The design, launch and assessment of a new volunteer-based plant monitoring scheme for the United Kingdom.
Volunteer-based plant monitoring in the UK has focused mainly on distribution mapping; there has been less emphasis on the collection of data on plant communities and habitats. Abundance data provide different insights into ecological pattern and allow for more powerful inference when considering en...
Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Public Library of Science (PLoS)
2019-01-01
|
Series: | PLoS ONE |
Online Access: | https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0215891 |
id |
doaj-589ada103b3042bb8014f3310fa69ad2 |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-589ada103b3042bb8014f3310fa69ad22021-03-03T20:42:44ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032019-01-01144e021589110.1371/journal.pone.0215891The design, launch and assessment of a new volunteer-based plant monitoring scheme for the United Kingdom.Oliver L PescottKevin J WalkerFelicity HarrisHayley NewChristine M CheffingsNiki NewtonMark JitlalJohn RedheadSimon M SmartDavid B RoyVolunteer-based plant monitoring in the UK has focused mainly on distribution mapping; there has been less emphasis on the collection of data on plant communities and habitats. Abundance data provide different insights into ecological pattern and allow for more powerful inference when considering environmental change. Abundance monitoring for other groups of organisms is well-established in the UK, e.g. for birds and butterflies, and conservation agencies have long desired comparable schemes for plants. We describe a new citizen science scheme for the UK (the 'National Plant Monitoring Scheme'; NPMS), with the primary aim of monitoring the abundance of plants at small scales. Scheme development emphasised volunteer flexibility through scheme co-creation and feedback, whilst retaining a rigorous approach to design. Sampling frameworks, target habitats and species, field methods and power are all described. We also evaluate several outcomes of the scheme design process, including: (i) landscape-context bias in the first two years of the scheme; (ii) the ability of different sets of indicator species to capture the main ecological gradients of UK vegetation; and, (iii) species richness bias in returns relative to a professional survey. Survey rates have been promising (over 60% of squares released have been surveyed), although upland squares are under-represented. Ecological gradients present in an ordination of an independent, unbiased, national survey were well-represented by NPMS indicator species, although further filtering to an entry-level set of easily identifiable species degraded signal in an ordination axis representing succession and disturbance. Comparison with another professional survey indicated that different biases might be present at different levels of participation within the scheme. Understanding the strengths and limitations of the NPMS will guide development, increase trust in outputs, and direct efforts for maintaining volunteer interest, as well as providing a set of ideas for other countries to experiment with.https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0215891 |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Oliver L Pescott Kevin J Walker Felicity Harris Hayley New Christine M Cheffings Niki Newton Mark Jitlal John Redhead Simon M Smart David B Roy |
spellingShingle |
Oliver L Pescott Kevin J Walker Felicity Harris Hayley New Christine M Cheffings Niki Newton Mark Jitlal John Redhead Simon M Smart David B Roy The design, launch and assessment of a new volunteer-based plant monitoring scheme for the United Kingdom. PLoS ONE |
author_facet |
Oliver L Pescott Kevin J Walker Felicity Harris Hayley New Christine M Cheffings Niki Newton Mark Jitlal John Redhead Simon M Smart David B Roy |
author_sort |
Oliver L Pescott |
title |
The design, launch and assessment of a new volunteer-based plant monitoring scheme for the United Kingdom. |
title_short |
The design, launch and assessment of a new volunteer-based plant monitoring scheme for the United Kingdom. |
title_full |
The design, launch and assessment of a new volunteer-based plant monitoring scheme for the United Kingdom. |
title_fullStr |
The design, launch and assessment of a new volunteer-based plant monitoring scheme for the United Kingdom. |
title_full_unstemmed |
The design, launch and assessment of a new volunteer-based plant monitoring scheme for the United Kingdom. |
title_sort |
design, launch and assessment of a new volunteer-based plant monitoring scheme for the united kingdom. |
publisher |
Public Library of Science (PLoS) |
series |
PLoS ONE |
issn |
1932-6203 |
publishDate |
2019-01-01 |
description |
Volunteer-based plant monitoring in the UK has focused mainly on distribution mapping; there has been less emphasis on the collection of data on plant communities and habitats. Abundance data provide different insights into ecological pattern and allow for more powerful inference when considering environmental change. Abundance monitoring for other groups of organisms is well-established in the UK, e.g. for birds and butterflies, and conservation agencies have long desired comparable schemes for plants. We describe a new citizen science scheme for the UK (the 'National Plant Monitoring Scheme'; NPMS), with the primary aim of monitoring the abundance of plants at small scales. Scheme development emphasised volunteer flexibility through scheme co-creation and feedback, whilst retaining a rigorous approach to design. Sampling frameworks, target habitats and species, field methods and power are all described. We also evaluate several outcomes of the scheme design process, including: (i) landscape-context bias in the first two years of the scheme; (ii) the ability of different sets of indicator species to capture the main ecological gradients of UK vegetation; and, (iii) species richness bias in returns relative to a professional survey. Survey rates have been promising (over 60% of squares released have been surveyed), although upland squares are under-represented. Ecological gradients present in an ordination of an independent, unbiased, national survey were well-represented by NPMS indicator species, although further filtering to an entry-level set of easily identifiable species degraded signal in an ordination axis representing succession and disturbance. Comparison with another professional survey indicated that different biases might be present at different levels of participation within the scheme. Understanding the strengths and limitations of the NPMS will guide development, increase trust in outputs, and direct efforts for maintaining volunteer interest, as well as providing a set of ideas for other countries to experiment with. |
url |
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0215891 |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT oliverlpescott thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT kevinjwalker thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT felicityharris thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT hayleynew thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT christinemcheffings thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT nikinewton thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT markjitlal thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT johnredhead thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT simonmsmart thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT davidbroy thedesignlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT oliverlpescott designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT kevinjwalker designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT felicityharris designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT hayleynew designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT christinemcheffings designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT nikinewton designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT markjitlal designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT johnredhead designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT simonmsmart designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom AT davidbroy designlaunchandassessmentofanewvolunteerbasedplantmonitoringschemefortheunitedkingdom |
_version_ |
1714821023274106880 |