The Challenges of Using Oropharyngeal Samples To Measure Pneumococcal Carriage in Adults
Streptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus) is a significant global pathogen. Accurate identification and serotyping are vital. In contrast with World Health Organization recommendations based on culture methods, we demonstrate that pneumococcal identification and serotyping with molecular methods a...
Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
American Society for Microbiology
2020-07-01
|
Series: | mSphere |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1128/mSphere.00478-20 |
id |
doaj-4b1d29c439764cbd8990fb1c1290526b |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-4b1d29c439764cbd8990fb1c1290526b2020-11-25T03:18:51ZengAmerican Society for MicrobiologymSphere2379-50422020-07-0154e00478-2010.1128/mSphere.00478-20The Challenges of Using Oropharyngeal Samples To Measure Pneumococcal Carriage in AdultsLaura K. BoelsenEileen M. DunneKatherine A. GouldF. Tupou RatuJorge E. VidalFiona M. RussellE. Kim MulhollandJason HindsCatherine SatzkeStreptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus) is a significant global pathogen. Accurate identification and serotyping are vital. In contrast with World Health Organization recommendations based on culture methods, we demonstrate that pneumococcal identification and serotyping with molecular methods are affected by sample type. Results from oropharyngeal samples from adults were often inaccurate. This is particularly important for assessment of vaccine impact using carriage studies, particularly in low- and middle-income countries where there are significant barriers for disease surveillance.Streptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus) carriage is commonly used to measure effects of pneumococcal vaccines. Based on findings from culture-based studies, the World Health Organization recommends both nasopharyngeal (NP) and oropharyngeal (OP) sampling for detecting adult carriage. Given evidence of potential confounding by other streptococci, we evaluated molecular methods for pneumococcal identification and serotyping from 250 OP samples collected from adults in Fiji, using paired NP samples for comparison. Samples were screened using lytA quantitative PCR (qPCR), as well as pneumococcal identification and serotyping conducted by DNA microarray. A subset of OP samples were characterized by latex sweep agglutination and multiplex PCR. Alternate qPCR assays (piaB and bguR) for pneumococcal identification were evaluated. The lytA qPCR was less specific and had poor positive predictive value (PPV) in OP samples (88% and 26%, respectively) compared with NP samples (95% and 64%, respectively). Using additional targets piaB and/or bguR improved qPCR specificity in OP, although the PPV (42 to 53%) was still poor. Using microarray, we found that 102/107 (95%) of OP samples contained nonpneumococcal streptococci with partial or divergent complements of pneumococcal capsule genes. We explored 91 colonies isolated from 11 OP samples using various techniques, including multiplex PCR, latex agglutination, and microarray. We found that nonpneumococcal streptococci contribute to false positives in pneumococcal serotyping and may also contribute to spurious identification by qPCR. Our results highlight that molecular approaches should include multiple loci to minimize false-positive results when testing OP samples. Regardless of method, pneumococcal identification and serotyping results from OP samples should be interpreted with caution.https://doi.org/10.1128/mSphere.00478-20pcrstreptococcus pneumoniaecarriagegenotypicidentificationnasopharyngealoropharyngealserotyping |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Laura K. Boelsen Eileen M. Dunne Katherine A. Gould F. Tupou Ratu Jorge E. Vidal Fiona M. Russell E. Kim Mulholland Jason Hinds Catherine Satzke |
spellingShingle |
Laura K. Boelsen Eileen M. Dunne Katherine A. Gould F. Tupou Ratu Jorge E. Vidal Fiona M. Russell E. Kim Mulholland Jason Hinds Catherine Satzke The Challenges of Using Oropharyngeal Samples To Measure Pneumococcal Carriage in Adults mSphere pcr streptococcus pneumoniae carriage genotypic identification nasopharyngeal oropharyngeal serotyping |
author_facet |
Laura K. Boelsen Eileen M. Dunne Katherine A. Gould F. Tupou Ratu Jorge E. Vidal Fiona M. Russell E. Kim Mulholland Jason Hinds Catherine Satzke |
author_sort |
Laura K. Boelsen |
title |
The Challenges of Using Oropharyngeal Samples To Measure Pneumococcal Carriage in Adults |
title_short |
The Challenges of Using Oropharyngeal Samples To Measure Pneumococcal Carriage in Adults |
title_full |
The Challenges of Using Oropharyngeal Samples To Measure Pneumococcal Carriage in Adults |
title_fullStr |
The Challenges of Using Oropharyngeal Samples To Measure Pneumococcal Carriage in Adults |
title_full_unstemmed |
The Challenges of Using Oropharyngeal Samples To Measure Pneumococcal Carriage in Adults |
title_sort |
challenges of using oropharyngeal samples to measure pneumococcal carriage in adults |
publisher |
American Society for Microbiology |
series |
mSphere |
issn |
2379-5042 |
publishDate |
2020-07-01 |
description |
Streptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus) is a significant global pathogen. Accurate identification and serotyping are vital. In contrast with World Health Organization recommendations based on culture methods, we demonstrate that pneumococcal identification and serotyping with molecular methods are affected by sample type. Results from oropharyngeal samples from adults were often inaccurate. This is particularly important for assessment of vaccine impact using carriage studies, particularly in low- and middle-income countries where there are significant barriers for disease surveillance.Streptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus) carriage is commonly used to measure effects of pneumococcal vaccines. Based on findings from culture-based studies, the World Health Organization recommends both nasopharyngeal (NP) and oropharyngeal (OP) sampling for detecting adult carriage. Given evidence of potential confounding by other streptococci, we evaluated molecular methods for pneumococcal identification and serotyping from 250 OP samples collected from adults in Fiji, using paired NP samples for comparison. Samples were screened using lytA quantitative PCR (qPCR), as well as pneumococcal identification and serotyping conducted by DNA microarray. A subset of OP samples were characterized by latex sweep agglutination and multiplex PCR. Alternate qPCR assays (piaB and bguR) for pneumococcal identification were evaluated. The lytA qPCR was less specific and had poor positive predictive value (PPV) in OP samples (88% and 26%, respectively) compared with NP samples (95% and 64%, respectively). Using additional targets piaB and/or bguR improved qPCR specificity in OP, although the PPV (42 to 53%) was still poor. Using microarray, we found that 102/107 (95%) of OP samples contained nonpneumococcal streptococci with partial or divergent complements of pneumococcal capsule genes. We explored 91 colonies isolated from 11 OP samples using various techniques, including multiplex PCR, latex agglutination, and microarray. We found that nonpneumococcal streptococci contribute to false positives in pneumococcal serotyping and may also contribute to spurious identification by qPCR. Our results highlight that molecular approaches should include multiple loci to minimize false-positive results when testing OP samples. Regardless of method, pneumococcal identification and serotyping results from OP samples should be interpreted with caution. |
topic |
pcr streptococcus pneumoniae carriage genotypic identification nasopharyngeal oropharyngeal serotyping |
url |
https://doi.org/10.1128/mSphere.00478-20 |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT laurakboelsen thechallengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT eileenmdunne thechallengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT katherineagould thechallengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT ftupouratu thechallengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT jorgeevidal thechallengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT fionamrussell thechallengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT ekimmulholland thechallengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT jasonhinds thechallengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT catherinesatzke thechallengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT laurakboelsen challengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT eileenmdunne challengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT katherineagould challengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT ftupouratu challengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT jorgeevidal challengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT fionamrussell challengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT ekimmulholland challengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT jasonhinds challengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults AT catherinesatzke challengesofusingoropharyngealsamplestomeasurepneumococcalcarriageinadults |
_version_ |
1715250738958958592 |