Parallel, targeted analysis of environmental samples via high‐throughput quantitative PCR

Abstract When analyzing environmental samples for DNA from multiple taxa, researchers must usually decide between iterative analyses with single‐taxon assays—which are reliable and sensitive, but also laborious to apply—and approaches such as metabarcoding that can simultaneously target multiple spe...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Taylor M. Wilcox, Kevin S. McKelvey, Michael K. Young, Cory Engkjer, Richard F. Lance, Andrew Lahr, Lisa A. Eby, Michael K. Schwartz
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Wiley 2020-10-01
Series:Environmental DNA
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1002/edn3.80
id doaj-8c6a384bdfe542df861064d888463382
record_format Article
spelling doaj-8c6a384bdfe542df861064d8884633822020-11-25T02:35:04ZengWileyEnvironmental DNA2637-49432020-10-012454455310.1002/edn3.80Parallel, targeted analysis of environmental samples via high‐throughput quantitative PCRTaylor M. Wilcox0Kevin S. McKelvey1Michael K. Young2Cory Engkjer3Richard F. Lance4Andrew Lahr5Lisa A. Eby6Michael K. Schwartz7National Genomics Center for Wildlife and Fish Conservation Rocky Mountain Research Station Missoula MT USANational Genomics Center for Wildlife and Fish Conservation Rocky Mountain Research Station Missoula MT USANational Genomics Center for Wildlife and Fish Conservation Rocky Mountain Research Station Missoula MT USANational Genomics Center for Wildlife and Fish Conservation Rocky Mountain Research Station Missoula MT USAEnvironmental Laboratory United States, Army Engineer Research and Development Center Vicksburg MS USAWildlife Biology Program Department of Ecosystem and Conservation Sciences University of Montana Missoula MT USAWildlife Biology Program Department of Ecosystem and Conservation Sciences University of Montana Missoula MT USANational Genomics Center for Wildlife and Fish Conservation Rocky Mountain Research Station Missoula MT USAAbstract When analyzing environmental samples for DNA from multiple taxa, researchers must usually decide between iterative analyses with single‐taxon assays—which are reliable and sensitive, but also laborious to apply—and approaches such as metabarcoding that can simultaneously target multiple species, but which are less sensitive for detection across taxa. Here, we test an intermediate approach that allows efficient, parallel assessment of taxon‐specific qPCR assays via high‐throughput quantitative PCR (HT‐qPCR). Based on an assessment of over 500 environmental samples, we found that sensitivity and specificity of our HT‐qPCR approach were similar (concordance 0.900–1.000) to values achieved through single‐species qPCR in six out of seven assays tested. Thus, HT‐qPCR may provide analyses of similar quality as single‐species qPCR analyses for environmental DNA, but at a lower cost per taxon. We see this approach as being a valuable addition to the eDNA sampling toolbox, particularly for situations where reliable inferences are needed for a defined suite of rare invasive or imperiled taxa.https://doi.org/10.1002/edn3.80environmental DNAmulti‐speciesmulti‐taxaqPCRrare species
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Taylor M. Wilcox
Kevin S. McKelvey
Michael K. Young
Cory Engkjer
Richard F. Lance
Andrew Lahr
Lisa A. Eby
Michael K. Schwartz
spellingShingle Taylor M. Wilcox
Kevin S. McKelvey
Michael K. Young
Cory Engkjer
Richard F. Lance
Andrew Lahr
Lisa A. Eby
Michael K. Schwartz
Parallel, targeted analysis of environmental samples via high‐throughput quantitative PCR
Environmental DNA
environmental DNA
multi‐species
multi‐taxa
qPCR
rare species
author_facet Taylor M. Wilcox
Kevin S. McKelvey
Michael K. Young
Cory Engkjer
Richard F. Lance
Andrew Lahr
Lisa A. Eby
Michael K. Schwartz
author_sort Taylor M. Wilcox
title Parallel, targeted analysis of environmental samples via high‐throughput quantitative PCR
title_short Parallel, targeted analysis of environmental samples via high‐throughput quantitative PCR
title_full Parallel, targeted analysis of environmental samples via high‐throughput quantitative PCR
title_fullStr Parallel, targeted analysis of environmental samples via high‐throughput quantitative PCR
title_full_unstemmed Parallel, targeted analysis of environmental samples via high‐throughput quantitative PCR
title_sort parallel, targeted analysis of environmental samples via high‐throughput quantitative pcr
publisher Wiley
series Environmental DNA
issn 2637-4943
publishDate 2020-10-01
description Abstract When analyzing environmental samples for DNA from multiple taxa, researchers must usually decide between iterative analyses with single‐taxon assays—which are reliable and sensitive, but also laborious to apply—and approaches such as metabarcoding that can simultaneously target multiple species, but which are less sensitive for detection across taxa. Here, we test an intermediate approach that allows efficient, parallel assessment of taxon‐specific qPCR assays via high‐throughput quantitative PCR (HT‐qPCR). Based on an assessment of over 500 environmental samples, we found that sensitivity and specificity of our HT‐qPCR approach were similar (concordance 0.900–1.000) to values achieved through single‐species qPCR in six out of seven assays tested. Thus, HT‐qPCR may provide analyses of similar quality as single‐species qPCR analyses for environmental DNA, but at a lower cost per taxon. We see this approach as being a valuable addition to the eDNA sampling toolbox, particularly for situations where reliable inferences are needed for a defined suite of rare invasive or imperiled taxa.
topic environmental DNA
multi‐species
multi‐taxa
qPCR
rare species
url https://doi.org/10.1002/edn3.80
work_keys_str_mv AT taylormwilcox paralleltargetedanalysisofenvironmentalsamplesviahighthroughputquantitativepcr
AT kevinsmckelvey paralleltargetedanalysisofenvironmentalsamplesviahighthroughputquantitativepcr
AT michaelkyoung paralleltargetedanalysisofenvironmentalsamplesviahighthroughputquantitativepcr
AT coryengkjer paralleltargetedanalysisofenvironmentalsamplesviahighthroughputquantitativepcr
AT richardflance paralleltargetedanalysisofenvironmentalsamplesviahighthroughputquantitativepcr
AT andrewlahr paralleltargetedanalysisofenvironmentalsamplesviahighthroughputquantitativepcr
AT lisaaeby paralleltargetedanalysisofenvironmentalsamplesviahighthroughputquantitativepcr
AT michaelkschwartz paralleltargetedanalysisofenvironmentalsamplesviahighthroughputquantitativepcr
_version_ 1724805493364359168