A leprosy clinical severity scale for erythema nodosum leprosum: An international, multicentre validation study of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale.

OBJECTIVES:We wished to validate our recently devised 16-item ENLIST ENL Severity Scale, a clinical tool for measuring the severity of the serious leprosy associated complication of erythema nodosum leprosum (ENL). We also wished to assess the responsiveness of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale in detec...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Stephen L Walker, Anna M Sales, C Ruth Butlin, Mahesh Shah, Armi Maghanoy, Saba M Lambert, Joydeepa Darlong, Benjamin Jewel Rozario, Vivek V Pai, Marivic Balagon, Shimelis N Doni, Deanna A Hagge, José A C Nery, Kapil D Neupane, Suwash Baral, Biliom A Sangma, Digafe T Alembo, Abeba M Yetaye, Belaynesh A Hassan, Mohammed B Shelemo, Peter G Nicholls, Diana N J Lockwood, Erythema Nodosum Leprosum International STudy Group
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2017-07-01
Series:PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases
Online Access:http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5510881?pdf=render
id doaj-494c8830dec049d4aaa11c5bac5d5485
record_format Article
spelling doaj-494c8830dec049d4aaa11c5bac5d54852020-11-25T01:46:38ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases1935-27271935-27352017-07-01117e000571610.1371/journal.pntd.0005716A leprosy clinical severity scale for erythema nodosum leprosum: An international, multicentre validation study of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale.Stephen L WalkerAnna M SalesC Ruth ButlinMahesh ShahArmi MaghanoySaba M LambertJoydeepa DarlongBenjamin Jewel RozarioVivek V PaiMarivic BalagonShimelis N DoniDeanna A HaggeJosé A C NeryKapil D NeupaneSuwash BaralBiliom A SangmaDigafe T AlemboAbeba M YetayeBelaynesh A HassanMohammed B ShelemoPeter G NichollsDiana N J LockwoodErythema Nodosum Leprosum International STudy GroupOBJECTIVES:We wished to validate our recently devised 16-item ENLIST ENL Severity Scale, a clinical tool for measuring the severity of the serious leprosy associated complication of erythema nodosum leprosum (ENL). We also wished to assess the responsiveness of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale in detecting clinical change in patients with ENL. METHODS:Participants, recruited from seven centres in six leprosy endemic countries, were assessed using the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale by two researchers, one of whom categorised the severity of ENL. At a subsequent visit a further assessment using the scale was made and both participant and physician rated the change in ENL using the subjective categories of "Much better", "somewhat better", "somewhat worse" and "much worse" compared with "No change" or "about the same". RESULTS:447 participants were assessed with the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale. The Cronbach alpha of the scale and each item was calculated to determine the internal consistency of the scale. The ENLIST ENL Severity Scale had good internal consistency and this improved following removal of six items to give a Cronbach's alpha of 0.77. The cut off between mild ENL and more severe disease was 9 determined using ROC curves. The minimal important difference of the scale was determined to be 5 using both participant and physician ratings of change. CONCLUSIONS:The 10-item ENLIST ENL Severity Scale is the first valid, reliable and responsive measure of ENL severity and improves our ability to assess and compare patients and their treatments in this severe and difficult to manage complication of leprosy. The ENLIST ENL Severity Scale will assist physicians in the monitoring and treatment of patients with ENL. The ENLIST ENL Severity Scale is easy to apply and will be useful as an outcome measure in treatment studies and enable the standardisation of other clinical and laboratory ENL research.http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5510881?pdf=render
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Stephen L Walker
Anna M Sales
C Ruth Butlin
Mahesh Shah
Armi Maghanoy
Saba M Lambert
Joydeepa Darlong
Benjamin Jewel Rozario
Vivek V Pai
Marivic Balagon
Shimelis N Doni
Deanna A Hagge
José A C Nery
Kapil D Neupane
Suwash Baral
Biliom A Sangma
Digafe T Alembo
Abeba M Yetaye
Belaynesh A Hassan
Mohammed B Shelemo
Peter G Nicholls
Diana N J Lockwood
Erythema Nodosum Leprosum International STudy Group
spellingShingle Stephen L Walker
Anna M Sales
C Ruth Butlin
Mahesh Shah
Armi Maghanoy
Saba M Lambert
Joydeepa Darlong
Benjamin Jewel Rozario
Vivek V Pai
Marivic Balagon
Shimelis N Doni
Deanna A Hagge
José A C Nery
Kapil D Neupane
Suwash Baral
Biliom A Sangma
Digafe T Alembo
Abeba M Yetaye
Belaynesh A Hassan
Mohammed B Shelemo
Peter G Nicholls
Diana N J Lockwood
Erythema Nodosum Leprosum International STudy Group
A leprosy clinical severity scale for erythema nodosum leprosum: An international, multicentre validation study of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale.
PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases
author_facet Stephen L Walker
Anna M Sales
C Ruth Butlin
Mahesh Shah
Armi Maghanoy
Saba M Lambert
Joydeepa Darlong
Benjamin Jewel Rozario
Vivek V Pai
Marivic Balagon
Shimelis N Doni
Deanna A Hagge
José A C Nery
Kapil D Neupane
Suwash Baral
Biliom A Sangma
Digafe T Alembo
Abeba M Yetaye
Belaynesh A Hassan
Mohammed B Shelemo
Peter G Nicholls
Diana N J Lockwood
Erythema Nodosum Leprosum International STudy Group
author_sort Stephen L Walker
title A leprosy clinical severity scale for erythema nodosum leprosum: An international, multicentre validation study of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale.
title_short A leprosy clinical severity scale for erythema nodosum leprosum: An international, multicentre validation study of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale.
title_full A leprosy clinical severity scale for erythema nodosum leprosum: An international, multicentre validation study of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale.
title_fullStr A leprosy clinical severity scale for erythema nodosum leprosum: An international, multicentre validation study of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale.
title_full_unstemmed A leprosy clinical severity scale for erythema nodosum leprosum: An international, multicentre validation study of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale.
title_sort leprosy clinical severity scale for erythema nodosum leprosum: an international, multicentre validation study of the enlist enl severity scale.
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
series PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases
issn 1935-2727
1935-2735
publishDate 2017-07-01
description OBJECTIVES:We wished to validate our recently devised 16-item ENLIST ENL Severity Scale, a clinical tool for measuring the severity of the serious leprosy associated complication of erythema nodosum leprosum (ENL). We also wished to assess the responsiveness of the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale in detecting clinical change in patients with ENL. METHODS:Participants, recruited from seven centres in six leprosy endemic countries, were assessed using the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale by two researchers, one of whom categorised the severity of ENL. At a subsequent visit a further assessment using the scale was made and both participant and physician rated the change in ENL using the subjective categories of "Much better", "somewhat better", "somewhat worse" and "much worse" compared with "No change" or "about the same". RESULTS:447 participants were assessed with the ENLIST ENL Severity Scale. The Cronbach alpha of the scale and each item was calculated to determine the internal consistency of the scale. The ENLIST ENL Severity Scale had good internal consistency and this improved following removal of six items to give a Cronbach's alpha of 0.77. The cut off between mild ENL and more severe disease was 9 determined using ROC curves. The minimal important difference of the scale was determined to be 5 using both participant and physician ratings of change. CONCLUSIONS:The 10-item ENLIST ENL Severity Scale is the first valid, reliable and responsive measure of ENL severity and improves our ability to assess and compare patients and their treatments in this severe and difficult to manage complication of leprosy. The ENLIST ENL Severity Scale will assist physicians in the monitoring and treatment of patients with ENL. The ENLIST ENL Severity Scale is easy to apply and will be useful as an outcome measure in treatment studies and enable the standardisation of other clinical and laboratory ENL research.
url http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC5510881?pdf=render
work_keys_str_mv AT stephenlwalker aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT annamsales aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT cruthbutlin aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT maheshshah aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT armimaghanoy aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT sabamlambert aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT joydeepadarlong aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT benjaminjewelrozario aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT vivekvpai aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT marivicbalagon aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT shimelisndoni aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT deannaahagge aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT joseacnery aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT kapildneupane aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT suwashbaral aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT biliomasangma aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT digafetalembo aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT abebamyetaye aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT belayneshahassan aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT mohammedbshelemo aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT petergnicholls aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT diananjlockwood aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT erythemanodosumleprosuminternationalstudygroup aleprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT stephenlwalker leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT annamsales leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT cruthbutlin leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT maheshshah leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT armimaghanoy leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT sabamlambert leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT joydeepadarlong leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT benjaminjewelrozario leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT vivekvpai leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT marivicbalagon leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT shimelisndoni leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT deannaahagge leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT joseacnery leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT kapildneupane leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT suwashbaral leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT biliomasangma leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT digafetalembo leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT abebamyetaye leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT belayneshahassan leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT mohammedbshelemo leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT petergnicholls leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT diananjlockwood leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
AT erythemanodosumleprosuminternationalstudygroup leprosyclinicalseverityscaleforerythemanodosumleprosumaninternationalmulticentrevalidationstudyoftheenlistenlseverityscale
_version_ 1725018191515615232