Current and future trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City: a dynamic modelling analysis

Background: After steady decline since the 1990s, tuberculosis incidence in New York City and throughout the USA has plateaued. We aimed to explore the major drivers of the flattening of tuberculosis incidence in New York City and to project the future trajectory of the tuberculosis epidemic in the...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Dr Anthony T Fojo, MD, Natalie L Stennis, MPH, Andrew S Azman, PhD, Emily A Kendall, MD, Sourya Shrestha, PhD, Shama D Ahuja, PhD, David W Dowdy, MD
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Elsevier 2017-07-01
Series:The Lancet Public Health
Online Access:http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2468266717301196
id doaj-49848791475e45fdb6674bc239665e6b
record_format Article
spelling doaj-49848791475e45fdb6674bc239665e6b2020-11-25T01:34:34ZengElsevierThe Lancet Public Health2468-26672017-07-0127e323e33010.1016/S2468-2667(17)30119-6Current and future trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City: a dynamic modelling analysisDr Anthony T Fojo, MD0Natalie L Stennis, MPH1Andrew S Azman, PhD2Emily A Kendall, MD3Sourya Shrestha, PhD4Shama D Ahuja, PhD5David W Dowdy, MD6Division of General Internal Medicine, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USABureau of Tuberculosis Control, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Long Island City, NY, USADepartment of Epidemiology, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USADivision of Infectious Diseases, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USADepartment of Epidemiology, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USABureau of Tuberculosis Control, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, Long Island City, NY, USADepartment of Epidemiology, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USABackground: After steady decline since the 1990s, tuberculosis incidence in New York City and throughout the USA has plateaued. We aimed to explore the major drivers of the flattening of tuberculosis incidence in New York City and to project the future trajectory of the tuberculosis epidemic in the absence of any additional intervention. Methods: We developed a compartmental transmission model of tuberculosis in New York City. The model was parameterised with detailed epidemiological data and stratified by age and nativity (US-born vs foreign-born). We ran the model under five alternative scenarios representing different explanations for recent declines in tuberculosis incidence. We evaluated the relative likelihood of each scenario by comparing its output with available data. We used the most likely scenarios to explore potential mechanisms underlying the recent declines in tuberculosis in New York City and to describe the reasonable range of future epidemic trajectories. Our primary outcome was the projected rate of decline in tuberculosis incidence from 2015 to 2025. Model calibration yielded estimates of future disease incidence and reductions in incidence with 95% credible intervals (CrIs). Findings: Demographic changes and declining tuberculosis transmission alone were insufficient to explain recent trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City. Only scenarios that assumed contemporary changes in tuberculosis dynamics among foreign-born individuals—a declining rate of reactivation or a decrease in imported subclinical tuberculosis—could accurately describe the trajectory of disease incidence since 2007. In those scenarios, the projected decline in incidence from 2015 to 2025 varied from minimal (2·0% per year [95% CrI 0·4–3·5]) to similar to 2005 to 2009 trends (4·4% per year [2·5–6·4]). The primary factor differentiating optimistic from pessimistic projections was the degree to which improvements in tuberculosis dynamics among the foreign-born population continued into the coming decade. Interpretation: Further progress towards elimination of tuberculosis in New York City requires additional focus on the foreign-born population. Without additional intervention in this group, tuberculosis incidence might not decline further. Funding: None.http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2468266717301196
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Dr Anthony T Fojo, MD
Natalie L Stennis, MPH
Andrew S Azman, PhD
Emily A Kendall, MD
Sourya Shrestha, PhD
Shama D Ahuja, PhD
David W Dowdy, MD
spellingShingle Dr Anthony T Fojo, MD
Natalie L Stennis, MPH
Andrew S Azman, PhD
Emily A Kendall, MD
Sourya Shrestha, PhD
Shama D Ahuja, PhD
David W Dowdy, MD
Current and future trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City: a dynamic modelling analysis
The Lancet Public Health
author_facet Dr Anthony T Fojo, MD
Natalie L Stennis, MPH
Andrew S Azman, PhD
Emily A Kendall, MD
Sourya Shrestha, PhD
Shama D Ahuja, PhD
David W Dowdy, MD
author_sort Dr Anthony T Fojo, MD
title Current and future trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City: a dynamic modelling analysis
title_short Current and future trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City: a dynamic modelling analysis
title_full Current and future trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City: a dynamic modelling analysis
title_fullStr Current and future trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City: a dynamic modelling analysis
title_full_unstemmed Current and future trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City: a dynamic modelling analysis
title_sort current and future trends in tuberculosis incidence in new york city: a dynamic modelling analysis
publisher Elsevier
series The Lancet Public Health
issn 2468-2667
publishDate 2017-07-01
description Background: After steady decline since the 1990s, tuberculosis incidence in New York City and throughout the USA has plateaued. We aimed to explore the major drivers of the flattening of tuberculosis incidence in New York City and to project the future trajectory of the tuberculosis epidemic in the absence of any additional intervention. Methods: We developed a compartmental transmission model of tuberculosis in New York City. The model was parameterised with detailed epidemiological data and stratified by age and nativity (US-born vs foreign-born). We ran the model under five alternative scenarios representing different explanations for recent declines in tuberculosis incidence. We evaluated the relative likelihood of each scenario by comparing its output with available data. We used the most likely scenarios to explore potential mechanisms underlying the recent declines in tuberculosis in New York City and to describe the reasonable range of future epidemic trajectories. Our primary outcome was the projected rate of decline in tuberculosis incidence from 2015 to 2025. Model calibration yielded estimates of future disease incidence and reductions in incidence with 95% credible intervals (CrIs). Findings: Demographic changes and declining tuberculosis transmission alone were insufficient to explain recent trends in tuberculosis incidence in New York City. Only scenarios that assumed contemporary changes in tuberculosis dynamics among foreign-born individuals—a declining rate of reactivation or a decrease in imported subclinical tuberculosis—could accurately describe the trajectory of disease incidence since 2007. In those scenarios, the projected decline in incidence from 2015 to 2025 varied from minimal (2·0% per year [95% CrI 0·4–3·5]) to similar to 2005 to 2009 trends (4·4% per year [2·5–6·4]). The primary factor differentiating optimistic from pessimistic projections was the degree to which improvements in tuberculosis dynamics among the foreign-born population continued into the coming decade. Interpretation: Further progress towards elimination of tuberculosis in New York City requires additional focus on the foreign-born population. Without additional intervention in this group, tuberculosis incidence might not decline further. Funding: None.
url http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2468266717301196
work_keys_str_mv AT dranthonytfojomd currentandfuturetrendsintuberculosisincidenceinnewyorkcityadynamicmodellinganalysis
AT natalielstennismph currentandfuturetrendsintuberculosisincidenceinnewyorkcityadynamicmodellinganalysis
AT andrewsazmanphd currentandfuturetrendsintuberculosisincidenceinnewyorkcityadynamicmodellinganalysis
AT emilyakendallmd currentandfuturetrendsintuberculosisincidenceinnewyorkcityadynamicmodellinganalysis
AT souryashresthaphd currentandfuturetrendsintuberculosisincidenceinnewyorkcityadynamicmodellinganalysis
AT shamadahujaphd currentandfuturetrendsintuberculosisincidenceinnewyorkcityadynamicmodellinganalysis
AT davidwdowdymd currentandfuturetrendsintuberculosisincidenceinnewyorkcityadynamicmodellinganalysis
_version_ 1725071136389070848