Synergy of High-Resolution Radar and Optical Images Satellite for Identification and Mapping of Wetland Macrophytes on the Danube Delta

In wetland environments, vegetation has an important role in ecological functioning. The main goal of this work is to identify an optimal combination of Sentinel-1 (S1), Sentinel-2 (S2), and Pleiades data using ground-reference data to accurately map wetland macrophytes in the Danube Delta. We teste...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Simona Niculescu, Jean-Baptiste Boissonnat, Cédric Lardeux, Dar Roberts, Jenica Hanganu, Antoine Billey, Adrian Constantinescu, Mihai Doroftei
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2020-07-01
Series:Remote Sensing
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/12/14/2188
id doaj-3a70089b92394e1989cf75d45ea0a53e
record_format Article
spelling doaj-3a70089b92394e1989cf75d45ea0a53e2020-11-25T03:47:21ZengMDPI AGRemote Sensing2072-42922020-07-01122188218810.3390/rs12142188Synergy of High-Resolution Radar and Optical Images Satellite for Identification and Mapping of Wetland Macrophytes on the Danube DeltaSimona Niculescu0Jean-Baptiste Boissonnat1Cédric Lardeux2Dar Roberts3Jenica Hanganu4Antoine Billey5Adrian Constantinescu6Mihai Doroftei7Department of Geography, University of Western Brittany, 3 Rue des Archives, 29238 Brest, , FranceDepartment of Geography, University of Rennes 2, Place Recteur Henri le Moal, 35000 Rennes, FranceONF International, 45 bis avenue de la Belle Gabrielle 94736 Nogent-sur-Marne, FranceDepartment of Geography, University Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara, CA 93106, USADanube Delta National Institute for Research and Development, Strada Babadag nr. 165, 820112 Tulcea, RomaniaDepartment of Geography, University of Western Brittany, 3 Rue des Archives, 29238 Brest, , FranceDanube Delta National Institute for Research and Development, Strada Babadag nr. 165, 820112 Tulcea, RomaniaDanube Delta National Institute for Research and Development, Strada Babadag nr. 165, 820112 Tulcea, RomaniaIn wetland environments, vegetation has an important role in ecological functioning. The main goal of this work is to identify an optimal combination of Sentinel-1 (S1), Sentinel-2 (S2), and Pleiades data using ground-reference data to accurately map wetland macrophytes in the Danube Delta. We tested several combinations of optical and Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) data rigorously at two levels. First, in order to reduce the confusion between reed (<i>Phragmites australis </i>(Cav.) Trin. ex Steud.) and other macrophyte communities, a time series analysis of S1 data was performed. The potential of S1 for detection of compact reed on plaur, compact reed on plaur/reed cut, open reed on plaur, pure reed, and reed on salinized soil was evaluated through time series of backscatter coefficient and coherence ratio images, calculated mainly according to the phenology of the reed. The analysis of backscattering coefficients allowed separation of reed classes that strongly overlapped. The coherence coefficient showed that C-band SAR repeat pass interferometric coherence for cut reed detection is feasible. In the second section, random forest (RF) classification was applied to the S2, Pleiades, and S1 data and in situ observations to discriminate and map reed against other aquatic macrophytes (submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV), emergent macrophytes, some floating broad-leaved and floating vegetation of delta lakes). In addition, different optical indices were included in the RF. A total of 67 classification models were made in several sensor combinations with two series of validation samples (with the reed and without reed) using both a simple and more detailed classification schema. The results showed that reed is completely discriminable compared to other macrophytes communities with all sensor combinations. In all combinations, the model-based producer’s accuracy (PA) and user’s accuracy (UA) for reed with both nomenclatures were over 90%. The diverse combinations of sensors were valuable for improving the overall classification accuracy of all of the communities of aquatic macrophytes except <i>Myriophyllum spicatum </i>L.https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/12/14/2188wetland vegetationDanube Deltabackscatter coefficientcoherence ratiostacking of times series radar and opticalrandom forest
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Simona Niculescu
Jean-Baptiste Boissonnat
Cédric Lardeux
Dar Roberts
Jenica Hanganu
Antoine Billey
Adrian Constantinescu
Mihai Doroftei
spellingShingle Simona Niculescu
Jean-Baptiste Boissonnat
Cédric Lardeux
Dar Roberts
Jenica Hanganu
Antoine Billey
Adrian Constantinescu
Mihai Doroftei
Synergy of High-Resolution Radar and Optical Images Satellite for Identification and Mapping of Wetland Macrophytes on the Danube Delta
