The Added Value of Bloodpool SPECT/CT in Painful Non-Operated Foot and Ankle Undiagnosed With Standard Three-Phase Bone Scintigraphy

Purpose: To evaluate the interest of adding a bloodpool SPECT/CT to standard three-phase bone scintigraphy (BS) for etiological diagnosis of subacute and chronic lower extremity pains.Methods: We prospectively included patients addressed for pain of lower extremities lasting for at least 6 weeks, wi...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Cécile Cuvilliers, Xavier Palard-Novello, Clémence Pontoizeau, Pierre Meneret, Anne Devillers, Florence Le Jeune, Antoine Girard
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Frontiers Media S.A. 2021-03-01
Series:Frontiers in Medicine
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmed.2021.634419/full
id doaj-56a8edf9aa7a431d977006d283278590
record_format Article
spelling doaj-56a8edf9aa7a431d977006d2832785902021-03-05T04:46:24ZengFrontiers Media S.A.Frontiers in Medicine2296-858X2021-03-01810.3389/fmed.2021.634419634419The Added Value of Bloodpool SPECT/CT in Painful Non-Operated Foot and Ankle Undiagnosed With Standard Three-Phase Bone ScintigraphyCécile Cuvilliers0Cécile Cuvilliers1Xavier Palard-Novello2Xavier Palard-Novello3Clémence Pontoizeau4Pierre Meneret5Pierre Meneret6Anne Devillers7Florence Le Jeune8Florence Le Jeune9Antoine Girard10Antoine Girard11Nuclear Medicine Department, Centre Eugène Marquis, Rennes, FranceUniversity of Rennes 1, Rennes, FranceNuclear Medicine Department, Centre Eugène Marquis, Rennes, FranceUniversity of Rennes 1, Rennes, FranceNuclear Medicine Department, Centre Eugène Marquis, Rennes, FranceNuclear Medicine Department, Centre Eugène Marquis, Rennes, FranceUniversity of Rennes 1, Rennes, FranceNuclear Medicine Department, Centre Eugène Marquis, Rennes, FranceNuclear Medicine Department, Centre Eugène Marquis, Rennes, FranceUniversity of Rennes 1, Rennes, FranceNuclear Medicine Department, Centre Eugène Marquis, Rennes, FranceUniversity of Rennes 1, Rennes, FrancePurpose: To evaluate the interest of adding a bloodpool SPECT/CT to standard three-phase bone scintigraphy (BS) for etiological diagnosis of subacute and chronic lower extremity pains.Methods: We prospectively included patients addressed for pain of lower extremities lasting for at least 6 weeks, without previous surgery. They underwent a standard three-phase BS including late phase SPECT/CT, modified with an additional bloodpool SPECT/CT acquisition. Two independent physicians interpreted the images provided by both protocols. Diagnostic conclusion, diagnostic confidence, and interrater agreements were compared.Results: One hundred and eighteen lower extremities from 113 patients were analyzed (71 men, median age of 53 years). Adding bloodpool SPECT/CT to standard three-phase BS changed diagnostic conclusions in 24.6% (29/118) of lower extremities. The modified protocol revealed at least one diagnostic conclusion explaining the pain in 89% of extremities, rather than 83.1% with the standard protocol (p = 0.02). Tendinopathies were diagnosed in 12.7% of lower extremities, rather than 4.2% with standard BS (p = 0.002). Adding bloodpool SPECT/CT substantially increased overall confidence of each reader (p < 0.001). Inter-reader agreement was not significantly impacted.Conclusion: Adding bloodpool SPECT/CT to standard three-phase BS impacted diagnostic conclusion in a quarter of the patients with painful lower extremities, notably by revealing significantly more tendonitis.https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmed.2021.634419/fullbloodpool SPECTbone scintigraphyanklefootearly SPECT/CT
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Cécile Cuvilliers
Cécile Cuvilliers
Xavier Palard-Novello
Xavier Palard-Novello
Clémence Pontoizeau
Pierre Meneret
Pierre Meneret
Anne Devillers
Florence Le Jeune
Florence Le Jeune
Antoine Girard
Antoine Girard
spellingShingle Cécile Cuvilliers
Cécile Cuvilliers
Xavier Palard-Novello
Xavier Palard-Novello
Clémence Pontoizeau
Pierre Meneret
Pierre Meneret
Anne Devillers
Florence Le Jeune
Florence Le Jeune
Antoine Girard
Antoine Girard
The Added Value of Bloodpool SPECT/CT in Painful Non-Operated Foot and Ankle Undiagnosed With Standard Three-Phase Bone Scintigraphy
Frontiers in Medicine
bloodpool SPECT
bone scintigraphy
ankle
foot
early SPECT/CT
author_facet Cécile Cuvilliers
Cécile Cuvilliers
Xavier Palard-Novello
Xavier Palard-Novello
Clémence Pontoizeau
Pierre Meneret
Pierre Meneret
Anne Devillers
Florence Le Jeune
Florence Le Jeune
Antoine Girard
