Cornea verticillata and acroparesthesia efficiently discriminate clusters of severity in Fabry disease.

BACKGROUD:Fabry disease (OMIM #301 500), the most prevalent lysosomal storage disease, is caused by enzymatic defects in alpha-galactosidase A (GLA gene; Xq22.1). Fabry disease has historically been characterized by progressive renal failure, early stroke and hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, with a dimi...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Wladimir Mauhin, Olivier Benveniste, Damien Amelin, Clémence Montagner, Foudil Lamari, Catherine Caillaud, Claire Douillard, Bertrand Dussol, Vanessa Leguy-Seguin, Pauline D'Halluin, Esther Noel, Thierry Zenone, Marie Matignon, François Maillot, Kim-Heang Ly, Gérard Besson, Marjolaine Willems, Fabien Labombarda, Agathe Masseau, Christian Lavigne, Didier Lacombe, Hélène Maillard, Olivier Lidove
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Public Library of Science (PLoS) 2020-01-01
Series:PLoS ONE
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0233460
id doaj-689a2edfa43d4ed89aefddaf3cda906d
record_format Article
spelling doaj-689a2edfa43d4ed89aefddaf3cda906d2021-03-03T21:51:19ZengPublic Library of Science (PLoS)PLoS ONE1932-62032020-01-01155e023346010.1371/journal.pone.0233460Cornea verticillata and acroparesthesia efficiently discriminate clusters of severity in Fabry disease.Wladimir MauhinOlivier BenvenisteDamien AmelinClémence MontagnerFoudil LamariCatherine CaillaudClaire DouillardBertrand DussolVanessa Leguy-SeguinPauline D'HalluinEsther NoelThierry ZenoneMarie MatignonFrançois MaillotKim-Heang LyGérard BessonMarjolaine WillemsFabien LabombardaAgathe MasseauChristian LavigneDidier LacombeHélène MaillardOlivier LidoveBACKGROUD:Fabry disease (OMIM #301 500), the most prevalent lysosomal storage disease, is caused by enzymatic defects in alpha-galactosidase A (GLA gene; Xq22.1). Fabry disease has historically been characterized by progressive renal failure, early stroke and hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, with a diminished life expectancy. A nonclassical phenotype has been described with an almost exclusive cardiac involvement. Specific therapies with enzyme substitution or chaperone molecules are now available depending on the mutation carried. Numerous clinical and fundamental studies have been conducted without stratifying patients by phenotype or severity, despite different prognoses and possible different pathophysiologies. We aimed to identify a simple and clinically relevant way to classify and stratify patients according to their disease severity. METHODS:Based on data from the French Fabry Biobank and Registry (FFABRY; n = 104; 54 males), we applied unsupervised multivariate statistics to determine clusters of patients and identify clinical criteria that would allow an effective classification of adult patients. Thanks to these criteria and empirical clinical considerations we secondly elaborate a new score that allow the severity stratification of patients. RESULTS:We observed that the absence of acroparesthesia or cornea verticillata is sufficient to classify males as having the nonclassical phenotype. We did not identify criteria that significantly cluster female patients. The classical phenotype was associated with a higher risk of severe renal (HR = 35.1; p <10-3) and cardiac events (HR = 4.8; p = 0.008) and a trend toward a higher risk of severe neurological events (HR = 7.7; p = 0.08) compared to nonclassical males. Our simple, rapid and clinically-relevant FFABRY score gave concordant results with the validated MSSI. CONCLUSION:Acroparesthesia and cornea verticillata are simple clinical criteria that efficiently stratify Fabry patients, defining 3 different groups: females and males with nonclassical and classical phenotypes of significantly different severity. The FFABRY score allows severity stratification of Fabry patients.https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0233460
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Wladimir Mauhin
Olivier Benveniste
Damien Amelin
Clémence Montagner
Foudil Lamari
Catherine Caillaud
Claire Douillard
Bertrand Dussol
Vanessa Leguy-Seguin
Pauline D'Halluin
Esther Noel
Thierry Zenone
Marie Matignon
François Maillot
Kim-Heang Ly
Gérard Besson
Marjolaine Willems
Fabien Labombarda
Agathe Masseau
Christian Lavigne
Didier Lacombe
Hélène Maillard
Olivier Lidove
spellingShingle Wladimir Mauhin
Olivier Benveniste
Damien Amelin
Clémence Montagner
Foudil Lamari
Catherine Caillaud
Claire Douillard
Bertrand Dussol
Vanessa Leguy-Seguin
Pauline D'Halluin
Esther Noel
Thierry Zenone
Marie Matignon
François Maillot
Kim-Heang Ly
Gérard Besson
Marjolaine Willems
Fabien Labombarda
Agathe Masseau
Christian Lavigne
Didier Lacombe
Hélène Maillard
Olivier Lidove
Cornea verticillata and acroparesthesia efficiently discriminate clusters of severity in Fabry disease.
