A pragmatic protocol for characterising errors in atmospheric inversions of methane emissions over Europe

This study aims at estimating errors to be accounted for in atmospheric inversions of methane (CH4) emissions at the European scale. Four types of errors are estimated in the concentration space over the model domain and at selected measurement sites. Furthermore, errors in emission inventories are...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Barbara Szénási, Antoine Berchet, Grégoire Broquet, Arjo Segers, Hugo Denier van der Gon, Maarten Krol, Joanna J.S. Hullegie, Anja Kiesow, Dirk Günther, Ana Maria Roxana Petrescu, Marielle Saunois, Philippe Bousquet, Isabelle Pison
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Taylor & Francis Group 2021-01-01
Series:Tellus: Series B, Chemical and Physical Meteorology
Subjects:
Online Access:http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/16000889.2021.1914989
id doaj-0ec7cd23873e4f139945a8061eb38a47
record_format Article
spelling doaj-0ec7cd23873e4f139945a8061eb38a472021-05-13T09:30:28ZengTaylor & Francis GroupTellus: Series B, Chemical and Physical Meteorology1600-08892021-01-0173112310.1080/16000889.2021.19149891914989A pragmatic protocol for characterising errors in atmospheric inversions of methane emissions over EuropeBarbara Szénási0Antoine Berchet1Grégoire Broquet2Arjo Segers3Hugo Denier van der Gon4Maarten Krol5Joanna J.S. Hullegie6Anja Kiesow7Dirk Günther8Ana Maria Roxana Petrescu9Marielle Saunois10Philippe Bousquet11Isabelle Pison12Laboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l’Environnement, LSCE-IPSL (CEA-CNRS-UVSQ), Université Paris-SaclayLaboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l’Environnement, LSCE-IPSL (CEA-CNRS-UVSQ), Université Paris-SaclayLaboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l’Environnement, LSCE-IPSL (CEA-CNRS-UVSQ), Université Paris-SaclayTNO, Department of Climate, Air and SustainabilityTNO, Department of Climate, Air and SustainabilityWageningen University & ResearchTNO, Department of Climate, Air and SustainabilityGerman Environment Agency, Unit Emission SituationGerman Environment Agency, Unit Emission SituationDepartment of Earth and Life Sciences, Faculty of Science, Vrije Universiteit AmsterdamLaboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l’Environnement, LSCE-IPSL (CEA-CNRS-UVSQ), Université Paris-SaclayLaboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l’Environnement, LSCE-IPSL (CEA-CNRS-UVSQ), Université Paris-SaclayLaboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l’Environnement, LSCE-IPSL (CEA-CNRS-UVSQ), Université Paris-SaclayThis study aims at estimating errors to be accounted for in atmospheric inversions of methane (CH4) emissions at the European scale. Four types of errors are estimated in the concentration space over the model domain and at selected measurement sites. Furthermore, errors in emission inventories are estimated at country and source sector scales. A technically ready method is used, which is implemented by running a set of simulations of hourly CH4 mixing ratios for 2015 using two area-limited transport models at three horizontal resolutions with multiple data sets of emissions and boundary and initial conditions as inputs. The obtained error estimates provide insights into how these errors could be treated in an inverse modelling system for inverting CH4 emissions over Europe. The main results show that sources of transport errors may better be controlled alongside the emissions, which differs from usual inversion practices. The average total concentration error is estimated at 29 ppb. The assessed error of total CH4 emissions is 22% and emission errors are heterogeneous at sector (23–49%) and country scales (16–124%), with largest errors occurring in the waste sector due to uncertainties in activity data and emission factors and in Finland due to uncertainties in natural wetland emissions.http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/16000889.2021.1914989methaneeuropeerror estimationatmospheric inversion
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Barbara Szénási
Antoine Berchet
Grégoire Broquet
Arjo Segers
Hugo Denier van der Gon
Maarten Krol
Joanna J.S. Hullegie
Anja Kiesow
Dirk Günther
Ana Maria Roxana Petrescu
Marielle Saunois
Philippe Bousquet
Isabelle Pison
spellingShingle Barbara Szénási
Antoine Berchet
Grégoire Broquet
Arjo Segers
Hugo Denier van der Gon
Maarten Krol
Joanna J.S. Hullegie
Anja Kiesow
Dirk Günther
Ana Maria Roxana Petrescu
Marielle Saunois
Philippe Bousquet
Isabelle Pison
A pragmatic protocol for characterising errors in atmospheric inversions of methane emissions over Europe
Tellus: Series B, Chemical and Physical Meteorology
methane
europe
error estimation
atmospheric inversion
author_facet Barbara Szénási
Antoine Berchet
Grégoire Broquet
Arjo Segers
Hugo Denier van der Gon
Maarten Krol
Joanna J.S. Hullegie
Anja Kiesow
Dirk Günther
Ana Maria Roxana Petrescu
Marielle Saunois
Philippe Bousquet
Isabelle Pison
author_sort Barbara Szénási
title A pragmatic protocol for characterising errors in atmospheric inversions of methane emissions over Europe
title_short A pragmatic protocol for characterising errors in atmospheric inversions of methane emissions over Europe
title_full A pragmatic protocol for characterising errors in atmospheric inversions of methane emissions over Europe
title_fullStr A pragmatic protocol for characterising errors in atmospheric inversions of methane emissions over Europe
title_full_unstemmed A pragmatic protocol for characterising errors in atmospheric inversions of methane emissions over Europe
title_sort pragmatic protocol for characterising errors in atmospheric inversions of methane emissions over europe
publisher Taylor & Francis Group
series Tellus: Series B, Chemical and Physical Meteorology
issn 1600-0889
publishDate 2021-01-01
description This study aims at estimating errors to be accounted for in atmospheric inversions of methane (CH4) emissions at the European scale. Four types of errors are estimated in the concentration space over the model domain and at selected measurement sites. Furthermore, errors in emission inventories are estimated at country and source sector scales. A technically ready method is used, which is implemented by running a set of simulations of hourly CH4 mixing ratios for 2015 using two area-limited transport models at three horizontal resolutions with multiple data sets of emissions and boundary and initial conditions as inputs. The obtained error estimates provide insights into how these errors could be treated in an inverse modelling system for inverting CH4 emissions over Europe. The main results show that sources of transport errors may better be controlled alongside the emissions, which differs from usual inversion practices. The average total concentration error is estimated at 29 ppb. The assessed error of total CH4 emissions is 22% and emission errors are heterogeneous at sector (23–49%) and country scales (16–124%), with largest errors occurring in the waste sector due to uncertainties in activity data and emission factors and in Finland due to uncertainties in natural wetland emissions.
topic methane
europe
error estimation
atmospheric inversion
url http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/16000889.2021.1914989
work_keys_str_mv AT barbaraszenasi apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT antoineberchet apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT gregoirebroquet apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT arjosegers apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT hugodeniervandergon apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT maartenkrol apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT joannajshullegie apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT anjakiesow apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT dirkgunther apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT anamariaroxanapetrescu apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT mariellesaunois apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT philippebousquet apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT isabellepison apragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT barbaraszenasi pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT antoineberchet pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT gregoirebroquet pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT arjosegers pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT hugodeniervandergon pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT maartenkrol pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT joannajshullegie pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT anjakiesow pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT dirkgunther pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT anamariaroxanapetrescu pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT mariellesaunois pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT philippebousquet pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
AT isabellepison pragmaticprotocolforcharacterisingerrorsinatmosphericinversionsofmethaneemissionsovereurope
_version_ 1721442280899870720