Coexist WiFi for ZigBee Networks With Fine-Grained Frequency Approach

The widely deployed WiFi APs and ZigBee devices make the coexistence for these two networks more pervasive than ever. Previous solutions focus on the contention resolution in time domain, but would lead to the underutilized frequency resources. However, for frequency domain schemes, to enable effici...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Ping Li, Yubo Yan, Panlong Yang, Xiang-Yang Li, Qiongzheng Lin
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: IEEE 2019-01-01
Series:IEEE Access
Subjects:
Online Access:https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8840838/
id doaj-5be155e519ca4de680f9aa6af09ac333
record_format Article
spelling doaj-5be155e519ca4de680f9aa6af09ac3332021-03-30T00:30:29ZengIEEEIEEE Access2169-35362019-01-01713536313537610.1109/ACCESS.2019.29419638840838Coexist WiFi for ZigBee Networks With Fine-Grained Frequency ApproachPing Li0https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1343-8768Yubo Yan1Panlong Yang2Xiang-Yang Li3Qiongzheng Lin4University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, ChinaUniversity of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, ChinaUniversity of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, ChinaUniversity of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, ChinaUniversity of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, ChinaThe widely deployed WiFi APs and ZigBee devices make the coexistence for these two networks more pervasive than ever. Previous solutions focus on the contention resolution in time domain, but would lead to the underutilized frequency resources. However, for frequency domain schemes, to enable efficient coexistence for WiFi and ZigBee networks, the WiFi nodes or ZigBee nodes have to select the appropriate channel for transmission. Such scheme will need strict cooperations among these two independent systems, and could not work with the conventional legacy systems seamlessly. In this paper, we propose a frequency overlay approach named COFFEE (COexist wiFi For zigbEE networks), where subcarriers interfering with ZigBee transmissions are nullified by WiFi. According to our basic evaluations, due to the relatively robust feature in WiFi/OFDM design, nullifying small portion of subcarriers would affect the WiFi performance slightly, but could improve the capability for coexistence significantly. Thus by using COFFEE, WiFi and ZigBee nodes can transmit their packets concurrently without any coordination. Also, COFFEE and conventional legacy WiFi systems could work together seamlessly. Furthermore, we implement COFFEE with USRP software radio platform and evaluate the performance under real wireless network scenarios. The extensive evaluations show that compared to the coexistence schemes in time domain, COFFEE is able to increase the network throughput by more than 300%. Even when the ZigBee node never knows the transmission time of WiFi packet, it still can provide concurrent lossless transmission by using COFFEE with only 10% to 15% WiFi throughput reduction.https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8840838/CoexistenceWiFiZigBeeOFDM
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Ping Li
Yubo Yan
Panlong Yang
Xiang-Yang Li
Qiongzheng Lin
spellingShingle Ping Li
Yubo Yan
Panlong Yang
Xiang-Yang Li
Qiongzheng Lin
Coexist WiFi for ZigBee Networks With Fine-Grained Frequency Approach
IEEE Access
Coexistence
WiFi
ZigBee
OFDM
author_facet Ping Li
Yubo Yan
Panlong Yang
Xiang-Yang Li
Qiongzheng Lin
author_sort Ping Li
title Coexist WiFi for ZigBee Networks With Fine-Grained Frequency Approach
title_short Coexist WiFi for ZigBee Networks With Fine-Grained Frequency Approach
title_full Coexist WiFi for ZigBee Networks With Fine-Grained Frequency Approach
title_fullStr Coexist WiFi for ZigBee Networks With Fine-Grained Frequency Approach
title_full_unstemmed Coexist WiFi for ZigBee Networks With Fine-Grained Frequency Approach
title_sort coexist wifi for zigbee networks with fine-grained frequency approach
publisher IEEE
series IEEE Access
issn 2169-3536
publishDate 2019-01-01
description The widely deployed WiFi APs and ZigBee devices make the coexistence for these two networks more pervasive than ever. Previous solutions focus on the contention resolution in time domain, but would lead to the underutilized frequency resources. However, for frequency domain schemes, to enable efficient coexistence for WiFi and ZigBee networks, the WiFi nodes or ZigBee nodes have to select the appropriate channel for transmission. Such scheme will need strict cooperations among these two independent systems, and could not work with the conventional legacy systems seamlessly. In this paper, we propose a frequency overlay approach named COFFEE (COexist wiFi For zigbEE networks), where subcarriers interfering with ZigBee transmissions are nullified by WiFi. According to our basic evaluations, due to the relatively robust feature in WiFi/OFDM design, nullifying small portion of subcarriers would affect the WiFi performance slightly, but could improve the capability for coexistence significantly. Thus by using COFFEE, WiFi and ZigBee nodes can transmit their packets concurrently without any coordination. Also, COFFEE and conventional legacy WiFi systems could work together seamlessly. Furthermore, we implement COFFEE with USRP software radio platform and evaluate the performance under real wireless network scenarios. The extensive evaluations show that compared to the coexistence schemes in time domain, COFFEE is able to increase the network throughput by more than 300%. Even when the ZigBee node never knows the transmission time of WiFi packet, it still can provide concurrent lossless transmission by using COFFEE with only 10% to 15% WiFi throughput reduction.
topic Coexistence
WiFi
ZigBee
OFDM
url https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8840838/
work_keys_str_mv AT pingli coexistwififorzigbeenetworkswithfinegrainedfrequencyapproach
AT yuboyan coexistwififorzigbeenetworkswithfinegrainedfrequencyapproach
AT panlongyang coexistwififorzigbeenetworkswithfinegrainedfrequencyapproach
AT xiangyangli coexistwififorzigbeenetworkswithfinegrainedfrequencyapproach
AT qiongzhenglin coexistwififorzigbeenetworkswithfinegrainedfrequencyapproach
_version_ 1724188215856857088