An international delphi survey for the definition of the variables for the development of new classification criteria for periodic fever aphtous stomatitis pharingitis cervical adenitis (PFAPA)

Abstract Background Diagnosis of Periodic fever, aphthous stomatitis, pharyngitis and cervical adenitis (PFAPA) is currently based on a set of criteria proposed in 1999 modified from Marshall’s criteria. Nevertheless no validated evidence based set of classification criteria for PFAPA has been estab...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Federica Vanoni, Silvia Federici, Jordi Antón, Karyl S. Barron, Paul Brogan, Fabrizio De Benedetti, Fatma Dedeoglu, Erkan Demirkaya, Veronique Hentgen, Tilmann Kallinich, Ronald Laxer, Ricardo Russo, Natasa Toplak, Yosef Uziel, Alberto Martini, Nicolino Ruperto, Marco Gattorno, Michael Hofer, for Eurofever and the Paediatric Rheumatology International Trials Organisation (PRINTO)
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: BMC 2018-04-01
Series:Pediatric Rheumatology Online Journal
Subjects:
Online Access:http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12969-018-0246-9
id doaj-1dab4df312dc4d0a8723718c86e2c572
record_format Article
spelling doaj-1dab4df312dc4d0a8723718c86e2c5722020-11-24T21:50:08ZengBMCPediatric Rheumatology Online Journal1546-00962018-04-011611610.1186/s12969-018-0246-9An international delphi survey for the definition of the variables for the development of new classification criteria for periodic fever aphtous stomatitis pharingitis cervical adenitis (PFAPA)Federica Vanoni0Silvia Federici1Jordi Antón2Karyl S. Barron3Paul Brogan4Fabrizio De Benedetti5Fatma Dedeoglu6Erkan Demirkaya7Veronique Hentgen8Tilmann Kallinich9Ronald Laxer10Ricardo Russo11Natasa Toplak12Yosef Uziel13Alberto Martini14Nicolino Ruperto15Marco Gattorno16Michael Hofer17for Eurofever and the Paediatric Rheumatology International Trials Organisation (PRINTO)Department of Pediatrics, Ospedale San GiovanniIstituto Giannina Gaslini, Clinica Pediatrica e Reumatologia, PRINTOPediatric Rheumatology, Hospital Sant Joan de Déu, Universitat de BarcelonaNIH-NIAID, Division of Intramural ResearchDepartment of Infection, Inflammation and Rheumatology, Great Ormond St HospitalIRCCS Ospedale Pediatrico Bambino Gesù, Division of RheumatologyDivision of Immunology, Rheumatology Program, Harvard Medical School Boston, Boston Children’s HospitalDivision of Paediatric Rheumatology, Western University and Children’s Hospital LHSCHôpital A Mignot - Centre Hospitalier de Versailles, CEREMAIA, French reference center for autoinflammatory diseases and inflammatory amyloidosisPediatric Pneumology and Immunology, Charité Universitätsmedizin BerlinDepartments of Pediatrics and Medicine, University of Toronto and The Hospital for Sick ChildrenServicio de Inmunología y Reumatología, Hospital de Pediatría Juan P. GarrahanDepartment of Allergology, Rheumatology and Clinical Immunology, University Children’s Hospital, University Medical Center LjubljanaMeir Medical Centre, Pediatric Rheumatology Unit, Department of Pediatrics, Kfar Saba and Sackler School of Medicine, Tel Aviv UniversityIstituto Giannina Gaslini, Direzione ScientificaIstituto Giannina Gaslini, Direzione ScientificaIstituto Giannina Gaslini, Clinica Pediatrica e Reumatologia, PRINTOUnité Romande d’Immuno-rhumatologie Pédiatrique, CHUV, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, and HUGAbstract Background Diagnosis of Periodic fever, aphthous stomatitis, pharyngitis and cervical adenitis (PFAPA) is currently based on a set of criteria proposed in 1999 modified from Marshall’s criteria. Nevertheless no validated evidence based set of classification criteria for PFAPA has been established so far. The aim of this study was to identify candidate classification criteria PFAPA syndrome using international consensus formation through a Delphi questionnaire survey. Methods A first open-ended questionnaire was sent to adult and pediatric clinicians/researchers, asking to identify the variables thought most likely to be helpful and relevant for the diagnosis of PFAPA. In a second survey, respondents were asked to select, from the list of variables coming from the first survey, the 10 features that they felt were most important, and to rank them in descending order from most important to least important. Results The response rate to the first and second Delphi was respectively 109/124 (88%) and 141/162 (87%). The number of participants that completed the first and second Delphi was 69/124 (56%) and 110/162 (68%). From the first Delphi we obtained a list of 92 variables, of which 62 were selected in the second Delphi. Variables reaching the top five position of the rank were regular periodicity, aphthous stomatitis, response to corticosteroids, cervical adenitis, and well-being between flares. Conclusion Our process led to identification of features that were felt to be the most important as candidate classification criteria for PFAPA by a large sample of international rheumatologists. The performance of these items will be tested further in the next phase of the study, through analysis of real patient data.http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12969-018-0246-9Autoinflammatory diseasesMonogenic periodic feverPFAPA
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Federica Vanoni
Silvia Federici
Jordi Antón
Karyl S. Barron
Paul Brogan
Fabrizio De Benedetti
Fatma Dedeoglu
Erkan Demirkaya
Veronique Hentgen
Tilmann Kallinich
Ronald Laxer
Ricardo Russo
Natasa Toplak
Yosef Uziel
Alberto Martini
Nicolino Ruperto
Marco Gattorno
Michael Hofer
for Eurofever and the Paediatric Rheumatology International Trials Organisation (PRINTO)
spellingShingle Federica Vanoni
Silvia Federici
Jordi Antón
Karyl S. Barron
Paul Brogan
Fabrizio De Benedetti
Fatma Dedeoglu
Erkan Demirkaya
Veronique Hentgen
Tilmann Kallinich
Ronald Laxer
Ricardo Russo
Natasa Toplak
Yosef Uziel
Alberto Martini
Nicolino Ruperto
Marco Gattorno
Michael Hofer
for Eurofever and the Paediatric Rheumatology International Trials Organisation (PRINTO)
An international delphi survey for the definition of the variables for the development of new classification criteria for periodic fever aphtous stomatitis pharingitis cervical adenitis (PFAPA)
Pediatric Rheumatology Online Journal
Autoinflammatory diseases
Monogenic periodic fever
PFAPA
author_facet Federica Vanoni
Silvia Federici
Jordi Antón
Karyl S. Barron
Paul Brogan
Fabrizio De Benedetti
Fatma Dedeoglu
Erkan Demirkaya
Veronique Hentgen
