Daniele Toti
author_facet Anne De Baas
Pierluigi Del Nostro
Jesper Friis
Emanuele Ghedini
Gerhard Goldbeck
Ilaria Maria Paponetti
Andrea Pozzi
Arkopaul Sarkar
Lan Yang
Francesco Antonio Zaccarini
Daniele Toti
author_sort Anne De Baas
collection DOAJ
container_title IEEE Access
description The growing complexity and interdisciplinary nature of Materials Science research demand efficient data management and exchange through structured knowledge representation. Domain-Level Ontologies (DLOs) for Materials Science have emerged as a valuable tool for describing materials properties, processes, and structures, enabling effective data integration, interoperability, and knowledge discovery. However, the harmonization of DLOs, and, more generally, the establishment of fully interoperable multi-level ecosystems, remains a challenge due to various factors, including the diverse landscape of existing ontologies. This work provides, for the first time in literature, a comprehensive overview of the state-of-the-art of DLOs for Materials Science, reviewing more than 40 DLOs and highlighting their main features and purposes. Furthermore, an alignment methodology including both manual and automated steps, making use of Top-Level Ontologies’ (TLO) capability of promoting interoperability, and revolving around the engineering of FAIR standalone entities acting as minimal data pipelines (“bridge concepts”), is presented. A proof of concept is also provided. The primary aspiration of this undertaking is to make a meaningful contribution towards the establishment of a unified ontology framework for Materials Science, facilitating more effective data integration and fostering interoperability across Materials Science subdomains.
format Article
id doaj-art-ef92ce8ad85a4d2fb4477a64b2cdfdcd
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 2169-3536
language English
publishDate 2023-01-01
publisher IEEE
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-ef92ce8ad85a4d2fb4477a64b2cdfdcd2025-08-20T00:11:47ZengIEEEIEEE Access2169-35362023-01-011112037212040110.1109/ACCESS.2023.332772510296887Review and Alignment of Domain-Level Ontologies for Materials ScienceAnne De Baas0https://orcid.org/0009-0007-5850-6628Pierluigi Del Nostro1https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5174-8508Jesper Friis2Emanuele Ghedini3https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3805-8761Gerhard Goldbeck4https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4181-2852Ilaria Maria Paponetti5Andrea Pozzi6https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9808-5123Arkopaul Sarkar7Lan Yang8Francesco Antonio Zaccarini9https://orcid.org/0009-0008-8009-5009Daniele Toti10https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9668-6961Goldbeck Consulting Ltd., St. John’s Innovation Centre, Cambridge, U.K.Goldbeck Consulting Ltd., St. John’s Innovation Centre, Cambridge, U.K.SINTEF AS, Trondheim, NorwayAlma Mater Studiorum, University of Bologna, Bologna, ItalyGoldbeck Consulting Ltd., St. John’s Innovation Centre, Cambridge, U.K.Alma Mater Studiorum, University of Bologna, Bologna, ItalyFaculty of Mathematical, Physical and Natural Sciences, Catholic University of the Sacred Heart, Brescia, ItalyEcole Nationale d’Ingénieurs de Tarbes, Institute for Corrosion and Multiphase Technology, Tarbes, FranceInsight SFI Research Centre for Data Analytics, Data Science Institute, University of Galway, Galway, IrelandAlma Mater Studiorum, University of Bologna, Bologna, ItalyGoldbeck Consulting Ltd., St. John’s Innovation Centre, Cambridge, U.K.The growing complexity and interdisciplinary nature of Materials Science research demand efficient data management and exchange through structured knowledge representation. Domain-Level Ontologies (DLOs) for Materials Science have emerged as a valuable tool for describing materials properties, processes, and structures, enabling effective data integration, interoperability, and knowledge discovery. However, the harmonization of DLOs, and, more generally, the establishment of fully interoperable multi-level ecosystems, remains a challenge due to various factors, including the diverse landscape of existing ontologies. This work provides, for the first time in literature, a comprehensive overview of the state-of-the-art of DLOs for Materials Science, reviewing more than 40 DLOs and highlighting their main features and purposes. Furthermore, an alignment methodology including both manual and automated steps, making use of Top-Level Ontologies’ (TLO) capability of promoting interoperability, and revolving around the engineering of FAIR standalone entities acting as minimal data pipelines (“bridge concepts”), is presented. A proof of concept is also provided. The primary aspiration of this undertaking is to make a meaningful contribution towards the establishment of a unified ontology framework for Materials Science, facilitating more effective data integration and fostering interoperability across Materials Science subdomains.https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/10296887/Ontologydomain-level ontologytop-level ontologyalignmentdataharmonization
spellingShingle Anne De Baas
Pierluigi Del Nostro
Jesper Friis
Emanuele Ghedini
Gerhard Goldbeck
Ilaria Maria Paponetti
Andrea Pozzi
Arkopaul Sarkar
Lan Yang
Francesco Antonio Zaccarini
Daniele Toti
Review and Alignment of Domain-Level Ontologies for Materials Science
Ontology
domain-level ontology
top-level ontology
alignment
data
harmonization
title Review and Alignment of Domain-Level Ontologies for Materials Science
title_full Review and Alignment of Domain-Level Ontologies for Materials Science
title_fullStr Review and Alignment of Domain-Level Ontologies for Materials Science
title_full_unstemmed Review and Alignment of Domain-Level Ontologies for Materials Science
title_short Review and Alignment of Domain-Level Ontologies for Materials Science
title_sort review and alignment of domain level ontologies for materials science
topic Ontology
domain-level ontology
top-level ontology
alignment
data
harmonization
url https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/10296887/
work_keys_str_mv AT annedebaas reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT pierluigidelnostro reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT jesperfriis reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT emanueleghedini reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT gerhardgoldbeck reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT ilariamariapaponetti reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT andreapozzi reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT arkopaulsarkar reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT lanyang reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT francescoantoniozaccarini reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience
AT danieletoti reviewandalignmentofdomainlevelontologiesformaterialsscience