Feasibility of comprehensive genotyping specimens from radial endobronchial ultrasonography and electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy

Introduction Mini-invasive bronchoscopic techniques (such as radial endobronchial ultrasonography (rEBUS) and electromagnetic navigation (EMN)) have been developed to reach the peripheral lung but result in small samples. The feasibility of an adequate molecular testing from these specimens has been...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Maxime Robin, Laurent Mhanna, Leonor Chaltiel, Gavin Plat, Valentin Héluain, Céline Basset, Julie Meilleroux, Thomas Filleron, Julien Mazières, Christophe Hermant, Nicolas Guibert
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: European Respiratory Society 2021-07-01
Series:ERJ Open Research
Online Access:http://openres.ersjournals.com/content/7/3/00942-2020.full
id doaj-15ac3399989f4c8fb0de107746ff48e1
record_format Article
spelling doaj-15ac3399989f4c8fb0de107746ff48e12021-10-04T13:41:21ZengEuropean Respiratory SocietyERJ Open Research2312-05412021-07-017310.1183/23120541.00942-202000942-2020Feasibility of comprehensive genotyping specimens from radial endobronchial ultrasonography and electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopyMaxime Robin0Laurent Mhanna1Leonor Chaltiel2Gavin Plat3Valentin Héluain4Céline Basset5Julie Meilleroux6Thomas Filleron7Julien Mazières8Christophe Hermant9Nicolas Guibert10 Pulmonology Dept, Larrey University Hospital, Toulouse, France Pulmonology Dept, Larrey University Hospital, Toulouse, France Biostatistics Dept, Institut Claudius Regaud, Toulouse University Cancer Institute (IUCT-O), Toulouse, France Pulmonology Dept, Larrey University Hospital, Toulouse, France Pulmonology Dept, Larrey University Hospital, Toulouse, France Cytology Dept, IUCT-O, Toulouse, France Pathology Dept, IUCT-O, Toulouse, France Biostatistics Dept, Institut Claudius Regaud, Toulouse University Cancer Institute (IUCT-O), Toulouse, France Pulmonology Dept, Larrey University Hospital, Toulouse, France Pulmonology Dept, Larrey University Hospital, Toulouse, France Pulmonology Dept, Larrey University Hospital, Toulouse, France Introduction Mini-invasive bronchoscopic techniques (such as radial endobronchial ultrasonography (rEBUS) and electromagnetic navigation (EMN)) have been developed to reach the peripheral lung but result in small samples. The feasibility of an adequate molecular testing from these specimens has been very little studied. Methods We retrospectively reviewed EMN and rEBUS procedures performed in patients diagnosed with lung cancer in our institution in 2017 and 2018. We analysed the sensitivity for rEBUS and EMN and each sampling method, and the feasibility of a comprehensive molecular testing. Results In total, 317 rEBUS and 14 EMN were performed. Median sizes of tumours were 16 and 32 mm for EMN and rEBUS, respectively. Overall sensitivity for rEBUS and EMN was 84.3%. Cytology was found to be complementary with biopsies, with 13.3% of cancer diagnosed on cytology while biopsies were negative. Complication rate was 2.4% (pneumothorax 1.5%, mild haemoptysis 0.9%). Genotyping (immunohistochemistry for ROS1 and ALK followed by fluorescence in situ hybridisation if positive and hybrid capture next-generation sequencing covering 48 genes), when ordered (n=188), was feasible in 69.1% (EGFR 17.7%, KRAS 31.7%, BRAF 4.8%, ALK 1.2%, MET 3.1%, HER2 0.8%). PD-L1 (programmed death-ligand 1) expression, when ordered (n=232), could be analysed in 94% of cases. Overall, 56.9% (33 out of 58) of patients for whom genotyping was not feasible underwent a second sampling (12 pretreatment, 21 at progression), allowing for the detection of six actionable genotypes (five EGFR, one MET). Conclusion rEBUS and EMN are sensitive and safe procedures that result in limited samples, often not suitable for genotyping, highlighting the importance of integrating liquid biopsy in routine testing.http://openres.ersjournals.com/content/7/3/00942-2020.full
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Maxime Robin
Laurent Mhanna
Leonor Chaltiel
Gavin Plat
Valentin Héluain
Céline Basset
Julie Meilleroux
Thomas Filleron
Julien Mazières
Christophe Hermant
Nicolas Guibert
spellingShingle Maxime Robin
Laurent Mhanna
Leonor Chaltiel
Gavin Plat
Valentin Héluain
