Fracture rate and time to fracture in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma receiving finely fractionated compared to coarsely fractionated radiation therapy: A single institution study

Abstract Background Radiation therapy (RT) is used for local pain alleviation in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma (OS), especially among dogs that are poor surgical candidates for amputation. However, many historical reports of fractionated protocols lack time to fracture and fracture rates. Obje...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Veterinary Medicine and Science
Main Authors: Carissa J. Norquest, Charles A. Maitz, Deborah A. Keys, Melanie Moore, Jeffrey N. Bryan, Tara J. Ehling, Jimmy C. Lattimer, Brian K. Flesner
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Wiley 2022-05-01
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1002/vms3.782
_version_ 1850410774106734592
author Carissa J. Norquest
Charles A. Maitz
Deborah A. Keys
Melanie Moore
Jeffrey N. Bryan
Tara J. Ehling
Jimmy C. Lattimer
Brian K. Flesner
author_facet Carissa J. Norquest
Charles A. Maitz
Deborah A. Keys
Melanie Moore
Jeffrey N. Bryan
Tara J. Ehling
Jimmy C. Lattimer
Brian K. Flesner
author_sort Carissa J. Norquest
collection DOAJ
container_title Veterinary Medicine and Science
description Abstract Background Radiation therapy (RT) is used for local pain alleviation in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma (OS), especially among dogs that are poor surgical candidates for amputation. However, many historical reports of fractionated protocols lack time to fracture and fracture rates. Objectives The primary objectives of this retrospective study were to determine fracture rate and time to fracture of dogs receiving RT (coarse or fine fractionated) for appendicular OS. Secondary objectives were to evaluate tolerability and disease outcome measures. Methods Fifty‐one dogs that received RT as part of treatment for appendicular OS were available for evaluation. Forty‐five received coarse fractionation (C‐RT, 8 or 6 Gy per fraction protocols [C‐RT8 or C‐RT6]) while the remaining six received fine fractionation (F‐RT). Results The overall pathologic fracture rate was 37%. Pathologic fracture rate was significantly higher for dogs that received F‐RT (5/6, 83%) compared to dogs that received C‐RT (12/40, 30%, p = 0.021). In the 17 dogs that fractured, the overall median time to fracture was 57 days. For all dogs, the median progression free interval (PFI) and median overall survival time (OST) were 90 and 140 days, respectively. In a very small cohort of dogs (n = 7) treated with zoledronate and RT, fracture rate was 0% and extended survival times were noted. Conclusions In conclusion, C‐RT is recommended over F‐RT due to lower risk of pathologic fracture and similar PFI. Prospective evaluation of combined C‐RT and zoledronate, especially for dogs with poor surgical candidacy, is warranted for the treatment of canine appendicular osteosarcoma.
format Article
id doaj-art-faee43ee59bf42c7aec3a7afa491e82b
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 2053-1095
language English
publishDate 2022-05-01
publisher Wiley
record_format Article
spelling doaj-art-faee43ee59bf42c7aec3a7afa491e82b2025-08-19T22:46:48ZengWileyVeterinary Medicine and Science2053-10952022-05-01831013102410.1002/vms3.782Fracture rate and time to fracture in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma receiving finely fractionated compared to coarsely fractionated radiation therapy: A single institution studyCarissa J. Norquest0Charles A. Maitz1Deborah A. Keys2Melanie Moore3Jeffrey N. Bryan4Tara J. Ehling5Jimmy C. Lattimer6Brian K. Flesner7Veterinary Health Center University of Missouri Columbia MissouriVeterinary Health Center University of Missouri Columbia MissouriKaleidoscope Statistics LLC Athens GeorgiaVeterinary Health Center University of Missouri Columbia MissouriVeterinary Health Center University of Missouri Columbia MissouriVeterinary Health Center at Wentzville University of Missouri Wentzville MissouriVeterinary Health Center University of Missouri Columbia MissouriVeterinary Health Center University of Missouri Columbia MissouriAbstract Background Radiation therapy (RT) is used for local pain alleviation in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma (OS), especially among dogs that are poor surgical candidates for amputation. However, many historical reports of fractionated protocols lack time to fracture and fracture rates. Objectives The primary objectives of this retrospective study were to determine fracture