Navigating to new frontiers in behavioral neuroscience: Traditional neuropsychological tests predict human performance on a rodent-inspired radial-arm maze

We constructed an 11-arm, walk-through, human radial-arm maze (HRAM) as a translational instrument to compare existing methodology in the areas of rodent and human learning and memory research. The HRAM, utilized here, serves as an intermediary test between the classic rat radial-arm maze (RAM) and...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Sarah E. Mennenga, Leslie C. Baxter, Itamar S. Grunfeld, Gene A. Brewer, Leona S. Aiken, Elizabeth B. Engler-Chiurazzi, Bryan W. Camp, Jazmin I. Acosta, B. Blair Braden, Keley R. Schaefer, Julia E. Gerson, Courtney N. Lavery, Candy W.S. Tsang, Lauren T. Hewitt, Melissa L. Kingston, Stephanie V. Koebele, K. Jake Patten, B. Hunter Ball, Michael K. McBeath, Heather A. Bimonte-Nelson
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Frontiers Media S.A. 2014-09-01
Series:Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience
Subjects:
Online Access:http://journal.frontiersin.org/Journal/10.3389/fnbeh.2014.00294/full
id doaj-203d1c4480fa4ea5a28775d45ff0a6cb
record_format Article
spelling doaj-203d1c4480fa4ea5a28775d45ff0a6cb2020-11-25T01:28:26ZengFrontiers Media S.A.Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience1662-51532014-09-01810.3389/fnbeh.2014.00294103816Navigating to new frontiers in behavioral neuroscience: Traditional neuropsychological tests predict human performance on a rodent-inspired radial-arm mazeSarah E. Mennenga0Sarah E. Mennenga1Leslie C. Baxter2Leslie C. Baxter3Itamar S. Grunfeld4Itamar S. Grunfeld5Itamar S. Grunfeld6Gene A. Brewer7Leona S. Aiken8Elizabeth B. Engler-Chiurazzi9Elizabeth B. Engler-Chiurazzi10Bryan W. Camp11Bryan W. Camp12Jazmin I. Acosta13Jazmin I. Acosta14B. Blair Braden15B. Blair Braden16B. Blair Braden17Keley R. Schaefer18Keley R. Schaefer19Julia E. Gerson20Julia E. Gerson21Courtney N. Lavery22Courtney N. Lavery23Candy W.S. Tsang24Candy W.S. Tsang25Lauren T. Hewitt26Lauren T. Hewitt27Melissa L. Kingston28Melissa L. Kingston29Stephanie V. Koebele30Stephanie V. Koebele31K. Jake Patten32B. Hunter Ball33Michael K. McBeath34Heather A. Bimonte-Nelson35Heather A. Bimonte-Nelson36Arizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumBarrow Neurological InstituteArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumBarrow Neurological InstituteArizona State UniversityArizona State UniversityArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumBarrow Neurological InstituteArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumArizona State UniversityArizona State UniversityArizona State UniversityArizona State UniversityArizona Alzheimer's ConsortiumWe constructed an 11-arm, walk-through, human radial-arm maze (HRAM) as a translational instrument to compare existing methodology in the areas of rodent and human learning and memory research. The HRAM, utilized here, serves as an intermediary test between the classic rat radial-arm maze (RAM) and standard human neuropsychological and cognitive tests. We show that the HRAM is a useful instrument to examine working memory ability, explore the relationships between rodent and human memory and cognition models, and evaluate factors that contribute to human navigational ability. One-hundred-and-fifty-seven participants were tested on the HRAM, and scores were compared to performance on a standard cognitive battery focused on episodic memory, working memory capacity, and visuospatial ability. We found that errors on the HRAM increased as working memory demand became elevated, similar to the pattern typically seen in rodents, and that for this task, performance appears similar to Miller’s classic description of human working memory capacity of 7±2 items. Regression analysis revealed that measures of working memory capacity and visuospatial ability accounted for a large proportion of variance in HRAM scores, while measures of episodic memory and general intelligence did not serve as significant predictors of HRAM performance. We present the HRAM as a novel instrument for measuring navigational behavior in humans, as is traditionally done in basic science studies evaluating rodent learning and memory, thus providing a useful tool to help connect and translate between human and rodent models of cognitive functioning.http://journal.frontiersin.org/Journal/10.3389/fnbeh.2014.00294/fullCognitionMemoryhumanworking memoryrodentNeuropsychological test
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Sarah E. Mennenga
Sarah E. Mennenga
Leslie C. Baxter
Leslie C. Baxter
Itamar S. Grunfeld
Itamar S. Grunfeld
Itamar S. Grunfeld
Gene A. Brewer
Leona S. Aiken
Elizabeth B. Engler-Chiurazzi
Elizabeth B. Engler-Chiurazzi
Bryan W. Camp
Bryan W. Camp
Jazmin I. Acosta
Jazmin I. Acosta
B. Blair Braden
B. Blair Braden
B. Blair Braden
Keley R. Schaefer
Keley R. Schaefer
Julia E. Gerson
Julia E. Gerson
Courtney N. Lavery
Courtney N. Lavery
Candy W.S. Tsang
Candy W.S. Tsang
Lauren T. Hewitt
Lauren T. Hewitt
Melissa L. Kingston
Melissa L. Kingston
Stephanie V. Koebele
Stephanie V. Koebele
K. Jake Patten
B. Hunter Ball
Michael K. McBeath
Heather A. Bimonte-Nelson
Heather A. Bimonte-Nelson
spellingShingle Sarah E. Mennenga
Sarah E. Mennenga
Leslie C. Baxter
Leslie C. Baxter
Itamar S. Grunfeld
Itamar S. Grunfeld
Itamar S. Grunfeld
Gene A. Brewer
Leona S. Aiken
Elizabeth B. Engler-Chiurazzi
Elizabeth B. Engler-Chiurazzi
Bryan W. Camp
Bryan W. Camp
Jazmin I. Acosta
Jazmin I. Acosta
B. Blair Braden
B. Blair Braden
B. Blair Braden
Keley R. Schaefer
Keley R. Schaefer
Julia E. Gerson
Julia E. Gerson
Courtney N. Lavery
Courtney N. Lavery
Candy W.S. Tsang
Candy W.S. Tsang
Lauren T. Hewitt
Lauren T. Hewitt
Melissa L. Kingston
Melissa L. Kingston
Stephanie V. Koebele
Stephanie V. Koebele
K. Jake Patten
B. Hunter Ball
Michael K. McBeath
Heather A. Bimonte-Nelson
Heather A. Bimonte-Nelson
Navigating to new frontiers in behavioral neuroscience: Traditional neuropsychological tests predict human performance on a rodent-inspired radial-arm maze
Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience
Cognition
Memory
human
working memory
rodent
Neuropsychological test
author_facet Sarah E. Mennenga
Sarah E. Mennenga
Leslie C. Baxter
Leslie C. Baxter
Itamar S. Grunfeld
Itamar S. Grunfeld
Itamar S. Grunfeld
