A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck "Leirvigen 1", Norway.
Although Scandinavian flint is one of the most important materials used for prehistoric stone tool production in Northern and Central Europe, a conclusive method for securely differentiating between flint sources, geologically bound to northern European chalk formations, has never been achieved. The...
Main Authors: | , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Public Library of Science (PLoS)
2018-01-01
|
Series: | PLoS ONE |
Online Access: | http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6082525?pdf=render |
id |
doaj-04746270a21c49fea10ccc3c8a39a56c |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-04746270a21c49fea10ccc3c8a39a56c2020-11-24T20:41:38ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032018-01-01138e020064710.1371/journal.pone.0200647A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck "Leirvigen 1", Norway.Michael BrandlMaria M MartinezChristoph HauzenbergerPeter FilzmoserPål NymoenNatascha MehlerAlthough Scandinavian flint is one of the most important materials used for prehistoric stone tool production in Northern and Central Europe, a conclusive method for securely differentiating between flint sources, geologically bound to northern European chalk formations, has never been achieved. The main problems with traditional approaches concern the oftentimes high similarities of SiO2 raw materials (i.e. chert and flint) on different scales due to similar genetic conditions and higher intra- than inter-source variation. Conventional chert and flint provenance studies chiefly concentrate on visual, petrographic or geochemical investigations. Hence, attempts to generate characteristic fingerprints of particular chert raw materials were in most cases unsatisfying. Here we show that the Multi Layered Chert Sourcing Approach (MLA) achieves a clear differentiation between primary sources of Scandinavian flint. The MLA combines visual comparative studies, stereo-microscopic analyses of microfossil inclusions, geochemical trace element analyses applying LA-ICP-MS (Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry) and statistical analyses through CODA (Compositional Data Analysis). For archaeologists, provenance studies are the gateway to advance interpretations of economic behavior expressed in resource management strategies entailing the procurement, use and distribution of lithic raw materials. We demonstrate the relevance of our results for archaeological materials in a case study in which we were able to differentiate between Scandinavian flint sources and establish the provenance of historic ballast flint from a shipwreck found near Kristiansand close to the shore of southern Norway from a beach source in Northern Jutland, the Vigsø Bay.http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6082525?pdf=render |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Michael Brandl Maria M Martinez Christoph Hauzenberger Peter Filzmoser Pål Nymoen Natascha Mehler |
spellingShingle |
Michael Brandl Maria M Martinez Christoph Hauzenberger Peter Filzmoser Pål Nymoen Natascha Mehler A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck "Leirvigen 1", Norway. PLoS ONE |
author_facet |
Michael Brandl Maria M Martinez Christoph Hauzenberger Peter Filzmoser Pål Nymoen Natascha Mehler |
author_sort |
Michael Brandl |
title |
A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck "Leirvigen 1", Norway. |
title_short |
A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck "Leirvigen 1", Norway. |
title_full |
A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck "Leirvigen 1", Norway. |
title_fullStr |
A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck "Leirvigen 1", Norway. |
title_full_unstemmed |
A multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing Scandinavian flint: Provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck "Leirvigen 1", Norway. |
title_sort |
multi-technique analytical approach to sourcing scandinavian flint: provenance of ballast flint from the shipwreck "leirvigen 1", norway. |
publisher |
Public Library of Science (PLoS) |
series |
PLoS ONE |
issn |
1932-6203 |
publishDate |
2018-01-01 |
description |
Although Scandinavian flint is one of the most important materials used for prehistoric stone tool production in Northern and Central Europe, a conclusive method for securely differentiating between flint sources, geologically bound to northern European chalk formations, has never been achieved. The main problems with traditional approaches concern the oftentimes high similarities of SiO2 raw materials (i.e. chert and flint) on different scales due to similar genetic conditions and higher intra- than inter-source variation. Conventional chert and flint provenance studies chiefly concentrate on visual, petrographic or geochemical investigations. Hence, attempts to generate characteristic fingerprints of particular chert raw materials were in most cases unsatisfying. Here we show that the Multi Layered Chert Sourcing Approach (MLA) achieves a clear differentiation between primary sources of Scandinavian flint. The MLA combines visual comparative studies, stereo-microscopic analyses of microfossil inclusions, geochemical trace element analyses applying LA-ICP-MS (Laser Ablation Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry) and statistical analyses through CODA (Compositional Data Analysis). For archaeologists, provenance studies are the gateway to advance interpretations of economic behavior expressed in resource management strategies entailing the procurement, use and distribution of lithic raw materials. We demonstrate the relevance of our results for archaeological materials in a case study in which we were able to differentiate between Scandinavian flint sources and establish the provenance of historic ballast flint from a shipwreck found near Kristiansand close to the shore of southern Norway from a beach source in Northern Jutland, the Vigsø Bay. |
url |
http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC6082525?pdf=render |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT michaelbrandl amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT mariammartinez amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT christophhauzenberger amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT peterfilzmoser amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT palnymoen amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT nataschamehler amultitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT michaelbrandl multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT mariammartinez multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT christophhauzenberger multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT peterfilzmoser multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT palnymoen multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway AT nataschamehler multitechniqueanalyticalapproachtosourcingscandinavianflintprovenanceofballastflintfromtheshipwreckleirvigen1norway |
_version_ |
1716824418165981184 |