On the use of laser-scanning vibrometry for mechanical performance evaluation of 3D printed specimens

In this study, we explored the suitability of laser-scanning vibrometry (LSV) for evaluation of the mechanical behavior of rectangular prisms produced by Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF). Our hypothesis was that LSV would be able to discriminate the mechanical behavior of specimens fabricated with d...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Francisco Medel, Víctor Esteban, Javier Abad
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Elsevier 2021-07-01
Series:Materials & Design
Subjects:
Online Access:http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0264127521002719
id doaj-18bbcb319f2e4374827e0956cce574f9
record_format Article
spelling doaj-18bbcb319f2e4374827e0956cce574f92021-06-11T05:11:25ZengElsevierMaterials & Design0264-12752021-07-01205109719On the use of laser-scanning vibrometry for mechanical performance evaluation of 3D printed specimensFrancisco Medel0Víctor Esteban1Javier Abad2Department of Mechanical Engineering, Institute of Engineering Research of Aragón-I3A, Campus Río Ebro, School of Engineering and Architecture, Universidad de Zaragoza, Zaragoza, Spain; Corresponding author.Technical Department TJF S.A. Caspe, Zaragoza, SpainDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Institute of Engineering Research of Aragón-I3A, Campus Río Ebro, School of Engineering and Architecture, Universidad de Zaragoza, Zaragoza, SpainIn this study, we explored the suitability of laser-scanning vibrometry (LSV) for evaluation of the mechanical behavior of rectangular prisms produced by Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF). Our hypothesis was that LSV would be able to discriminate the mechanical behavior of specimens fabricated with different process parameters combinations. Build orientation, raster angle, nozzle temperature, printing speed and layer thickness were the process parameters of interest. Based on a factorial design of experiment approach, 48 different process parameter combinations were taken into account and 96 polylactic acid (PLA) rectangular prisms were fabricated. The characterization of their dynamical behavior provided frequency data, making possible the computation of an equivalent elastic modulus metric. Statistical analysis of the equivalent elastic modulus dataset confirmed the significant influences of raster angle, build orientation and nozzle temperature. Moreover, multivariate regression models served to rank, not only the significant influences of individual process parameters, but also the significant quadratic and cubic interactions between them. The previous knowledge was then applied to generate an ad hoc model selecting the most important factors (linear and interactions). The predicted equivalent elastic moduli provided by our ad hoc model were used in modal analysis simulations of both 3D printed rectangular prisms and a complex part. The simulated frequencies thus obtained were generally closer to the experimental ones (≤11%), as compared to modal analysis simulations based on internal geometry modelling (≤33%). The use of LSV appears very promising in the characterization of the mechanical behavior and integrity of 3D printed parts. Other additive manufacturing technologies may benefit from the use of this technique and from the adoption of the presented methodology to test, simulate and optimize the properties of 3D printed products.http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0264127521002719Fused Filament Fabrication3D printingLaser-scanning vibrometryMechanical propertiesElastic ModulusPolylactic acid (PLA)
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Francisco Medel
Víctor Esteban
Javier Abad
spellingShingle Francisco Medel
Víctor Esteban
Javier Abad
On the use of laser-scanning vibrometry for mechanical performance evaluation of 3D printed specimens
Materials & Design
Fused Filament Fabrication
3D printing
Laser-scanning vibrometry
Mechanical properties
Elastic Modulus
Polylactic acid (PLA)
author_facet Francisco Medel
Víctor Esteban
Javier Abad
author_sort Francisco Medel
title On the use of laser-scanning vibrometry for mechanical performance evaluation of 3D printed specimens
title_short On the use of laser-scanning vibrometry for mechanical performance evaluation of 3D printed specimens
title_full On the use of laser-scanning vibrometry for mechanical performance evaluation of 3D printed specimens
title_fullStr On the use of laser-scanning vibrometry for mechanical performance evaluation of 3D printed specimens
title_full_unstemmed On the use of laser-scanning vibrometry for mechanical performance evaluation of 3D printed specimens
title_sort on the use of laser-scanning vibrometry for mechanical performance evaluation of 3d printed specimens
publisher Elsevier
series Materials & Design
issn 0264-1275
publishDate 2021-07-01
description In this study, we explored the suitability of laser-scanning vibrometry (LSV) for evaluation of the mechanical behavior of rectangular prisms produced by Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF). Our hypothesis was that LSV would be able to discriminate the mechanical behavior of specimens fabricated with different process parameters combinations. Build orientation, raster angle, nozzle temperature, printing speed and layer thickness were the process parameters of interest. Based on a factorial design of experiment approach, 48 different process parameter combinations were taken into account and 96 polylactic acid (PLA) rectangular prisms were fabricated. The characterization of their dynamical behavior provided frequency data, making possible the computation of an equivalent elastic modulus metric. Statistical analysis of the equivalent elastic modulus dataset confirmed the significant influences of raster angle, build orientation and nozzle temperature. Moreover, multivariate regression models served to rank, not only the significant influences of individual process parameters, but also the significant quadratic and cubic interactions between them. The previous knowledge was then applied to generate an ad hoc model selecting the most important factors (linear and interactions). The predicted equivalent elastic moduli provided by our ad hoc model were used in modal analysis simulations of both 3D printed rectangular prisms and a complex part. The simulated frequencies thus obtained were generally closer to the experimental ones (≤11%), as compared to modal analysis simulations based on internal geometry modelling (≤33%). The use of LSV appears very promising in the characterization of the mechanical behavior and integrity of 3D printed parts. Other additive manufacturing technologies may benefit from the use of this technique and from the adoption of the presented methodology to test, simulate and optimize the properties of 3D printed products.
topic Fused Filament Fabrication
3D printing
Laser-scanning vibrometry
Mechanical properties
Elastic Modulus
Polylactic acid (PLA)
url http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0264127521002719
work_keys_str_mv AT franciscomedel ontheuseoflaserscanningvibrometryformechanicalperformanceevaluationof3dprintedspecimens
AT victoresteban ontheuseoflaserscanningvibrometryformechanicalperformanceevaluationof3dprintedspecimens
AT javierabad ontheuseoflaserscanningvibrometryformechanicalperformanceevaluationof3dprintedspecimens
_version_ 1721383670017687552