ANALYSIS OF UNCERTAINTY QUANTIFICATION METHOD BY COMPARING MONTE-CARLO METHOD AND WILKS’ FORMULA

• Main Authors: SEUNG WOOK LEE, BUB DONG CHUNG, YOUNG-SEOK BANG, SUNG WON BAE
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Published: Elsevier 2014-08-01
• Series: Nuclear Engineering and Technology
• Subjects: Uncertainty Quantification; Wilks’ Formula; Monte-Carlo Method; MARS-KS
• Online Access: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1738573315301169

An analysis of the uncertainty quantification related to LBLOCA using the Monte-Carlo calculation has been performed and compared with the tolerance level determined by the Wilks’ formula. The uncertainty range and distribution of each input parameter associated with the LOCA phenomena were determined based on previous PIRT results and documentation during the BEMUSE project. Calulations were conducted on 3,500 cases within a 2-week CPU time on a 14-PC cluster system. The Monte-Carlo exercise shows that the 95% upper limit PCT value can be obtained well, with a 95% confidence level using the Wilks’ formula, although we have to endure a 5% risk of PCT under-prediction. The results also show that the statistical fluctuation of the limit value using Wilks’ first-order is as large as the uncertainty value itself. It is therefore desirable to increase the order of the Wilks’ formula to be higher than the second-order to estimate the reliable safety margin of the design features. It is also shown that, with its ever increasing computational capability, the Monte-Carlo method is accessible for a nuclear power plant safety analysis within a realistic time frame.