Remote Sensing
wetland vegetation
Danube Delta
backscatter coefficient
coherence ratio
stacking of times series radar and optical
random forest
author_facet Simona Niculescu
Jean-Baptiste Boissonnat
Cédric Lardeux
Dar Roberts
Jenica Hanganu
Antoine Billey
Adrian Constantinescu
Mihai Doroftei
author_sort Simona Niculescu
title Synergy of High-Resolution Radar and Optical Images Satellite for Identification and Mapping of Wetland Macrophytes on the Danube Delta
title_short Synergy of High-Resolution Radar and Optical Images Satellite for Identification and Mapping of Wetland Macrophytes on the Danube Delta
title_full Synergy of High-Resolution Radar and Optical Images Satellite for Identification and Mapping of Wetland Macrophytes on the Danube Delta
title_fullStr Synergy of High-Resolution Radar and Optical Images Satellite for Identification and Mapping of Wetland Macrophytes on the Danube Delta
title_full_unstemmed Synergy of High-Resolution Radar and Optical Images Satellite for Identification and Mapping of Wetland Macrophytes on the Danube Delta
title_sort synergy of high-resolution radar and optical images satellite for identification and mapping of wetland macrophytes on the danube delta
publisher MDPI AG
series Remote Sensing
issn 2072-4292
publishDate 2020-07-01
description In wetland environments, vegetation has an important role in ecological functioning. The main goal of this work is to identify an optimal combination of Sentinel-1 (S1), Sentinel-2 (S2), and Pleiades data using ground-reference data to accurately map wetland macrophytes in the Danube Delta. We tested several combinations of optical and Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) data rigorously at two levels. First, in order to reduce the confusion between reed (<i>Phragmites australis </i>(Cav.) Trin. ex Steud.) and other macrophyte communities, a time series analysis of S1 data was performed. The potential of S1 for detection of compact reed on plaur, compact reed on plaur/reed cut, open reed on plaur, pure reed, and reed on salinized soil was evaluated through time series of backscatter coefficient and coherence ratio images, calculated mainly according to the phenology of the reed. The analysis of backscattering coefficients allowed separation of reed classes that strongly overlapped. The coherence coefficient showed that C-band SAR repeat pass interferometric coherence for cut reed detection is feasible. In the second section, random forest (RF) classification was applied to the S2, Pleiades, and S1 data and in situ observations to discriminate and map reed against other aquatic macrophytes (submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV), emergent macrophytes, some floating broad-leaved and floating vegetation of delta lakes). In addition, different optical indices were included in the RF. A total of 67 classification models were made in several sensor combinations with two series of validation samples (with the reed and without reed) using both a simple and more detailed classification schema. The results showed that reed is completely discriminable compared to other macrophytes communities with all sensor combinations. In all combinations, the model-based producer’s accuracy (PA) and user’s accuracy (UA) for reed with both nomenclatures were over 90%. The diverse combinations of sensors were valuable for improving the overall classification accuracy of all of the communities of aquatic macrophytes except <i>Myriophyllum spicatum </i>L.
topic wetland vegetation
Danube Delta
backscatter coefficient
coherence ratio
stacking of times series radar and optical
random forest
url https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/12/14/2188
work_keys_str_mv AT simonaniculescu synergyofhighresolutionradarandopticalimagessatelliteforidentificationandmappingofwetlandmacrophytesonthedanubedelta
AT jeanbaptisteboissonnat synergyofhighresolutionradarandopticalimagessatelliteforidentificationandmappingofwetlandmacrophytesonthedanubedelta
AT cedriclardeux synergyofhighresolutionradarandopticalimagessatelliteforidentificationandmappingofwetlandmacrophytesonthedanubedelta
AT darroberts synergyofhighresolutionradarandopticalimagessatelliteforidentificationandmappingofwetlandmacrophytesonthedanubedelta
AT jenicahanganu synergyofhighresolutionradarandopticalimagessatelliteforidentificationandmappingofwetlandmacrophytesonthedanubedelta
AT antoinebilley synergyofhighresolutionradarandopticalimagessatelliteforidentificationandmappingofwetlandmacrophytesonthedanubedelta
AT adrianconstantinescu synergyofhighresolutionradarandopticalimagessatelliteforidentificationandmappingofwetlandmacrophytesonthedanubedelta
AT mihaidoroftei synergyofhighresolutionradarandopticalimagessatelliteforidentificationandmappingofwetlandmacrophytesonthedanubedelta
_version_ 1724502286283046912