Effects of Diagnostic Errors in Pattern Differentiation and Acupuncture Prescription: A Single-Blinded, Interrater Agreement Study
This study compared the interrater agreement for pattern differentiation and acupoints prescription between two groups of human patients simulated with different diagnostic outcomes. Patients were simulated using a dataset about zangfu patterns and separated into groups (n=30 each) according to the...
Main Authors: | , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Hindawi Limited
2015-01-01
|
Series: | Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine |
Online Access: | http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/469675 |
id |
doaj-8c5b55ce4e0d4eefbd42fc1b0d4138c9 |
---|---|
record_format |
Article |
spelling |
doaj-8c5b55ce4e0d4eefbd42fc1b0d4138c92020-11-24T20:57:48ZengHindawi LimitedEvidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine1741-427X1741-42882015-01-01201510.1155/2015/469675469675Effects of Diagnostic Errors in Pattern Differentiation and Acupuncture Prescription: A Single-Blinded, Interrater Agreement StudyIngrid Jardim de Azeredo Souza Oliveira0Arthur de Sá Ferreira1Laboratório de Simulação Computacional e Modelagem em Reabilitação, Programa de Pós-graduação em Ciências da Reabilitação, Centro Universitário Augusto Motta (UNISUAM), 21041-010 Rio de Janeiro, RJ, BrazilLaboratório de Simulação Computacional e Modelagem em Reabilitação, Programa de Pós-graduação em Ciências da Reabilitação, Centro Universitário Augusto Motta (UNISUAM), 21041-010 Rio de Janeiro, RJ, BrazilThis study compared the interrater agreement for pattern differentiation and acupoints prescription between two groups of human patients simulated with different diagnostic outcomes. Patients were simulated using a dataset about zangfu patterns and separated into groups (n=30 each) according to the diagnostic outcome determined by a computational model. A questionnaire with 90 patients was delivered to 6 TCM experts (4-year minimal of clinic experience) who were asked to indicate a single pattern (among 73) and 8 acupoints (among 378). Interrater agreement was higher for pattern differentiation than for acupuncture prescription. Interrater agreement on pattern differentiation was slight for both groups with correct (Light’s κ=0.167, 95% CI = [0.108; 0.254]) and incorrect diagnosis (Light’s κ=0.190, 95% CI = [0.120; 0.286]). Interrater agreement on acupuncture prescription was slight for both groups of correct (ι=0.029, 95% CI = [0.015; 0.057]) and incorrect diagnosis (ι=0.040, 95% CI = [0.023; 0.058], P=0.075). Diagnostic performance of raters yielded the following: accuracy = 60.9%, sensitivity = 21.7%, and specificity = 100%. An overall improvement in the interrater agreement and diagnostic accuracy was observed when the data were analyzed using the internal systems instead of the pattern’s labels.http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/469675 |
collection |
DOAJ |
language |
English |
format |
Article |
sources |
DOAJ |
author |
Ingrid Jardim de Azeredo Souza Oliveira Arthur de Sá Ferreira |
spellingShingle |
Ingrid Jardim de Azeredo Souza Oliveira Arthur de Sá Ferreira Effects of Diagnostic Errors in Pattern Differentiation and Acupuncture Prescription: A Single-Blinded, Interrater Agreement Study Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine |
author_facet |
Ingrid Jardim de Azeredo Souza Oliveira Arthur de Sá Ferreira |
author_sort |
Ingrid Jardim de Azeredo Souza Oliveira |
title |
Effects of Diagnostic Errors in Pattern Differentiation and Acupuncture Prescription: A Single-Blinded, Interrater Agreement Study |
title_short |
Effects of Diagnostic Errors in Pattern Differentiation and Acupuncture Prescription: A Single-Blinded, Interrater Agreement Study |
title_full |
Effects of Diagnostic Errors in Pattern Differentiation and Acupuncture Prescription: A Single-Blinded, Interrater Agreement Study |
title_fullStr |
Effects of Diagnostic Errors in Pattern Differentiation and Acupuncture Prescription: A Single-Blinded, Interrater Agreement Study |
title_full_unstemmed |
Effects of Diagnostic Errors in Pattern Differentiation and Acupuncture Prescription: A Single-Blinded, Interrater Agreement Study |
title_sort |
effects of diagnostic errors in pattern differentiation and acupuncture prescription: a single-blinded, interrater agreement study |
publisher |
Hindawi Limited |
series |
Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine |
issn |
1741-427X 1741-4288 |
publishDate |
2015-01-01 |
description |
This study compared the interrater agreement for pattern differentiation and acupoints prescription between two groups of human patients simulated with different diagnostic outcomes. Patients were simulated using a dataset about zangfu patterns and separated into groups (n=30 each) according to the diagnostic outcome determined by a computational model. A questionnaire with 90 patients was delivered to 6 TCM experts (4-year minimal of clinic experience) who were asked to indicate a single pattern (among 73) and 8 acupoints (among 378). Interrater agreement was higher for pattern differentiation than for acupuncture prescription. Interrater agreement on pattern differentiation was slight for both groups with correct (Light’s κ=0.167, 95% CI = [0.108; 0.254]) and incorrect diagnosis (Light’s κ=0.190, 95% CI = [0.120; 0.286]). Interrater agreement on acupuncture prescription was slight for both groups of correct (ι=0.029, 95% CI = [0.015; 0.057]) and incorrect diagnosis (ι=0.040, 95% CI = [0.023; 0.058], P=0.075). Diagnostic performance of raters yielded the following: accuracy = 60.9%, sensitivity = 21.7%, and specificity = 100%. An overall improvement in the interrater agreement and diagnostic accuracy was observed when the data were analyzed using the internal systems instead of the pattern’s labels. |
url |
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/469675 |
work_keys_str_mv |
AT ingridjardimdeazeredosouzaoliveira effectsofdiagnosticerrorsinpatterndifferentiationandacupunctureprescriptionasingleblindedinterrateragreementstudy AT arthurdesaferreira effectsofdiagnosticerrorsinpatterndifferentiationandacupunctureprescriptionasingleblindedinterrateragreementstudy |
_version_ |
1716787444937916416 |