PLoS ONE
author_facet Wladimir Mauhin
Olivier Benveniste
Damien Amelin
Clémence Montagner
Foudil Lamari
Catherine Caillaud
Claire Douillard
Bertrand Dussol
Vanessa Leguy-Seguin
Pauline D'Halluin
Esther Noel
Thierry Zenone
Marie Matignon
François Maillot
Kim-Heang Ly
Gérard Besson
Marjolaine Willems
Fabien Labombarda
Agathe Masseau
Christian Lavigne
Didier Lacombe
Hélène Maillard
Olivier Lidove
author_sort Wladimir Mauhin
title Cornea verticillata and acroparesthesia efficiently discriminate clusters of severity in Fabry disease.
title_short Cornea verticillata and acroparesthesia efficiently discriminate clusters of severity in Fabry disease.
title_full Cornea verticillata and acroparesthesia efficiently discriminate clusters of severity in Fabry disease.
title_fullStr Cornea verticillata and acroparesthesia efficiently discriminate clusters of severity in Fabry disease.
title_full_unstemmed Cornea verticillata and acroparesthesia efficiently discriminate clusters of severity in Fabry disease.
title_sort cornea verticillata and acroparesthesia efficiently discriminate clusters of severity in fabry disease.
publisher Public Library of Science (PLoS)
series PLoS ONE
issn 1932-6203
publishDate 2020-01-01
description BACKGROUD:Fabry disease (OMIM #301 500), the most prevalent lysosomal storage disease, is caused by enzymatic defects in alpha-galactosidase A (GLA gene; Xq22.1). Fabry disease has historically been characterized by progressive renal failure, early stroke and hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, with a diminished life expectancy. A nonclassical phenotype has been described with an almost exclusive cardiac involvement. Specific therapies with enzyme substitution or chaperone molecules are now available depending on the mutation carried. Numerous clinical and fundamental studies have been conducted without stratifying patients by phenotype or severity, despite different prognoses and possible different pathophysiologies. We aimed to identify a simple and clinically relevant way to classify and stratify patients according to their disease severity. METHODS:Based on data from the French Fabry Biobank and Registry (FFABRY; n = 104; 54 males), we applied unsupervised multivariate statistics to determine clusters of patients and identify clinical criteria that would allow an effective classification of adult patients. Thanks to these criteria and empirical clinical considerations we secondly elaborate a new score that allow the severity stratification of patients. RESULTS:We observed that the absence of acroparesthesia or cornea verticillata is sufficient to classify males as having the nonclassical phenotype. We did not identify criteria that significantly cluster female patients. The classical phenotype was associated with a higher risk of severe renal (HR = 35.1; p <10-3) and cardiac events (HR = 4.8; p = 0.008) and a trend toward a higher risk of severe neurological events (HR = 7.7; p = 0.08) compared to nonclassical males. Our simple, rapid and clinically-relevant FFABRY score gave concordant results with the validated MSSI. CONCLUSION:Acroparesthesia and cornea verticillata are simple clinical criteria that efficiently stratify Fabry patients, defining 3 different groups: females and males with nonclassical and classical phenotypes of significantly different severity. The FFABRY score allows severity stratification of Fabry patients.
url https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0233460
work_keys_str_mv AT wladimirmauhin corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT olivierbenveniste corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT damienamelin corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT clemencemontagner corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT foudillamari corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT catherinecaillaud corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT clairedouillard corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT bertranddussol corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT vanessaleguyseguin corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT paulinedhalluin corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT esthernoel corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT thierryzenone corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT mariematignon corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT francoismaillot corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT kimheangly corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT gerardbesson corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT marjolainewillems corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT fabienlabombarda corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT agathemasseau corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT christianlavigne corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT didierlacombe corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT helenemaillard corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
AT olivierlidove corneaverticillataandacroparesthesiaefficientlydiscriminateclustersofseverityinfabrydisease
_version_ 1714814670464876544