Comparison of Trauma Scoring Systems in Pediatric Trauma Patients

Aim:We aimed to evaluate and compare the performance of BIG score (Base deficit, INR, GCS), pediatric trauma score, revised trauma score, injury severity score, new injury severity score (NISS) in mortality and stay intensive care unit.Materials and Methods:One thousand five hundred ten pediatric pa...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Published in:Eurasian Journal of Emergency Medicine
Main Authors: Hasan Sultanoğlu, Seda Özkan, Tuba Erdem Sultanoğlu, Nezih Kavak
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Emergency Medicine Physicians’ Association of Turkey 2019-03-01
Subjects:
Online Access: http://akademikaciltip.com/archives/archive-detail/article-preview/comparison-of-trauma-scoring-systems-in-pediatric-/24284
_version_ 1848651015267549184
author Hasan Sultanoğlu
Seda Özkan
Tuba Erdem Sultanoğlu
Nezih Kavak
author_facet Hasan Sultanoğlu
Seda Özkan
Tuba Erdem Sultanoğlu
Nezih Kavak
author_sort Hasan Sultanoğlu
collection DOAJ
container_title Eurasian Journal of Emergency Medicine
description Aim:We aimed to evaluate and compare the performance of BIG score (Base deficit, INR, GCS), pediatric trauma score, revised trauma score, injury severity score, new injury severity score (NISS) in mortality and stay intensive care unit.Materials and Methods:One thousand five hundred ten pediatric patients aged less than 18 years who were admitted to the emergency department with multi-trauma between 1 July 2012 and 1 July 2016 were included in the retrospective research. Demographic data, vital signs in the emergency department, trauma location, injury severity indexes and follow up of patients were examined.Results:One thousand five hundred ten patients were included, 40.5% were female and 59.5% were male. Mean age was 7.81±4.8; mortality was 4.2%. The best score to evaluate mortality was “probability of survival 2014 (PS14)”. The best score to force the stay in ICU was found as NISS, the most sensitive system was NISS and PS14 (94.9%) and the most specific was NISS (86.7). PS14 was the first to evaluate the survival. In our research, 94.3% of patient had blunt trauma and 5.7% had penetrating trauma. PS14 was found the best score to determine survival and mortality for blunt trauma patients.Conclusion:Although all scoring systems appeared similarly predictive among pediatric trauma patients, The PS14 score was more predictive for mortality and survival, and the NISS score for the need of intensive care admission. The NISS score was the most predictive score for intensive care admission in blunt and penetrating traumas combined. Particularly the newly developed PS14 score can be used as a powerfully predictive scoring system for outcomes among all pediatric trauma patients, irrespective of trauma mechanism.
format Article
id doaj-eefd73a67b3840c38ff7b9b66a93ef74
institution Directory of Open Access Journals
issn 2149-5807
2149-6048
language English
publishDate 2019-03-01
publisher Emergency Medicine Physicians’ Association of Turkey
record_format Article
spelling doaj-eefd73a67b3840c38ff7b9b66a93ef742025-11-03T01:42:15ZengEmergency Medicine Physicians’ Association of TurkeyEurasian Journal of Emergency Medicine2149-58072149-60482019-03-011811810.4274/eajem.galenos.2018.9483013049054Comparison of Trauma Scoring Systems in Pediatric Trauma PatientsHasan Sultanoğlu0Seda Özkan1Tuba Erdem Sultanoğlu2Nezih Kavak3 Clinic of Emergency Medicine, Dr. Ersin Arslan Training and Research Hospital, Gaziantep, Turkey Clinic of Emergency Medicine, Dışkapı Training and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey Clinic of Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation, Şehitkamil State Hospital, Gaziantep, Turkey Clinic of Emergency Medicine, Dışkapı Training and Research Hospital, Ankara, Turkey Aim:We aimed to evaluate and compare the performance of BIG score (Base deficit, INR, GCS), pediatric trauma score, revised trauma score, injury severity score, new injury severity score (NISS) in mortality and stay intensive care unit.Materials and Methods:One thousand five hundred ten pediatric patients aged less than 18 years who were admitted to the emergency department with multi-trauma between 1 July 2012 and 1 July 2016 were included in the retrospective research. Demographic data, vital signs in the emergency department, trauma location, injury severity indexes and follow up of patients were examined.Results:One thousand five hundred ten patients were included, 40.5% were female and 59.5% were male. Mean age was 7.81±4.8; mortality was 4.2%. The best score to evaluate mortality was “probability of survival 2014 (PS14)”. The best score to force the stay in ICU was found as NISS, the most sensitive system was NISS and PS14 (94.9%) and the most specific was NISS (86.7). PS14 was the first to evaluate the survival. In our research, 94.3% of patient had blunt trauma and 5.7% had penetrating trauma. PS14 was found the best score to determine survival and mortality for blunt trauma patients.Conclusion:Although all scoring systems appeared similarly predictive among pediatric trauma patients, The PS14 score was more predictive for mortality and survival, and the NISS score for the need of intensive care admission. The NISS score was the most predictive score for intensive care admission in blunt and penetrating traumas combined. Particularly the newly developed PS14 score can be used as a powerfully predictive scoring system for outcomes among all pediatric trauma patients, irrespective of trauma mechanism. http://akademikaciltip.com/archives/archive-detail/article-preview/comparison-of-trauma-scoring-systems-in-pediatric-/24284 Pediatric traumatrauma scoresBIGprobability of survival 2014pediatric trauma scorerevised trauma scoreinjury severity scorenew injury severity score
spellingShingle Hasan Sultanoğlu
Seda Özkan
Tuba Erdem Sultanoğlu
Nezih Kavak
Comparison of Trauma Scoring Systems in Pediatric Trauma Patients
Pediatric trauma
trauma scores
BIG
probability of survival 2014
pediatric trauma score
revised trauma score
injury severity score
new injury severity score
title Comparison of Trauma Scoring Systems in Pediatric Trauma Patients
title_full Comparison of Trauma Scoring Systems in Pediatric Trauma Patients
title_fullStr Comparison of Trauma Scoring Systems in Pediatric Trauma Patients
title_full_unstemmed Comparison of Trauma Scoring Systems in Pediatric Trauma Patients
title_short Comparison of Trauma Scoring Systems in Pediatric Trauma Patients
title_sort comparison of trauma scoring systems in pediatric trauma patients
topic Pediatric trauma
trauma scores
BIG
probability of survival 2014
pediatric trauma score
revised trauma score
injury severity score
new injury severity score
url http://akademikaciltip.com/archives/archive-detail/article-preview/comparison-of-trauma-scoring-systems-in-pediatric-/24284
work_keys_str_mv AT hasansultanoglu comparisonoftraumascoringsystemsinpediatrictraumapatients
AT sedaozkan comparisonoftraumascoringsystemsinpediatrictraumapatients
AT tubaerdemsultanoglu comparisonoftraumascoringsystemsinpediatrictraumapatients
AT nezihkavak comparisonoftraumascoringsystemsinpediatrictraumapatients