Antoine Girard
author_sort Cécile Cuvilliers
title The Added Value of Bloodpool SPECT/CT in Painful Non-Operated Foot and Ankle Undiagnosed With Standard Three-Phase Bone Scintigraphy
title_short The Added Value of Bloodpool SPECT/CT in Painful Non-Operated Foot and Ankle Undiagnosed With Standard Three-Phase Bone Scintigraphy
title_full The Added Value of Bloodpool SPECT/CT in Painful Non-Operated Foot and Ankle Undiagnosed With Standard Three-Phase Bone Scintigraphy
title_fullStr The Added Value of Bloodpool SPECT/CT in Painful Non-Operated Foot and Ankle Undiagnosed With Standard Three-Phase Bone Scintigraphy
title_full_unstemmed The Added Value of Bloodpool SPECT/CT in Painful Non-Operated Foot and Ankle Undiagnosed With Standard Three-Phase Bone Scintigraphy
title_sort added value of bloodpool spect/ct in painful non-operated foot and ankle undiagnosed with standard three-phase bone scintigraphy
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
series Frontiers in Medicine
issn 2296-858X
publishDate 2021-03-01
description Purpose: To evaluate the interest of adding a bloodpool SPECT/CT to standard three-phase bone scintigraphy (BS) for etiological diagnosis of subacute and chronic lower extremity pains.Methods: We prospectively included patients addressed for pain of lower extremities lasting for at least 6 weeks, without previous surgery. They underwent a standard three-phase BS including late phase SPECT/CT, modified with an additional bloodpool SPECT/CT acquisition. Two independent physicians interpreted the images provided by both protocols. Diagnostic conclusion, diagnostic confidence, and interrater agreements were compared.Results: One hundred and eighteen lower extremities from 113 patients were analyzed (71 men, median age of 53 years). Adding bloodpool SPECT/CT to standard three-phase BS changed diagnostic conclusions in 24.6% (29/118) of lower extremities. The modified protocol revealed at least one diagnostic conclusion explaining the pain in 89% of extremities, rather than 83.1% with the standard protocol (p = 0.02). Tendinopathies were diagnosed in 12.7% of lower extremities, rather than 4.2% with standard BS (p = 0.002). Adding bloodpool SPECT/CT substantially increased overall confidence of each reader (p < 0.001). Inter-reader agreement was not significantly impacted.Conclusion: Adding bloodpool SPECT/CT to standard three-phase BS impacted diagnostic conclusion in a quarter of the patients with painful lower extremities, notably by revealing significantly more tendonitis.
topic bloodpool SPECT
bone scintigraphy
ankle
foot
early SPECT/CT
url https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmed.2021.634419/full
work_keys_str_mv AT cecilecuvilliers theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT cecilecuvilliers theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT xavierpalardnovello theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT xavierpalardnovello theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT clemencepontoizeau theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT pierremeneret theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT pierremeneret theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT annedevillers theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT florencelejeune theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT florencelejeune theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT antoinegirard theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT antoinegirard theaddedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT cecilecuvilliers addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT cecilecuvilliers addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT xavierpalardnovello addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT xavierpalardnovello addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT clemencepontoizeau addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT pierremeneret addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT pierremeneret addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT annedevillers addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT florencelejeune addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT florencelejeune addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT antoinegirard addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
AT antoinegirard addedvalueofbloodpoolspectctinpainfulnonoperatedfootandankleundiagnosedwithstandardthreephasebonescintigraphy
_version_ 1724230785453522944