Gene A. Brewer
Leona S. Aiken
Elizabeth B. Engler-Chiurazzi
Elizabeth B. Engler-Chiurazzi
Bryan W. Camp
Bryan W. Camp
Jazmin I. Acosta
Jazmin I. Acosta
B. Blair Braden
B. Blair Braden
B. Blair Braden
Keley R. Schaefer
Keley R. Schaefer
Julia E. Gerson
Julia E. Gerson
Courtney N. Lavery
Courtney N. Lavery
Candy W.S. Tsang
Candy W.S. Tsang
Lauren T. Hewitt
Lauren T. Hewitt
Melissa L. Kingston
Melissa L. Kingston
Stephanie V. Koebele
Stephanie V. Koebele
K. Jake Patten
B. Hunter Ball
Michael K. McBeath
Heather A. Bimonte-Nelson
Heather A. Bimonte-Nelson
author_sort Sarah E. Mennenga
title Navigating to new frontiers in behavioral neuroscience: Traditional neuropsychological tests predict human performance on a rodent-inspired radial-arm maze
title_short Navigating to new frontiers in behavioral neuroscience: Traditional neuropsychological tests predict human performance on a rodent-inspired radial-arm maze
title_full Navigating to new frontiers in behavioral neuroscience: Traditional neuropsychological tests predict human performance on a rodent-inspired radial-arm maze
title_fullStr Navigating to new frontiers in behavioral neuroscience: Traditional neuropsychological tests predict human performance on a rodent-inspired radial-arm maze
title_full_unstemmed Navigating to new frontiers in behavioral neuroscience: Traditional neuropsychological tests predict human performance on a rodent-inspired radial-arm maze
title_sort navigating to new frontiers in behavioral neuroscience: traditional neuropsychological tests predict human performance on a rodent-inspired radial-arm maze
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
series Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience
issn 1662-5153
publishDate 2014-09-01
description We constructed an 11-arm, walk-through, human radial-arm maze (HRAM) as a translational instrument to compare existing methodology in the areas of rodent and human learning and memory research. The HRAM, utilized here, serves as an intermediary test between the classic rat radial-arm maze (RAM) and standard human neuropsychological and cognitive tests. We show that the HRAM is a useful instrument to examine working memory ability, explore the relationships between rodent and human memory and cognition models, and evaluate factors that contribute to human navigational ability. One-hundred-and-fifty-seven participants were tested on the HRAM, and scores were compared to performance on a standard cognitive battery focused on episodic memory, working memory capacity, and visuospatial ability. We found that errors on the HRAM increased as working memory demand became elevated, similar to the pattern typically seen in rodents, and that for this task, performance appears similar to Miller’s classic description of human working memory capacity of 7±2 items. Regression analysis revealed that measures of working memory capacity and visuospatial ability accounted for a large proportion of variance in HRAM scores, while measures of episodic memory and general intelligence did not serve as significant predictors of HRAM performance. We present the HRAM as a novel instrument for measuring navigational behavior in humans, as is traditionally done in basic science studies evaluating rodent learning and memory, thus providing a useful tool to help connect and translate between human and rodent models of cognitive functioning.
topic Cognition
Memory
human
working memory
rodent
Neuropsychological test
url http://journal.frontiersin.org/Journal/10.3389/fnbeh.2014.00294/full
work_keys_str_mv AT sarahemennenga navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT sarahemennenga navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT lesliecbaxter navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT lesliecbaxter navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT itamarsgrunfeld navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT itamarsgrunfeld navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT itamarsgrunfeld navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT geneabrewer navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT leonasaiken navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT elizabethbenglerchiurazzi navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT elizabethbenglerchiurazzi navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT bryanwcamp navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT bryanwcamp navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT jazminiacosta navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT jazminiacosta navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT bblairbraden navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT bblairbraden navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT bblairbraden navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT keleyrschaefer navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT keleyrschaefer navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT juliaegerson navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT juliaegerson navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT courtneynlavery navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT courtneynlavery navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT candywstsang navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT candywstsang navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT laurenthewitt navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT laurenthewitt navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT melissalkingston navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT melissalkingston navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT stephanievkoebele navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT stephanievkoebele navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT kjakepatten navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT bhunterball navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT michaelkmcbeath navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT heatherabimontenelson navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
AT heatherabimontenelson navigatingtonewfrontiersinbehavioralneurosciencetraditionalneuropsychologicaltestspredicthumanperformanceonarodentinspiredradialarmmaze
_version_ 1725101763392962560