Detecting travel modes from smartphone-based travel surveys with continuous hidden Markov models

In the last decades, studies on travel mode detection from location data have been increasing exponentially. However, these studies have struggled with three limitations: data collection-, feature selection-, and classification approach–related issues. Thus, we propose a novel framework to collect t...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Guangnian Xiao, Qin Cheng, Chunqin Zhang
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: SAGE Publishing 2019-04-01
Series:International Journal of Distributed Sensor Networks
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1177/1550147719844156
id doaj-830a86b052bb401d8c2e5af936a9e090
record_format Article
spelling doaj-830a86b052bb401d8c2e5af936a9e0902020-11-25T03:43:39ZengSAGE PublishingInternational Journal of Distributed Sensor Networks1550-14772019-04-011510.1177/1550147719844156Detecting travel modes from smartphone-based travel surveys with continuous hidden Markov modelsGuangnian Xiao0Qin Cheng1Chunqin Zhang2School of Economics & Management, Shanghai Maritime University, Shanghai, ChinaSchool of Economics & Management, Shanghai Maritime University, Shanghai, ChinaSchool of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Zhejiang Sci-Tech University, Hangzhou, ChinaIn the last decades, studies on travel mode detection from location data have been increasing exponentially. However, these studies have struggled with three limitations: data collection-, feature selection-, and classification approach–related issues. Thus, we propose a novel framework to collect trajectory data and infer travel modes by making a great deal of effort. First, we conduct a travel survey with smartphones in Shanghai City, China. Furthermore, we use a prompted recall survey with surveyor intervention by telephones. In the survey, the surveyor asks respondents to validate the travel information automatically detected from trajectory data. Second, we use well-known sequential forward selection procedures to select the most reasonable combination of features. This set of features is expected to help achieve high classification accuracy with few features. Third, as a machine learning approach incorporating high resistance to noise in features, a continuous hidden Markov model is used to classify segments in dataset 1 that comprises Global Positioning System data alone. Consequently, 94.37% of segments are flagged correctly for the training dataset, while 93.47% are detected properly for the test dataset by making a comparison between detected travel modes and travel modes validated during the prompted recall survey. A higher accuracy (95.28%) is achieved in the test dataset on dataset 2 that consists of Global Positioning System, accelerometer, Global System for Mobile communication, and Wi-Fi data. The promising results obtained with this method provide a new perspective in understanding travel mode detection and other related issues in Global Positioning System travel surveys, including trip purpose detection.https://doi.org/10.1177/1550147719844156
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Guangnian Xiao
Qin Cheng
Chunqin Zhang
spellingShingle Guangnian Xiao
Qin Cheng
Chunqin Zhang
Detecting travel modes from smartphone-based travel surveys with continuous hidden Markov models
International Journal of Distributed Sensor Networks
author_facet Guangnian Xiao
Qin Cheng
Chunqin Zhang
author_sort Guangnian Xiao
title Detecting travel modes from smartphone-based travel surveys with continuous hidden Markov models
title_short Detecting travel modes from smartphone-based travel surveys with continuous hidden Markov models
title_full Detecting travel modes from smartphone-based travel surveys with continuous hidden Markov models
title_fullStr Detecting travel modes from smartphone-based travel surveys with continuous hidden Markov models
title_full_unstemmed Detecting travel modes from smartphone-based travel surveys with continuous hidden Markov models
title_sort detecting travel modes from smartphone-based travel surveys with continuous hidden markov models
publisher SAGE Publishing
series International Journal of Distributed Sensor Networks
issn 1550-1477
publishDate 2019-04-01
description In the last decades, studies on travel mode detection from location data have been increasing exponentially. However, these studies have struggled with three limitations: data collection-, feature selection-, and classification approach–related issues. Thus, we propose a novel framework to collect trajectory data and infer travel modes by making a great deal of effort. First, we conduct a travel survey with smartphones in Shanghai City, China. Furthermore, we use a prompted recall survey with surveyor intervention by telephones. In the survey, the surveyor asks respondents to validate the travel information automatically detected from trajectory data. Second, we use well-known sequential forward selection procedures to select the most reasonable combination of features. This set of features is expected to help achieve high classification accuracy with few features. Third, as a machine learning approach incorporating high resistance to noise in features, a continuous hidden Markov model is used to classify segments in dataset 1 that comprises Global Positioning System data alone. Consequently, 94.37% of segments are flagged correctly for the training dataset, while 93.47% are detected properly for the test dataset by making a comparison between detected travel modes and travel modes validated during the prompted recall survey. A higher accuracy (95.28%) is achieved in the test dataset on dataset 2 that consists of Global Positioning System, accelerometer, Global System for Mobile communication, and Wi-Fi data. The promising results obtained with this method provide a new perspective in understanding travel mode detection and other related issues in Global Positioning System travel surveys, including trip purpose detection.
url https://doi.org/10.1177/1550147719844156
work_keys_str_mv AT guangnianxiao detectingtravelmodesfromsmartphonebasedtravelsurveyswithcontinuoushiddenmarkovmodels
AT qincheng detectingtravelmodesfromsmartphonebasedtravelsurveyswithcontinuoushiddenmarkovmodels
AT chunqinzhang detectingtravelmodesfromsmartphonebasedtravelsurveyswithcontinuoushiddenmarkovmodels
_version_ 1724518538698293248