Céline Basset
Julie Meilleroux
Thomas Filleron
Julien Mazières
Christophe Hermant
Nicolas Guibert
Feasibility of comprehensive genotyping specimens from radial endobronchial ultrasonography and electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy
ERJ Open Research
author_facet Maxime Robin
Laurent Mhanna
Leonor Chaltiel
Gavin Plat
Valentin Héluain
Céline Basset
Julie Meilleroux
Thomas Filleron
Julien Mazières
Christophe Hermant
Nicolas Guibert
author_sort Maxime Robin
title Feasibility of comprehensive genotyping specimens from radial endobronchial ultrasonography and electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy
title_short Feasibility of comprehensive genotyping specimens from radial endobronchial ultrasonography and electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy
title_full Feasibility of comprehensive genotyping specimens from radial endobronchial ultrasonography and electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy
title_fullStr Feasibility of comprehensive genotyping specimens from radial endobronchial ultrasonography and electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy
title_full_unstemmed Feasibility of comprehensive genotyping specimens from radial endobronchial ultrasonography and electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy
title_sort feasibility of comprehensive genotyping specimens from radial endobronchial ultrasonography and electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy
publisher European Respiratory Society
series ERJ Open Research
issn 2312-0541
publishDate 2021-07-01
description Introduction Mini-invasive bronchoscopic techniques (such as radial endobronchial ultrasonography (rEBUS) and electromagnetic navigation (EMN)) have been developed to reach the peripheral lung but result in small samples. The feasibility of an adequate molecular testing from these specimens has been very little studied. Methods We retrospectively reviewed EMN and rEBUS procedures performed in patients diagnosed with lung cancer in our institution in 2017 and 2018. We analysed the sensitivity for rEBUS and EMN and each sampling method, and the feasibility of a comprehensive molecular testing. Results In total, 317 rEBUS and 14 EMN were performed. Median sizes of tumours were 16 and 32 mm for EMN and rEBUS, respectively. Overall sensitivity for rEBUS and EMN was 84.3%. Cytology was found to be complementary with biopsies, with 13.3% of cancer diagnosed on cytology while biopsies were negative. Complication rate was 2.4% (pneumothorax 1.5%, mild haemoptysis 0.9%). Genotyping (immunohistochemistry for ROS1 and ALK followed by fluorescence in situ hybridisation if positive and hybrid capture next-generation sequencing covering 48 genes), when ordered (n=188), was feasible in 69.1% (EGFR 17.7%, KRAS 31.7%, BRAF 4.8%, ALK 1.2%, MET 3.1%, HER2 0.8%). PD-L1 (programmed death-ligand 1) expression, when ordered (n=232), could be analysed in 94% of cases. Overall, 56.9% (33 out of 58) of patients for whom genotyping was not feasible underwent a second sampling (12 pretreatment, 21 at progression), allowing for the detection of six actionable genotypes (five EGFR, one MET). Conclusion rEBUS and EMN are sensitive and safe procedures that result in limited samples, often not suitable for genotyping, highlighting the importance of integrating liquid biopsy in routine testing.
url http://openres.ersjournals.com/content/7/3/00942-2020.full
work_keys_str_mv AT maximerobin feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT laurentmhanna feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT leonorchaltiel feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT gavinplat feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT valentinheluain feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT celinebasset feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT juliemeilleroux feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT thomasfilleron feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT julienmazieres feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT christophehermant feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
AT nicolasguibert feasibilityofcomprehensivegenotypingspecimensfromradialendobronchialultrasonographyandelectromagneticnavigationbronchoscopy
_version_ 1716844026141868032