Effects of Challenging Weather and Illumination on Learning-Based License Plate Detection in Noncontrolled Environments

License Plate Detection (LPD) is one of the most important steps of an Automatic License Plate Recognition (ALPR) system because it is the seed of the entire recognition process. In indoor controlled environments, there are many effective methods for detecting license plates. However, outdoors LPD i...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: A. Rio-Alvarez, J. de Andres-Suarez, M. Gonzalez-Rodriguez, D. Fernandez-Lanvin, B. López Pérez
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Hindawi Limited 2019-01-01
Series:Scientific Programming
Online Access:http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2019/6897345
id doaj-6f303adc1e92475993765c8cc65bfe5e
record_format Article
spelling doaj-6f303adc1e92475993765c8cc65bfe5e2021-07-02T03:31:12ZengHindawi LimitedScientific Programming1058-92441875-919X2019-01-01201910.1155/2019/68973456897345Effects of Challenging Weather and Illumination on Learning-Based License Plate Detection in Noncontrolled EnvironmentsA. Rio-Alvarez0J. de Andres-Suarez1M. Gonzalez-Rodriguez2D. Fernandez-Lanvin3B. López Pérez4Faculty of Computer Science, University of Oviedo, Oviedo, SpainFaculty of Computer Science, University of Oviedo, Oviedo, SpainFaculty of Computer Science, University of Oviedo, Oviedo, SpainFaculty of Computer Science, University of Oviedo, Oviedo, SpainFaculty of Computer Science, University of Oviedo, Oviedo, SpainLicense Plate Detection (LPD) is one of the most important steps of an Automatic License Plate Recognition (ALPR) system because it is the seed of the entire recognition process. In indoor controlled environments, there are many effective methods for detecting license plates. However, outdoors LPD is still a challenge due to the large number of factors that may affect the process and the results obtained. It is an evidence that a complete training set of images including as many as possible license plates angles and sizes improves the performance of every classifier. On this line of work, numerous training sets contain images taken under different weather conditions. However, no studies tested the differences in the effectiveness of different descriptors for these different conditions. In this paper, various classifiers were trained with features extracted from a set of rainfall images using different kinds of texture-based descriptors. The accuracy of these specific trained classifiers over a test set of rainfall images was compared with the accuracy of the same descriptor-classifier pair trained with features extracted from an ideal conditions images set. In the same way, we repeat the experiment with images affected by challenging illumination. The research concludes, on one hand, that including images affected by rain, snow, or fog in the training sets does not improve the accuracy of the classifier detecting license plates over images affected by these weather conditions. Classifiers trained with ideal conditions images improve the accuracy of license plate detection in images affected by rainfalls up to 19% depending on the kind of extracted features. However, on the other hand, results evidence that including images affected by low illumination regardless of the kind of the selected feature increases the accuracy of the classifier up to 29%.http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2019/6897345
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author A. Rio-Alvarez
J. de Andres-Suarez
M. Gonzalez-Rodriguez
D. Fernandez-Lanvin
B. López Pérez
spellingShingle A. Rio-Alvarez
J. de Andres-Suarez
M. Gonzalez-Rodriguez
D. Fernandez-Lanvin
B. López Pérez
Effects of Challenging Weather and Illumination on Learning-Based License Plate Detection in Noncontrolled Environments
Scientific Programming
author_facet A. Rio-Alvarez
J. de Andres-Suarez
M. Gonzalez-Rodriguez
D. Fernandez-Lanvin
B. López Pérez
author_sort A. Rio-Alvarez
title Effects of Challenging Weather and Illumination on Learning-Based License Plate Detection in Noncontrolled Environments
title_short Effects of Challenging Weather and Illumination on Learning-Based License Plate Detection in Noncontrolled Environments
title_full Effects of Challenging Weather and Illumination on Learning-Based License Plate Detection in Noncontrolled Environments
title_fullStr Effects of Challenging Weather and Illumination on Learning-Based License Plate Detection in Noncontrolled Environments
title_full_unstemmed Effects of Challenging Weather and Illumination on Learning-Based License Plate Detection in Noncontrolled Environments
title_sort effects of challenging weather and illumination on learning-based license plate detection in noncontrolled environments
publisher Hindawi Limited
series Scientific Programming
issn 1058-9244
1875-919X
publishDate 2019-01-01
description License Plate Detection (LPD) is one of the most important steps of an Automatic License Plate Recognition (ALPR) system because it is the seed of the entire recognition process. In indoor controlled environments, there are many effective methods for detecting license plates. However, outdoors LPD is still a challenge due to the large number of factors that may affect the process and the results obtained. It is an evidence that a complete training set of images including as many as possible license plates angles and sizes improves the performance of every classifier. On this line of work, numerous training sets contain images taken under different weather conditions. However, no studies tested the differences in the effectiveness of different descriptors for these different conditions. In this paper, various classifiers were trained with features extracted from a set of rainfall images using different kinds of texture-based descriptors. The accuracy of these specific trained classifiers over a test set of rainfall images was compared with the accuracy of the same descriptor-classifier pair trained with features extracted from an ideal conditions images set. In the same way, we repeat the experiment with images affected by challenging illumination. The research concludes, on one hand, that including images affected by rain, snow, or fog in the training sets does not improve the accuracy of the classifier detecting license plates over images affected by these weather conditions. Classifiers trained with ideal conditions images improve the accuracy of license plate detection in images affected by rainfalls up to 19% depending on the kind of extracted features. However, on the other hand, results evidence that including images affected by low illumination regardless of the kind of the selected feature increases the accuracy of the classifier up to 29%.
url http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2019/6897345
work_keys_str_mv AT arioalvarez effectsofchallengingweatherandilluminationonlearningbasedlicenseplatedetectioninnoncontrolledenvironments
AT jdeandressuarez effectsofchallengingweatherandilluminationonlearningbasedlicenseplatedetectioninnoncontrolledenvironments
AT mgonzalezrodriguez effectsofchallengingweatherandilluminationonlearningbasedlicenseplatedetectioninnoncontrolledenvironments
AT dfernandezlanvin effectsofchallengingweatherandilluminationonlearningbasedlicenseplatedetectioninnoncontrolledenvironments
AT blopezperez effectsofchallengingweatherandilluminationonlearningbasedlicenseplatedetectioninnoncontrolledenvironments
_version_ 1721341496129486848