Using Co-authorship Networks to Map and Analyse Global Neglected Tropical Disease Research with an Affiliation to Germany.

BACKGROUND:Research on Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTDs) has increased in recent decades, and significant need-gaps in diagnostic and treatment tools remain. Analysing bibliometric data from published research is a powerful method for revealing research efforts, partnerships and expertise. We aim t...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Max Ernst Bender, Suzanne Edwards, Peter von Philipsborn, Fridolin Steinbeis, Thomas Keil, Peter Tinnemann
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2015-12-01
Series:PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases
Online Access:http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4703140?pdf=render
id doaj-5c8709b0e1854779aeb1043950946f30
record_format Article
spelling doaj-5c8709b0e1854779aeb1043950946f302020-11-25T01:46:38ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases1935-27271935-27352015-12-01912e000418210.1371/journal.pntd.0004182Using Co-authorship Networks to Map and Analyse Global Neglected Tropical Disease Research with an Affiliation to Germany.Max Ernst BenderSuzanne EdwardsPeter von PhilipsbornFridolin SteinbeisThomas KeilPeter TinnemannBACKGROUND:Research on Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTDs) has increased in recent decades, and significant need-gaps in diagnostic and treatment tools remain. Analysing bibliometric data from published research is a powerful method for revealing research efforts, partnerships and expertise. We aim to identify and map NTD research networks in Germany and their partners abroad to enable an informed and transparent evaluation of German contributions to NTD research. METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS:A SCOPUS database search for articles with German author affiliations that were published between 2002 and 2012 was conducted for kinetoplastid and helminth diseases. Open-access tools were used for data cleaning and scientometrics (OpenRefine), geocoding (OpenStreetMaps) and to create (Table2Net), visualise and analyse co-authorship networks (Gephi). From 26,833 publications from around the world that addressed 11 diseases, we identified 1,187 (4.4%) with at least one German author affiliation, and we processed 972 publications for the five most published-about diseases. Of those, we extracted 4,007 individual authors and 863 research institutions to construct co-author networks. The majority of co-authors outside Germany were from high-income countries and Brazil. Collaborations with partners on the African continent remain scattered. NTD research within Germany was distributed among 220 research institutions. We identified strong performers on an individual level by using classic parameters (number of publications, h-index) and social network analysis parameters (betweenness centrality). The research network characteristics varied strongly between diseases. CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE:The share of NTD publications with German affiliations is approximately half of its share in other fields of medical research. This finding underlines the need to identify barriers and expand Germany's otherwise strong research activities towards NTDs. A geospatial analysis of research collaborations with partners abroad can support decisions to strengthen research capacity, particularly in low- and middle-income countries, which were less involved in collaborations than high-income countries. Identifying knowledge hubs within individual researcher networks complements traditional scientometric indicators that are used to identify opportunities for collaboration. Using free tools to analyse research processes and output could facilitate data-driven health policies. Our findings contribute to the prioritisation of efforts in German NTD research at a time of impending local and global policy decisions.http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4703140?pdf=render
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Max Ernst Bender
Suzanne Edwards
Peter von Philipsborn
Fridolin Steinbeis
Thomas Keil
Peter Tinnemann
spellingShingle Max Ernst Bender
Suzanne Edwards
Peter von Philipsborn
Fridolin Steinbeis
Thomas Keil
Peter Tinnemann
Using Co-authorship Networks to Map and Analyse Global Neglected Tropical Disease Research with an Affiliation to Germany.
PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases
author_facet Max Ernst Bender
Suzanne Edwards
Peter von Philipsborn
Fridolin Steinbeis
Thomas Keil
Peter Tinnemann
author_sort Max Ernst Bender
title Using Co-authorship Networks to Map and Analyse Global Neglected Tropical Disease Research with an Affiliation to Germany.
title_short Using Co-authorship Networks to Map and Analyse Global Neglected Tropical Disease Research with an Affiliation to Germany.
title_full Using Co-authorship Networks to Map and Analyse Global Neglected Tropical Disease Research with an Affiliation to Germany.
title_fullStr Using Co-authorship Networks to Map and Analyse Global Neglected Tropical Disease Research with an Affiliation to Germany.
title_full_unstemmed Using Co-authorship Networks to Map and Analyse Global Neglected Tropical Disease Research with an Affiliation to Germany.
title_sort using co-authorship networks to map and analyse global neglected tropical disease research with an affiliation to germany.
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
series PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases
issn 1935-2727
1935-2735
publishDate 2015-12-01
description BACKGROUND:Research on Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTDs) has increased in recent decades, and significant need-gaps in diagnostic and treatment tools remain. Analysing bibliometric data from published research is a powerful method for revealing research efforts, partnerships and expertise. We aim to identify and map NTD research networks in Germany and their partners abroad to enable an informed and transparent evaluation of German contributions to NTD research. METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS:A SCOPUS database search for articles with German author affiliations that were published between 2002 and 2012 was conducted for kinetoplastid and helminth diseases. Open-access tools were used for data cleaning and scientometrics (OpenRefine), geocoding (OpenStreetMaps) and to create (Table2Net), visualise and analyse co-authorship networks (Gephi). From 26,833 publications from around the world that addressed 11 diseases, we identified 1,187 (4.4%) with at least one German author affiliation, and we processed 972 publications for the five most published-about diseases. Of those, we extracted 4,007 individual authors and 863 research institutions to construct co-author networks. The majority of co-authors outside Germany were from high-income countries and Brazil. Collaborations with partners on the African continent remain scattered. NTD research within Germany was distributed among 220 research institutions. We identified strong performers on an individual level by using classic parameters (number of publications, h-index) and social network analysis parameters (betweenness centrality). The research network characteristics varied strongly between diseases. CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE:The share of NTD publications with German affiliations is approximately half of its share in other fields of medical research. This finding underlines the need to identify barriers and expand Germany's otherwise strong research activities towards NTDs. A geospatial analysis of research collaborations with partners abroad can support decisions to strengthen research capacity, particularly in low- and middle-income countries, which were less involved in collaborations than high-income countries. Identifying knowledge hubs within individual researcher networks complements traditional scientometric indicators that are used to identify opportunities for collaboration. Using free tools to analyse research processes and output could facilitate data-driven health policies. Our findings contribute to the prioritisation of efforts in German NTD research at a time of impending local and global policy decisions.
url http://europepmc.org/articles/PMC4703140?pdf=render
work_keys_str_mv AT maxernstbender usingcoauthorshipnetworkstomapandanalyseglobalneglectedtropicaldiseaseresearchwithanaffiliationtogermany
AT suzanneedwards usingcoauthorshipnetworkstomapandanalyseglobalneglectedtropicaldiseaseresearchwithanaffiliationtogermany
AT petervonphilipsborn usingcoauthorshipnetworkstomapandanalyseglobalneglectedtropicaldiseaseresearchwithanaffiliationtogermany
AT fridolinsteinbeis usingcoauthorshipnetworkstomapandanalyseglobalneglectedtropicaldiseaseresearchwithanaffiliationtogermany
AT thomaskeil usingcoauthorshipnetworkstomapandanalyseglobalneglectedtropicaldiseaseresearchwithanaffiliationtogermany
AT petertinnemann usingcoauthorshipnetworkstomapandanalyseglobalneglectedtropicaldiseaseresearchwithanaffiliationtogermany
_version_ 1725018197698019328