Disinfection Treatments of Disposable Respirators Influencing the Bactericidal/Bacteria Removal Efficiency, Filtration Performance, and Structural Integrity

In the outbreak of COVID-19, the extended wear of single-use, disposable respirators was inevitable due to limited supplies. As a respirator is front-line protection against particulate matter, including bioaerosol and droplets, a comprehensive understanding for the reuse strategy is needed. In this...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Seojin Jung, Tahmineh Hemmatian, Eugene Song, Kyeongeun Lee, Dongwan Seo, Jehyung Yi, Jooyoun Kim
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2021-12-01
Series:Polymers
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4360/13/1/45
id doaj-5d9ad73a925b4a0bb423c719372d62dd
record_format Article
spelling doaj-5d9ad73a925b4a0bb423c719372d62dd2020-12-25T00:04:58ZengMDPI AGPolymers2073-43602021-12-0113454510.3390/polym13010045Disinfection Treatments of Disposable Respirators Influencing the Bactericidal/Bacteria Removal Efficiency, Filtration Performance, and Structural IntegritySeojin Jung0Tahmineh Hemmatian1Eugene Song2Kyeongeun Lee3Dongwan Seo4Jehyung Yi5Jooyoun Kim6Department of Textiles, Merchandising and Fashion Design, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, KoreaDepartment of Textiles, Merchandising and Fashion Design, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, KoreaDepartment of Textiles, Merchandising and Fashion Design, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, KoreaDepartment of Textiles, Merchandising and Fashion Design, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, KoreaReliability Assessment Center, FITI Testing & Research Institute, Seoul 07791, KoreaDepartment of Textiles, Merchandising and Fashion Design, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, KoreaDepartment of Textiles, Merchandising and Fashion Design, Seoul National University, Seoul 08826, KoreaIn the outbreak of COVID-19, the extended wear of single-use, disposable respirators was inevitable due to limited supplies. As a respirator is front-line protection against particulate matter, including bioaerosol and droplets, a comprehensive understanding for the reuse strategy is needed. In this study, eight different disinfection methods commonly applied for the reuse of respirators were compared for their influence on the filtration and bactericidal/bacteria removal performance, with in-depth discussion on the cause of effects. Treatments including oven-dry, ultraviolet irradiation (UV), microwaving, laundering with and without detergent, and immersion in hypochlorite, isopropanol, and ethanol were performed to respirators. Immersion in ethanol or isopropanol was effective for inactivation and removal of bacteria, yet such a treatment significantly deteriorated the filtration efficiency in about 20–28%, dissipating the surface charges. Laundering, while effective in removing the attached bacteria, triggered physical damage, leading to a possible reduction of filtration performance. A short-term oven-dry, UV irradiation, and microwaving mostly preserved the filtration performance, yet the drawback lied in the incomplete bactericidal efficiency. This study would contribute to the public health and safety by providing scientific background on the effect of disinfection treatment methods for respirators.https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4360/13/1/45respiratorreusepublic healthfiltrationelectrostaticmechanical
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Seojin Jung
Tahmineh Hemmatian
Eugene Song
Kyeongeun Lee
Dongwan Seo
Jehyung Yi
Jooyoun Kim
spellingShingle Seojin Jung
Tahmineh Hemmatian
Eugene Song
Kyeongeun Lee
Dongwan Seo
Jehyung Yi
Jooyoun Kim
Disinfection Treatments of Disposable Respirators Influencing the Bactericidal/Bacteria Removal Efficiency, Filtration Performance, and Structural Integrity
Polymers
respirator
reuse
public health
filtration
electrostatic
mechanical
author_facet Seojin Jung
Tahmineh Hemmatian
Eugene Song
Kyeongeun Lee
Dongwan Seo
Jehyung Yi
Jooyoun Kim
author_sort Seojin Jung
title Disinfection Treatments of Disposable Respirators Influencing the Bactericidal/Bacteria Removal Efficiency, Filtration Performance, and Structural Integrity
title_short Disinfection Treatments of Disposable Respirators Influencing the Bactericidal/Bacteria Removal Efficiency, Filtration Performance, and Structural Integrity
title_full Disinfection Treatments of Disposable Respirators Influencing the Bactericidal/Bacteria Removal Efficiency, Filtration Performance, and Structural Integrity
title_fullStr Disinfection Treatments of Disposable Respirators Influencing the Bactericidal/Bacteria Removal Efficiency, Filtration Performance, and Structural Integrity
title_full_unstemmed Disinfection Treatments of Disposable Respirators Influencing the Bactericidal/Bacteria Removal Efficiency, Filtration Performance, and Structural Integrity
title_sort disinfection treatments of disposable respirators influencing the bactericidal/bacteria removal efficiency, filtration performance, and structural integrity
publisher MDPI AG
series Polymers
issn 2073-4360
publishDate 2021-12-01
description In the outbreak of COVID-19, the extended wear of single-use, disposable respirators was inevitable due to limited supplies. As a respirator is front-line protection against particulate matter, including bioaerosol and droplets, a comprehensive understanding for the reuse strategy is needed. In this study, eight different disinfection methods commonly applied for the reuse of respirators were compared for their influence on the filtration and bactericidal/bacteria removal performance, with in-depth discussion on the cause of effects. Treatments including oven-dry, ultraviolet irradiation (UV), microwaving, laundering with and without detergent, and immersion in hypochlorite, isopropanol, and ethanol were performed to respirators. Immersion in ethanol or isopropanol was effective for inactivation and removal of bacteria, yet such a treatment significantly deteriorated the filtration efficiency in about 20–28%, dissipating the surface charges. Laundering, while effective in removing the attached bacteria, triggered physical damage, leading to a possible reduction of filtration performance. A short-term oven-dry, UV irradiation, and microwaving mostly preserved the filtration performance, yet the drawback lied in the incomplete bactericidal efficiency. This study would contribute to the public health and safety by providing scientific background on the effect of disinfection treatment methods for respirators.
topic respirator
reuse
public health
filtration
electrostatic
mechanical
url https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4360/13/1/45
work_keys_str_mv AT seojinjung disinfectiontreatmentsofdisposablerespiratorsinfluencingthebactericidalbacteriaremovalefficiencyfiltrationperformanceandstructuralintegrity
AT tahminehhemmatian disinfectiontreatmentsofdisposablerespiratorsinfluencingthebactericidalbacteriaremovalefficiencyfiltrationperformanceandstructuralintegrity
AT eugenesong disinfectiontreatmentsofdisposablerespiratorsinfluencingthebactericidalbacteriaremovalefficiencyfiltrationperformanceandstructuralintegrity
AT kyeongeunlee disinfectiontreatmentsofdisposablerespiratorsinfluencingthebactericidalbacteriaremovalefficiencyfiltrationperformanceandstructuralintegrity
AT dongwanseo disinfectiontreatmentsofdisposablerespiratorsinfluencingthebactericidalbacteriaremovalefficiencyfiltrationperformanceandstructuralintegrity
AT jehyungyi disinfectiontreatmentsofdisposablerespiratorsinfluencingthebactericidalbacteriaremovalefficiencyfiltrationperformanceandstructuralintegrity
AT jooyounkim disinfectiontreatmentsofdisposablerespiratorsinfluencingthebactericidalbacteriaremovalefficiencyfiltrationperformanceandstructuralintegrity
_version_ 1724371443464011776