ON THE PERFORMANCE OF DIFFERENT RANS BASED MODELS TO DESCRIBE THE TURBULENT FLOW IN AN AGITATED VESSEL USING NON-STRUCTURED GRIDS AND PIV VALIDATION

ABSTRACT The performances of the Standard κ-ε, RNG, Realizable, κ-ω and RSM turbulence models to describe the behavior of the flow in agitated tank reactors were evaluated. Because most of these tanks have complex geometries, structured meshing schemes are not a practical alternative in engineering....

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Alejandro Alonzo-Garcia, Víctor X. Mendoza-Escamilla, Sergio A. Martinez-Delgadillo, Israel Gonzalez-Neria, Claudia del C. Gutiérrez-Torres, José A. Jiménez-Bernal
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Brazilian Society of Chemical Engineering
Series:Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering
Subjects:
PIV
Online Access:http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0104-66322019000100361&lng=en&tlng=en
id doaj-526ec4b5220e4445aeaf120a5a46c10e
record_format Article
spelling doaj-526ec4b5220e4445aeaf120a5a46c10e2020-11-24T21:23:55ZengBrazilian Society of Chemical EngineeringBrazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering1678-438336136138210.1590/0104-6632.20190361s20180091S0104-66322019000100361ON THE PERFORMANCE OF DIFFERENT RANS BASED MODELS TO DESCRIBE THE TURBULENT FLOW IN AN AGITATED VESSEL USING NON-STRUCTURED GRIDS AND PIV VALIDATIONAlejandro Alonzo-GarciaVíctor X. Mendoza-EscamillaSergio A. Martinez-DelgadilloIsrael Gonzalez-NeriaClaudia del C. Gutiérrez-TorresJosé A. Jiménez-BernalABSTRACT The performances of the Standard κ-ε, RNG, Realizable, κ-ω and RSM turbulence models to describe the behavior of the flow in agitated tank reactors were evaluated. Because most of these tanks have complex geometries, structured meshing schemes are not a practical alternative in engineering. Two particular unstructured meshing schemes composed of either Cartesian Cut-Cell (CC) or Tetrahedral elements were tested in domains larger than 3 million cells. In this work, the blade thickness, which is usually disregarded, was accounted for. The performance of the turbulence models was validated by PIV measurements. A strong dependence on the grid size and the power number was found, with CC grids having good agreement with grids > 3.6 Million. The pumping number was independent of the cell number and the values agree with experimental data. The Realizable model resolved with a tetrahedral grid presented the overall best performance.http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0104-66322019000100361&lng=en&tlng=enAgitated tankPitched blade turbine, Cut-CellRANSTetrahedral cellsPIV
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Alejandro Alonzo-Garcia
Víctor X. Mendoza-Escamilla
Sergio A. Martinez-Delgadillo
Israel Gonzalez-Neria
Claudia del C. Gutiérrez-Torres
José A. Jiménez-Bernal
spellingShingle Alejandro Alonzo-Garcia
Víctor X. Mendoza-Escamilla
Sergio A. Martinez-Delgadillo
Israel Gonzalez-Neria
Claudia del C. Gutiérrez-Torres
José A. Jiménez-Bernal
ON THE PERFORMANCE OF DIFFERENT RANS BASED MODELS TO DESCRIBE THE TURBULENT FLOW IN AN AGITATED VESSEL USING NON-STRUCTURED GRIDS AND PIV VALIDATION
Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering
Agitated tank
Pitched blade turbine, Cut-Cell
RANS
Tetrahedral cells
PIV
author_facet Alejandro Alonzo-Garcia
Víctor X. Mendoza-Escamilla
Sergio A. Martinez-Delgadillo
Israel Gonzalez-Neria
Claudia del C. Gutiérrez-Torres
José A. Jiménez-Bernal
author_sort Alejandro Alonzo-Garcia
title ON THE PERFORMANCE OF DIFFERENT RANS BASED MODELS TO DESCRIBE THE TURBULENT FLOW IN AN AGITATED VESSEL USING NON-STRUCTURED GRIDS AND PIV VALIDATION
title_short ON THE PERFORMANCE OF DIFFERENT RANS BASED MODELS TO DESCRIBE THE TURBULENT FLOW IN AN AGITATED VESSEL USING NON-STRUCTURED GRIDS AND PIV VALIDATION
title_full ON THE PERFORMANCE OF DIFFERENT RANS BASED MODELS TO DESCRIBE THE TURBULENT FLOW IN AN AGITATED VESSEL USING NON-STRUCTURED GRIDS AND PIV VALIDATION
title_fullStr ON THE PERFORMANCE OF DIFFERENT RANS BASED MODELS TO DESCRIBE THE TURBULENT FLOW IN AN AGITATED VESSEL USING NON-STRUCTURED GRIDS AND PIV VALIDATION
title_full_unstemmed ON THE PERFORMANCE OF DIFFERENT RANS BASED MODELS TO DESCRIBE THE TURBULENT FLOW IN AN AGITATED VESSEL USING NON-STRUCTURED GRIDS AND PIV VALIDATION
title_sort on the performance of different rans based models to describe the turbulent flow in an agitated vessel using non-structured grids and piv validation
publisher Brazilian Society of Chemical Engineering
series Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering
issn 1678-4383
description ABSTRACT The performances of the Standard κ-ε, RNG, Realizable, κ-ω and RSM turbulence models to describe the behavior of the flow in agitated tank reactors were evaluated. Because most of these tanks have complex geometries, structured meshing schemes are not a practical alternative in engineering. Two particular unstructured meshing schemes composed of either Cartesian Cut-Cell (CC) or Tetrahedral elements were tested in domains larger than 3 million cells. In this work, the blade thickness, which is usually disregarded, was accounted for. The performance of the turbulence models was validated by PIV measurements. A strong dependence on the grid size and the power number was found, with CC grids having good agreement with grids > 3.6 Million. The pumping number was independent of the cell number and the values agree with experimental data. The Realizable model resolved with a tetrahedral grid presented the overall best performance.
topic Agitated tank
Pitched blade turbine, Cut-Cell
RANS
Tetrahedral cells
PIV
url http://www.scielo.br/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0104-66322019000100361&lng=en&tlng=en
work_keys_str_mv AT alejandroalonzogarcia ontheperformanceofdifferentransbasedmodelstodescribetheturbulentflowinanagitatedvesselusingnonstructuredgridsandpivvalidation
AT victorxmendozaescamilla ontheperformanceofdifferentransbasedmodelstodescribetheturbulentflowinanagitatedvesselusingnonstructuredgridsandpivvalidation
AT sergioamartinezdelgadillo ontheperformanceofdifferentransbasedmodelstodescribetheturbulentflowinanagitatedvesselusingnonstructuredgridsandpivvalidation
AT israelgonzalezneria ontheperformanceofdifferentransbasedmodelstodescribetheturbulentflowinanagitatedvesselusingnonstructuredgridsandpivvalidation
AT claudiadelcgutierreztorres ontheperformanceofdifferentransbasedmodelstodescribetheturbulentflowinanagitatedvesselusingnonstructuredgridsandpivvalidation
AT joseajimenezbernal ontheperformanceofdifferentransbasedmodelstodescribetheturbulentflowinanagitatedvesselusingnonstructuredgridsandpivvalidation
_version_ 1725990468230053888