Environmental conditions do not predict diversification rates in the Bantu languages

• Main Authors: Robert Beyer, Joy S. Singarayer, Jay T. Stock, Andrea Manica
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier 2019-10-01
• Series: Heliyon
• Subjects: Climatology; Ecology; Paleoecology; Population dynamics; Linguistics; Environmental science
• Online Access: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2405844019362905

The global distribution of language diversity mirrors that of several variables related to ecosystem productivity. It has been argued that this is driven by the size of social networks, which tend to be larger in harsher climates to ensure food security, leading to reduced language divergence. Is this pattern purely synchronic, or is there also a quantifiable relationship between environmental conditions and language diversification over time? We used a spatio-temporal phylogeny of the Bantu language family to estimate local diversification rates at the times and locations of language divergence. We compared these data against spatially-explicit reconstructions of several palaeoclimate and palaeovegetation variables (mean annual temperature and the temperature of the coldest and warmest quarter, annual precipitation and the precipitation of the wettest and driest quarter, growing degree days, the length of the growing season, and net primary production), to investigate a potential link between local environmental factors and diversification rates in the Bantu languages. A regression analysis does not suggest a statistically significant relationship between climatic or ecological variables and linguistic diversification over time. We find a strong positive correlation between pairwise linguistic and geographic distances in the Bantu languages, arguing for a dominant role of isolation as a result of the rapid Bantu expansion that might have overwhelmed any potential influence of local environmental factors.