rate and time to fracture of dogs receiving RT (coarse or fine fractionated) for appendicular OS. Secondary objectives were to evaluate tolerability and disease outcome measures. Methods Fifty‐one dogs that received RT as part of treatment for appendicular OS were available for evaluation. Forty‐five received coarse fractionation (C‐RT, 8 or 6 Gy per fraction protocols [C‐RT8 or C‐RT6]) while the remaining six received fine fractionation (F‐RT). Results The overall pathologic fracture rate was 37%. Pathologic fracture rate was significantly higher for dogs that received F‐RT (5/6, 83%) compared to dogs that received C‐RT (12/40, 30%, p = 0.021). In the 17 dogs that fractured, the overall median time to fracture was 57 days. For all dogs, the median progression free interval (PFI) and median overall survival time (OST) were 90 and 140 days, respectively. In a very small cohort of dogs (n = 7) treated with zoledronate and RT, fracture rate was 0% and extended survival times were noted. Conclusions In conclusion, C‐RT is recommended over F‐RT due to lower risk of pathologic fracture and similar PFI. Prospective evaluation of combined C‐RT and zoledronate, especially for dogs with poor surgical candidacy, is warranted for the treatment of canine appendicular osteosarcoma.https://doi.org/10.1002/vms3.782canineosteosarcomapathologic fractureradiation therapyzoledronate
spellingShingle Carissa J. Norquest
Charles A. Maitz
Deborah A. Keys
Melanie Moore
Jeffrey N. Bryan
Tara J. Ehling
Jimmy C. Lattimer
Brian K. Flesner
Fracture rate and time to fracture in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma receiving finely fractionated compared to coarsely fractionated radiation therapy: A single institution study
canine
osteosarcoma
pathologic fracture
radiation therapy
zoledronate
title Fracture rate and time to fracture in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma receiving finely fractionated compared to coarsely fractionated radiation therapy: A single institution study
title_full Fracture rate and time to fracture in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma receiving finely fractionated compared to coarsely fractionated radiation therapy: A single institution study
title_fullStr Fracture rate and time to fracture in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma receiving finely fractionated compared to coarsely fractionated radiation therapy: A single institution study
title_full_unstemmed Fracture rate and time to fracture in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma receiving finely fractionated compared to coarsely fractionated radiation therapy: A single institution study
title_short Fracture rate and time to fracture in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma receiving finely fractionated compared to coarsely fractionated radiation therapy: A single institution study
title_sort fracture rate and time to fracture in dogs with appendicular osteosarcoma receiving finely fractionated compared to coarsely fractionated radiation therapy a single institution study
topic canine
osteosarcoma
pathologic fracture
radiation therapy
zoledronate
url https://doi.org/10.1002/vms3.782
work_keys_str_mv AT carissajnorquest fracturerateandtimetofractureindogswithappendicularosteosarcomareceivingfinelyfractionatedcomparedtocoarselyfractionatedradiationtherapyasingleinstitutionstudy
AT charlesamaitz fracturerateandtimetofractureindogswithappendicularosteosarcomareceivingfinelyfractionatedcomparedtocoarselyfractionatedradiationtherapyasingleinstitutionstudy
AT deborahakeys fracturerateandtimetofractureindogswithappendicularosteosarcomareceivingfinelyfractionatedcomparedtocoarselyfractionatedradiationtherapyasingleinstitutionstudy
AT melaniemoore fracturerateandtimetofractureindogswithappendicularosteosarcomareceivingfinelyfractionatedcomparedtocoarselyfractionatedradiationtherapyasingleinstitutionstudy
AT jeffreynbryan fracturerateandtimetofractureindogswithappendicularosteosarcomareceivingfinelyfractionatedcomparedtocoarselyfractionatedradiationtherapyasingleinstitutionstudy
AT tarajehling fracturerateandtimetofractureindogswithappendicularosteosarcomareceivingfinelyfractionatedcomparedtocoarselyfractionatedradiationtherapyasingleinstitutionstudy
AT jimmyclattimer fracturerateandtimetofractureindogswithappendicularosteosarcomareceivingfinelyfractionatedcomparedtocoarselyfractionatedradiationtherapyasingleinstitutionstudy
AT briankflesner fracturerateandtimetofractureindogswithappendicularosteosarcomareceivingfinelyfractionatedcomparedtocoarselyfractionatedradiationtherapyasingleinstitutionstudy