Supervision of a self-driving vehicle unmasks latent sleepiness relative to manually controlled driving

Abstract Human error has been implicated as a causal factor in a large proportion of road accidents. Automated driving systems purport to mitigate this risk, but self-driving systems that allow a driver to entirely disengage from the driving task also require the driver to monitor the environment an...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Erin E. Flynn-Evans, Lily R. Wong, Yukiyo Kuriyagawa, Nikhil Gowda, Patrick F. Cravalho, Sean Pradhan, Nathan H. Feick, Nicholas G. Bathurst, Zachary L. Glaros, Theerawit Wilaiprasitporn, Kanika Bansal, Javier O. Garcia, Cassie J. Hilditch
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Nature Publishing Group 2021-09-01
Series:Scientific Reports
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-92914-5
id doaj-46bf0521253d48ae813efb6ebc707084
record_format Article
spelling doaj-46bf0521253d48ae813efb6ebc7070842021-09-19T11:33:46ZengNature Publishing GroupScientific Reports2045-23222021-09-0111111310.1038/s41598-021-92914-5Supervision of a self-driving vehicle unmasks latent sleepiness relative to manually controlled drivingErin E. Flynn-Evans0Lily R. Wong1Yukiyo Kuriyagawa2Nikhil Gowda3Patrick F. Cravalho4Sean Pradhan5Nathan H. Feick6Nicholas G. Bathurst7Zachary L. Glaros8Theerawit Wilaiprasitporn9Kanika Bansal10Javier O. Garcia11Cassie J. Hilditch12Fatigue Countermeasures Laboratory, Human Systems Integration Division, NASA Ames Research CenterFatigue Countermeasures Laboratory, San José State UniversityCollege of Industrial Technology, Nihon UniversityFatigue Countermeasures Laboratory, San José State UniversityFatigue Countermeasures Laboratory, San José State UniversityFatigue Countermeasures Laboratory, San José State UniversityFatigue Countermeasures Laboratory, San José State UniversityFatigue Countermeasures Laboratory, San José State UniversityFatigue Countermeasures Laboratory, Human Systems Integration Division, NASA Ames Research CenterSchool of Information Science and Technology, Vidyasirimedhi Institute of Science and TechnologyArmy Research Laboratory, U.S. CCDCArmy Research Laboratory, U.S. CCDCFatigue Countermeasures Laboratory, San José State UniversityAbstract Human error has been implicated as a causal factor in a large proportion of road accidents. Automated driving systems purport to mitigate this risk, but self-driving systems that allow a driver to entirely disengage from the driving task also require the driver to monitor the environment and take control when necessary. Given that sleep loss impairs monitoring performance and there is a high prevalence of sleep deficiency in modern society, we hypothesized that supervising a self-driving vehicle would unmask latent sleepiness compared to manually controlled driving among individuals following their typical sleep schedules. We found that participants felt sleepier, had more involuntary transitions to sleep, had slower reaction times and more attentional failures, and showed substantial modifications in brain synchronization during and following an autonomous drive compared to a manually controlled drive. Our findings suggest that the introduction of partial self-driving capabilities in vehicles has the potential to paradoxically increase accident risk.https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-92914-5
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Erin E. Flynn-Evans
Lily R. Wong
Yukiyo Kuriyagawa
Nikhil Gowda
Patrick F. Cravalho
Sean Pradhan
Nathan H. Feick
Nicholas G. Bathurst
Zachary L. Glaros
Theerawit Wilaiprasitporn
Kanika Bansal
Javier O. Garcia
Cassie J. Hilditch
spellingShingle Erin E. Flynn-Evans
Lily R. Wong
Yukiyo Kuriyagawa
Nikhil Gowda
Patrick F. Cravalho
Sean Pradhan
Nathan H. Feick
Nicholas G. Bathurst
Zachary L. Glaros
Theerawit Wilaiprasitporn
Kanika Bansal
Javier O. Garcia
Cassie J. Hilditch
Supervision of a self-driving vehicle unmasks latent sleepiness relative to manually controlled driving
Scientific Reports
author_facet Erin E. Flynn-Evans
Lily R. Wong
Yukiyo Kuriyagawa
Nikhil Gowda
Patrick F. Cravalho
Sean Pradhan
Nathan H. Feick
Nicholas G. Bathurst
Zachary L. Glaros
Theerawit Wilaiprasitporn
Kanika Bansal
Javier O. Garcia
Cassie J. Hilditch
author_sort Erin E. Flynn-Evans
title Supervision of a self-driving vehicle unmasks latent sleepiness relative to manually controlled driving
title_short Supervision of a self-driving vehicle unmasks latent sleepiness relative to manually controlled driving
title_full Supervision of a self-driving vehicle unmasks latent sleepiness relative to manually controlled driving
title_fullStr Supervision of a self-driving vehicle unmasks latent sleepiness relative to manually controlled driving
title_full_unstemmed Supervision of a self-driving vehicle unmasks latent sleepiness relative to manually controlled driving
title_sort supervision of a self-driving vehicle unmasks latent sleepiness relative to manually controlled driving
publisher Nature Publishing Group
series Scientific Reports
issn 2045-2322
publishDate 2021-09-01
description Abstract Human error has been implicated as a causal factor in a large proportion of road accidents. Automated driving systems purport to mitigate this risk, but self-driving systems that allow a driver to entirely disengage from the driving task also require the driver to monitor the environment and take control when necessary. Given that sleep loss impairs monitoring performance and there is a high prevalence of sleep deficiency in modern society, we hypothesized that supervising a self-driving vehicle would unmask latent sleepiness compared to manually controlled driving among individuals following their typical sleep schedules. We found that participants felt sleepier, had more involuntary transitions to sleep, had slower reaction times and more attentional failures, and showed substantial modifications in brain synchronization during and following an autonomous drive compared to a manually controlled drive. Our findings suggest that the introduction of partial self-driving capabilities in vehicles has the potential to paradoxically increase accident risk.
url https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-92914-5
work_keys_str_mv AT erineflynnevans supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT lilyrwong supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT yukiyokuriyagawa supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT nikhilgowda supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT patrickfcravalho supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT seanpradhan supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT nathanhfeick supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT nicholasgbathurst supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT zacharylglaros supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT theerawitwilaiprasitporn supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT kanikabansal supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT javierogarcia supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
AT cassiejhilditch supervisionofaselfdrivingvehicleunmaskslatentsleepinessrelativetomanuallycontrolleddriving
_version_ 1717375682156167168