Tilmann Kallinich
Ronald Laxer
Ricardo Russo
Natasa Toplak
Yosef Uziel
Alberto Martini
Nicolino Ruperto
Marco Gattorno
Michael Hofer
for Eurofever and the Paediatric Rheumatology International Trials Organisation (PRINTO)
author_sort Federica Vanoni
title An international delphi survey for the definition of the variables for the development of new classification criteria for periodic fever aphtous stomatitis pharingitis cervical adenitis (PFAPA)
title_short An international delphi survey for the definition of the variables for the development of new classification criteria for periodic fever aphtous stomatitis pharingitis cervical adenitis (PFAPA)
title_full An international delphi survey for the definition of the variables for the development of new classification criteria for periodic fever aphtous stomatitis pharingitis cervical adenitis (PFAPA)
title_fullStr An international delphi survey for the definition of the variables for the development of new classification criteria for periodic fever aphtous stomatitis pharingitis cervical adenitis (PFAPA)
title_full_unstemmed An international delphi survey for the definition of the variables for the development of new classification criteria for periodic fever aphtous stomatitis pharingitis cervical adenitis (PFAPA)
title_sort international delphi survey for the definition of the variables for the development of new classification criteria for periodic fever aphtous stomatitis pharingitis cervical adenitis (pfapa)
publisher BMC
series Pediatric Rheumatology Online Journal
issn 1546-0096
publishDate 2018-04-01
description Abstract Background Diagnosis of Periodic fever, aphthous stomatitis, pharyngitis and cervical adenitis (PFAPA) is currently based on a set of criteria proposed in 1999 modified from Marshall’s criteria. Nevertheless no validated evidence based set of classification criteria for PFAPA has been established so far. The aim of this study was to identify candidate classification criteria PFAPA syndrome using international consensus formation through a Delphi questionnaire survey. Methods A first open-ended questionnaire was sent to adult and pediatric clinicians/researchers, asking to identify the variables thought most likely to be helpful and relevant for the diagnosis of PFAPA. In a second survey, respondents were asked to select, from the list of variables coming from the first survey, the 10 features that they felt were most important, and to rank them in descending order from most important to least important. Results The response rate to the first and second Delphi was respectively 109/124 (88%) and 141/162 (87%). The number of participants that completed the first and second Delphi was 69/124 (56%) and 110/162 (68%). From the first Delphi we obtained a list of 92 variables, of which 62 were selected in the second Delphi. Variables reaching the top five position of the rank were regular periodicity, aphthous stomatitis, response to corticosteroids, cervical adenitis, and well-being between flares. Conclusion Our process led to identification of features that were felt to be the most important as candidate classification criteria for PFAPA by a large sample of international rheumatologists. The performance of these items will be tested further in the next phase of the study, through analysis of real patient data.
topic Autoinflammatory diseases
Monogenic periodic fever
PFAPA
url http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12969-018-0246-9
work_keys_str_mv AT federicavanoni aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT silviafederici aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT jordianton aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT karylsbarron aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT paulbrogan aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT fabriziodebenedetti aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT fatmadedeoglu aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT erkandemirkaya aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT veroniquehentgen aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT tilmannkallinich aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT ronaldlaxer aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT ricardorusso aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT natasatoplak aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT yosefuziel aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT albertomartini aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT nicolinoruperto aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT marcogattorno aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT michaelhofer aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT foreurofeverandthepaediatricrheumatologyinternationaltrialsorganisationprinto aninternationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT federicavanoni internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT silviafederici internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT jordianton internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT karylsbarron internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT paulbrogan internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT fabriziodebenedetti internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT fatmadedeoglu internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT erkandemirkaya internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT veroniquehentgen internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT tilmannkallinich internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT ronaldlaxer internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT ricardorusso internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT natasatoplak internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT yosefuziel internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT albertomartini internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT nicolinoruperto internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT marcogattorno internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT michaelhofer internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
AT foreurofeverandthepaediatricrheumatologyinternationaltrialsorganisationprinto internationaldelphisurveyforthedefinitionofthevariablesforthedevelopmentofnewclassificationcriteriaforperiodicfeveraphtousstomatitispharingitiscervicaladenitispfapa
_version_ 1725885043737362432