An investigation on the suitability of modern nondestructive testing methods for the inspection of specimens manufactured by laser powder bed fusion

Abstract Laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) is increasingly used to fabricate functional parts used in safety-relevant applications. To ensure that the sophisticated part specifications are achieved, 100% quality inspections are performed subsequent to the buildup process. However, knowledge about the...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Cara G. Kolb, Katja Zier, Jan-Carl Grager, Andreas Bachmann, Tobias Neuwirth, Simon Schmid, Maria Haag, Markus Axtner, Fabian Bayerlein, Christian U. Grosse, Michael F. Zaeh
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Springer 2021-06-01
Series:SN Applied Sciences
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1007/s42452-021-04685-3
id doaj-399c9ffbe064450588f903947699d0e6
record_format Article
spelling doaj-399c9ffbe064450588f903947699d0e62021-07-04T11:18:12ZengSpringerSN Applied Sciences2523-39632523-39712021-06-013711610.1007/s42452-021-04685-3An investigation on the suitability of modern nondestructive testing methods for the inspection of specimens manufactured by laser powder bed fusionCara G. Kolb0Katja Zier1Jan-Carl Grager2Andreas Bachmann3Tobias Neuwirth4Simon Schmid5Maria Haag6Markus Axtner7Fabian Bayerlein8Christian U. Grosse9Michael F. Zaeh10Department of Mechanical Engineering, Institute for Machine Tools and Industrial Management, Technical University of MunichChair of Non-destructive Testing, Technical University of MunichChair of Non-destructive Testing, Technical University of MunichDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Institute for Machine Tools and Industrial Management, Technical University of MunichResearch Neutron Source Heinz Maier-Leibnitz (FRM II), Technical University of MunichChair of Non-destructive Testing, Technical University of MunichFIT Additive Manufacturing GroupFIT Additive Manufacturing GroupDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Institute for Machine Tools and Industrial Management, Technical University of MunichChair of Non-destructive Testing, Technical University of MunichDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, Institute for Machine Tools and Industrial Management, Technical University of MunichAbstract Laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) is increasingly used to fabricate functional parts used in safety-relevant applications. To ensure that the sophisticated part specifications are achieved, 100% quality inspections are performed subsequent to the buildup process. However, knowledge about the detectability of defects in L-PBF parts using NDT methods is limited. This paper analyzes the suitability of NDT techniques in an ex situ environment, in particular active infrared thermography, neutron grating interferometry (nGI), X-ray computed tomography, and ultrasonic testing for the examination of L-PBF parts made from Inconel 718. Based on a test specimen with artificially inserted defects with varying dimensions and depths, these NDT techniques were compared in terms of their attainable resolution and thus defect detection capability. The empirical studies revealed that nGI shows the highest resolution capability. It was possible to detect defects with a diameter of 100–200 m at a depth of 60–80  $${\upmu } \hbox {m}$$ μ m . The results are discussed with regard to their relevance for the examination of L-PBF parts and thus not only contribute to a better understanding of the potential of the NDT techniques in comparison but also assist stakeholders in additive manufacturing in evaluating the suitability of the NDT techniques investigated.https://doi.org/10.1007/s42452-021-04685-3Laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF)Defect detectionActive infrared thermography imaging (aIRT)Neutron grating interferometry (nGI)Computed tomography (CT)Ultrasonic testing (UT)
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Cara G. Kolb
Katja Zier
Jan-Carl Grager
Andreas Bachmann
Tobias Neuwirth
Simon Schmid
Maria Haag
Markus Axtner
Fabian Bayerlein
Christian U. Grosse
Michael F. Zaeh
spellingShingle Cara G. Kolb
Katja Zier
Jan-Carl Grager
Andreas Bachmann
Tobias Neuwirth
Simon Schmid
Maria Haag
Markus Axtner
Fabian Bayerlein
Christian U. Grosse
Michael F. Zaeh
An investigation on the suitability of modern nondestructive testing methods for the inspection of specimens manufactured by laser powder bed fusion
SN Applied Sciences
Laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF)
Defect detection
Active infrared thermography imaging (aIRT)
Neutron grating interferometry (nGI)
Computed tomography (CT)
Ultrasonic testing (UT)
author_facet Cara G. Kolb
Katja Zier
Jan-Carl Grager
Andreas Bachmann
Tobias Neuwirth
Simon Schmid
Maria Haag
Markus Axtner
Fabian Bayerlein
Christian U. Grosse
Michael F. Zaeh
author_sort Cara G. Kolb
title An investigation on the suitability of modern nondestructive testing methods for the inspection of specimens manufactured by laser powder bed fusion
title_short An investigation on the suitability of modern nondestructive testing methods for the inspection of specimens manufactured by laser powder bed fusion
title_full An investigation on the suitability of modern nondestructive testing methods for the inspection of specimens manufactured by laser powder bed fusion
title_fullStr An investigation on the suitability of modern nondestructive testing methods for the inspection of specimens manufactured by laser powder bed fusion
title_full_unstemmed An investigation on the suitability of modern nondestructive testing methods for the inspection of specimens manufactured by laser powder bed fusion
title_sort investigation on the suitability of modern nondestructive testing methods for the inspection of specimens manufactured by laser powder bed fusion
publisher Springer
series SN Applied Sciences
issn 2523-3963
2523-3971
publishDate 2021-06-01
description Abstract Laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) is increasingly used to fabricate functional parts used in safety-relevant applications. To ensure that the sophisticated part specifications are achieved, 100% quality inspections are performed subsequent to the buildup process. However, knowledge about the detectability of defects in L-PBF parts using NDT methods is limited. This paper analyzes the suitability of NDT techniques in an ex situ environment, in particular active infrared thermography, neutron grating interferometry (nGI), X-ray computed tomography, and ultrasonic testing for the examination of L-PBF parts made from Inconel 718. Based on a test specimen with artificially inserted defects with varying dimensions and depths, these NDT techniques were compared in terms of their attainable resolution and thus defect detection capability. The empirical studies revealed that nGI shows the highest resolution capability. It was possible to detect defects with a diameter of 100–200 m at a depth of 60–80  $${\upmu } \hbox {m}$$ μ m . The results are discussed with regard to their relevance for the examination of L-PBF parts and thus not only contribute to a better understanding of the potential of the NDT techniques in comparison but also assist stakeholders in additive manufacturing in evaluating the suitability of the NDT techniques investigated.
topic Laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF)
Defect detection
Active infrared thermography imaging (aIRT)
Neutron grating interferometry (nGI)
Computed tomography (CT)
Ultrasonic testing (UT)
url https://doi.org/10.1007/s42452-021-04685-3
work_keys_str_mv AT caragkolb aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT katjazier aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT jancarlgrager aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT andreasbachmann aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT tobiasneuwirth aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT simonschmid aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT mariahaag aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT markusaxtner aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT fabianbayerlein aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT christianugrosse aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT michaelfzaeh aninvestigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT caragkolb investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT katjazier investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT jancarlgrager investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT andreasbachmann investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT tobiasneuwirth investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT simonschmid investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT mariahaag investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT markusaxtner investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT fabianbayerlein investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT christianugrosse investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
AT michaelfzaeh investigationonthesuitabilityofmodernnondestructivetestingmethodsfortheinspectionofspecimensmanufacturedbylaserpowderbedfusion
_version_ 1721320394986618880