12th–19th century craniological remnants from the Central Caucasus region

This paper presents the analysis of a craniological series from the Republic of Ingushetia (Lezhg, Jegikal villages), South Ossetia (Verhnij Rokk, Verhnej Erman, Srednij Erman villages) and the Chechen Republic (Staraja Sunzha village) conducted using modern morphologic methods. The research is bas...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Pugacheva E.V.
Format: Article
Language:Russian
Published: Tyumen Scientific Centre SB RA 2018-09-01
Series:Вестник археологии, антропологии и этнографии
Subjects:
Online Access:http://www.ipdn.ru/va-en/_private/a42/enga42-2-1.htm
id doaj-02cc6ccf1d574003b15ab9c0635ba9d8
record_format Article
spelling doaj-02cc6ccf1d574003b15ab9c0635ba9d82020-11-24T21:21:34ZrusTyumen Scientific Centre SB RAВестник археологии, антропологии и этнографии1811-74652071-04372018-09-013(42)727810.20874/2071-0437-2018-42-3-072-07812th–19th century craniological remnants from the Central Caucasus regionPugacheva E.V.0Saint-Petersburg State University This paper presents the analysis of a craniological series from the Republic of Ingushetia (Lezhg, Jegikal villages), South Ossetia (Verhnij Rokk, Verhnej Erman, Srednij Erman villages) and the Chechen Republic (Staraja Sunzha village) conducted using modern morphologic methods. The research is based on craniological materials from the MAE RAS (Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography of the Russian Academy of Sciences) collections that were gathered and described by V.V. Bunak in 1953. At that time, V.V. Bunak examined the material from the standpoint of the typological approach, giving great importance to the relative value of the cranial index. Therefore, it seems relevant to study the material within the framework of the population approach using modern me-thods. The aim of this paper is to classify the morphological characteristics of the Caucasian anthropological type using samples from two neighbouring groups (Ossetian and Ingush ones), which are analysed by two different methodologies. At the first stage, skulls were measured by a standard craniometric program. Subsequently, the obtained data was analysed by classical statistical methods (Mann — Whitney U test, Principal component analysis, Canonical discriminant analysis). At the second stage, the methods of geometric morphometry were applied for comparing the Procrustean distances by the principal component method (intragroup analysis) and the canonical discriminant analysis (intergroup analysis). The results of the geometric morphometry analysis have allowed us to trace the non-linear variation of the facial part of the skulls. The results obtained at both analytical stages have shown a good agreement. It is concluded that female groups are morphologically close to each other. Male groups show similarities between the Ingush and Ossetian materials. The craniological series from Staraya Sunzha is shown to be unique. Therefore, the majority of the craniological types identified by V.V. Bunak have not been confirmed by modern analytical methods, with the only exception being the male group from Staraya Sunzha.http://www.ipdn.ru/va-en/_private/a42/enga42-2-1.htmPhysical anthropologycraniologyCaucasusgeometric morphometricsburial vault
collection DOAJ
language Russian
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Pugacheva E.V.
spellingShingle Pugacheva E.V.
12th–19th century craniological remnants from the Central Caucasus region
Вестник археологии, антропологии и этнографии
Physical anthropology
craniology
Caucasus
geometric morphometrics
burial vault
author_facet Pugacheva E.V.
author_sort Pugacheva E.V.
title 12th–19th century craniological remnants from the Central Caucasus region
title_short 12th–19th century craniological remnants from the Central Caucasus region
title_full 12th–19th century craniological remnants from the Central Caucasus region
title_fullStr 12th–19th century craniological remnants from the Central Caucasus region
title_full_unstemmed 12th–19th century craniological remnants from the Central Caucasus region
title_sort 12th–19th century craniological remnants from the central caucasus region
publisher Tyumen Scientific Centre SB RA
series Вестник археологии, антропологии и этнографии
issn 1811-7465
2071-0437
publishDate 2018-09-01
description This paper presents the analysis of a craniological series from the Republic of Ingushetia (Lezhg, Jegikal villages), South Ossetia (Verhnij Rokk, Verhnej Erman, Srednij Erman villages) and the Chechen Republic (Staraja Sunzha village) conducted using modern morphologic methods. The research is based on craniological materials from the MAE RAS (Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography of the Russian Academy of Sciences) collections that were gathered and described by V.V. Bunak in 1953. At that time, V.V. Bunak examined the material from the standpoint of the typological approach, giving great importance to the relative value of the cranial index. Therefore, it seems relevant to study the material within the framework of the population approach using modern me-thods. The aim of this paper is to classify the morphological characteristics of the Caucasian anthropological type using samples from two neighbouring groups (Ossetian and Ingush ones), which are analysed by two different methodologies. At the first stage, skulls were measured by a standard craniometric program. Subsequently, the obtained data was analysed by classical statistical methods (Mann — Whitney U test, Principal component analysis, Canonical discriminant analysis). At the second stage, the methods of geometric morphometry were applied for comparing the Procrustean distances by the principal component method (intragroup analysis) and the canonical discriminant analysis (intergroup analysis). The results of the geometric morphometry analysis have allowed us to trace the non-linear variation of the facial part of the skulls. The results obtained at both analytical stages have shown a good agreement. It is concluded that female groups are morphologically close to each other. Male groups show similarities between the Ingush and Ossetian materials. The craniological series from Staraya Sunzha is shown to be unique. Therefore, the majority of the craniological types identified by V.V. Bunak have not been confirmed by modern analytical methods, with the only exception being the male group from Staraya Sunzha.
topic Physical anthropology
craniology
Caucasus
geometric morphometrics
burial vault
url http://www.ipdn.ru/va-en/_private/a42/enga42-2-1.htm
work_keys_str_mv AT pugachevaev 12th19thcenturycraniologicalremnantsfromthecentralcaucasusregion
_version_ 1725999351463936000