Optimal Temporal Resolution of Rainfall for Urban Applications and Uncertainty Propagation

The optimal temporal resolution for rainfall applications in urban hydrological models depends on different factors. Accumulations are often used to reduce uncertainty, while a sufficiently fine resolution is needed to capture the variability of the urban hydrological processes. Merging radar and ra...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Francesca Cecinati, Arie C. de Niet, Kasia Sawicka, Miguel A. Rico-Ramirez
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2017-10-01
Series:Water
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/9/10/762
id doaj-665c5aaeebce4994bf8bed7dd0aa128f
record_format Article
spelling doaj-665c5aaeebce4994bf8bed7dd0aa128f2020-11-24T20:42:45ZengMDPI AGWater2073-44412017-10-0191076210.3390/w9100762w9100762Optimal Temporal Resolution of Rainfall for Urban Applications and Uncertainty PropagationFrancesca Cecinati0Arie C. de Niet1Kasia Sawicka2Miguel A. Rico-Ramirez3Department of Civil Engineering, University of Bristol, Bristol BS8 1US, UKCoasts, Rivers and Land Reclamation PMC, Witteveen + Bos, 7400 AE Deventer, The NetherlandsSchool of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh, King's Buildings, EH9 3JN Edinburgh, UKDepartment of Civil Engineering, University of Bristol, Bristol BS8 1US, UKThe optimal temporal resolution for rainfall applications in urban hydrological models depends on different factors. Accumulations are often used to reduce uncertainty, while a sufficiently fine resolution is needed to capture the variability of the urban hydrological processes. Merging radar and rain gauge rainfall is recognized to improve the estimation accuracy. This work explores the possibility to merge radar and rain gauge rainfall at coarser temporal resolutions to reduce uncertainty, and to downscale the results. A case study in the UK is used to cross-validate the methodology. Rainfall estimates merged and downscaled at different resolutions are compared. As expected, coarser resolutions tend to reduce uncertainty in terms of rainfall estimation. Additionally, an example of urban application in Twenterand, the Netherlands, is presented. The rainfall data from four rain gauge networks are merged with radar composites and used in an InfoWorks model reproducing the urban drainage system of Vroomshoop, a village in Twenterand. Fourteen combinations of accumulation and downscaling resolutions are tested in the InfoWorks model and the optimal is selected comparing the results to water level observations. The uncertainty is propagated in the InfoWorks model with ensembles. The results show that the uncertainty estimated by the ensemble spread is proportional to the rainfall intensity and dependent on the relative position between rainfall cells and measurement points.https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/9/10/762Kriging with External Driftradar-rain gauge mergingrain gauge random error modelrainfall temporal downscalinguncertainty propagationrainfall ensembles
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Francesca Cecinati
Arie C. de Niet
Kasia Sawicka
Miguel A. Rico-Ramirez
spellingShingle Francesca Cecinati
Arie C. de Niet
Kasia Sawicka
Miguel A. Rico-Ramirez
Optimal Temporal Resolution of Rainfall for Urban Applications and Uncertainty Propagation
Water
Kriging with External Drift
radar-rain gauge merging
rain gauge random error model
rainfall temporal downscaling
uncertainty propagation
rainfall ensembles
author_facet Francesca Cecinati
Arie C. de Niet
Kasia Sawicka
Miguel A. Rico-Ramirez
author_sort Francesca Cecinati
title Optimal Temporal Resolution of Rainfall for Urban Applications and Uncertainty Propagation
title_short Optimal Temporal Resolution of Rainfall for Urban Applications and Uncertainty Propagation
title_full Optimal Temporal Resolution of Rainfall for Urban Applications and Uncertainty Propagation
title_fullStr Optimal Temporal Resolution of Rainfall for Urban Applications and Uncertainty Propagation
title_full_unstemmed Optimal Temporal Resolution of Rainfall for Urban Applications and Uncertainty Propagation
title_sort optimal temporal resolution of rainfall for urban applications and uncertainty propagation
publisher MDPI AG
series Water
issn 2073-4441
publishDate 2017-10-01
description The optimal temporal resolution for rainfall applications in urban hydrological models depends on different factors. Accumulations are often used to reduce uncertainty, while a sufficiently fine resolution is needed to capture the variability of the urban hydrological processes. Merging radar and rain gauge rainfall is recognized to improve the estimation accuracy. This work explores the possibility to merge radar and rain gauge rainfall at coarser temporal resolutions to reduce uncertainty, and to downscale the results. A case study in the UK is used to cross-validate the methodology. Rainfall estimates merged and downscaled at different resolutions are compared. As expected, coarser resolutions tend to reduce uncertainty in terms of rainfall estimation. Additionally, an example of urban application in Twenterand, the Netherlands, is presented. The rainfall data from four rain gauge networks are merged with radar composites and used in an InfoWorks model reproducing the urban drainage system of Vroomshoop, a village in Twenterand. Fourteen combinations of accumulation and downscaling resolutions are tested in the InfoWorks model and the optimal is selected comparing the results to water level observations. The uncertainty is propagated in the InfoWorks model with ensembles. The results show that the uncertainty estimated by the ensemble spread is proportional to the rainfall intensity and dependent on the relative position between rainfall cells and measurement points.
topic Kriging with External Drift
radar-rain gauge merging
rain gauge random error model
rainfall temporal downscaling
uncertainty propagation
rainfall ensembles
url https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/9/10/762
work_keys_str_mv AT francescacecinati optimaltemporalresolutionofrainfallforurbanapplicationsanduncertaintypropagation
AT ariecdeniet optimaltemporalresolutionofrainfallforurbanapplicationsanduncertaintypropagation
AT kasiasawicka optimaltemporalresolutionofrainfallforurbanapplicationsanduncertaintypropagation
AT miguelaricoramirez optimaltemporalresolutionofrainfallforurbanapplicationsanduncertaintypropagation
_version_ 1716821877410758656