Investigating Practical Impacts of Using Single-Antenna and Dual-Antenna GNSS/INS Sensors in UAS-Lidar Applications

Data collected from a moving lidar sensor can produce an accurate digital representation of the physical environment that is scanned, provided the time-dependent positions and orientations of the lidar sensor can be determined. The most widely used approach to determining these positions and orienta...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Ryan G. Brazeal, Benjamin E. Wilkinson, Adam R. Benjamin
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2021-08-01
Series:Sensors
Subjects:
UAV
GPS
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/21/16/5382
id doaj-9e2894d5fcac419e86212913cae065d7
record_format Article
spelling doaj-9e2894d5fcac419e86212913cae065d72021-08-26T14:18:52ZengMDPI AGSensors1424-82202021-08-01215382538210.3390/s21165382Investigating Practical Impacts of Using Single-Antenna and Dual-Antenna GNSS/INS Sensors in UAS-Lidar ApplicationsRyan G. Brazeal0Benjamin E. Wilkinson1Adam R. Benjamin2Geomatics Program, School of Forest, Fisheries, and Geomatics Sciences, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611, USAGeomatics Program, School of Forest, Fisheries, and Geomatics Sciences, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611, USAGeomatics Program, Fort Lauderdale Research & Education Center, School of Forest, Fisheries, and Geomatics Sciences, University of Florida, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33314, USAData collected from a moving lidar sensor can produce an accurate digital representation of the physical environment that is scanned, provided the time-dependent positions and orientations of the lidar sensor can be determined. The most widely used approach to determining these positions and orientations is to collect data with a GNSS/INS sensor. The use of dual-antenna GNSS/INS sensors within commercial UAS-lidar systems is uncommon due to the higher cost and more complex installation of the GNSS antennas. This study investigates the impacts of using a single-antenna and dual-antenna GNSS/INS MEMS-based sensor on the positional precision of a UAS-lidar generated point cloud, with an emphasis on the different heading determination techniques employed by each type of GNSS/INS sensor. Specifically, the impacts that sensor velocity and acceleration (single-antenna), and a GNSS compass (dual-antenna) have on heading precision are investigated. Results indicate that at the slower flying speeds often used by UAS (≤5 m/s), a dual-antenna GNSS/INS sensor can improve heading precision by up to a factor of five relative to a single-antenna GNSS/INS sensor, and that a point of diminishing returns for the improvement of heading precision exists at a flying speed of approximately 15 m/s for single-antenna GNSS/INS sensors. Additionally, a simple estimator for the expected heading precision of a single-antenna GNSS/INS sensor based on flying speed is presented. Utilizing UAS-lidar mapping systems with dual-antenna GNSS/INS sensors provides reliable, robust, and higher precision heading estimates, resulting in point clouds with higher accuracy and precision.https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/21/16/5382unoccupied aerial systemUAVdroneGPSinertialheading
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Ryan G. Brazeal
Benjamin E. Wilkinson
Adam R. Benjamin
spellingShingle Ryan G. Brazeal
Benjamin E. Wilkinson
Adam R. Benjamin
Investigating Practical Impacts of Using Single-Antenna and Dual-Antenna GNSS/INS Sensors in UAS-Lidar Applications
Sensors
unoccupied aerial system
UAV
drone
GPS
inertial
heading
author_facet Ryan G. Brazeal
Benjamin E. Wilkinson
Adam R. Benjamin
author_sort Ryan G. Brazeal
title Investigating Practical Impacts of Using Single-Antenna and Dual-Antenna GNSS/INS Sensors in UAS-Lidar Applications
title_short Investigating Practical Impacts of Using Single-Antenna and Dual-Antenna GNSS/INS Sensors in UAS-Lidar Applications
title_full Investigating Practical Impacts of Using Single-Antenna and Dual-Antenna GNSS/INS Sensors in UAS-Lidar Applications
title_fullStr Investigating Practical Impacts of Using Single-Antenna and Dual-Antenna GNSS/INS Sensors in UAS-Lidar Applications
title_full_unstemmed Investigating Practical Impacts of Using Single-Antenna and Dual-Antenna GNSS/INS Sensors in UAS-Lidar Applications
title_sort investigating practical impacts of using single-antenna and dual-antenna gnss/ins sensors in uas-lidar applications
publisher MDPI AG
series Sensors
issn 1424-8220
publishDate 2021-08-01
description Data collected from a moving lidar sensor can produce an accurate digital representation of the physical environment that is scanned, provided the time-dependent positions and orientations of the lidar sensor can be determined. The most widely used approach to determining these positions and orientations is to collect data with a GNSS/INS sensor. The use of dual-antenna GNSS/INS sensors within commercial UAS-lidar systems is uncommon due to the higher cost and more complex installation of the GNSS antennas. This study investigates the impacts of using a single-antenna and dual-antenna GNSS/INS MEMS-based sensor on the positional precision of a UAS-lidar generated point cloud, with an emphasis on the different heading determination techniques employed by each type of GNSS/INS sensor. Specifically, the impacts that sensor velocity and acceleration (single-antenna), and a GNSS compass (dual-antenna) have on heading precision are investigated. Results indicate that at the slower flying speeds often used by UAS (≤5 m/s), a dual-antenna GNSS/INS sensor can improve heading precision by up to a factor of five relative to a single-antenna GNSS/INS sensor, and that a point of diminishing returns for the improvement of heading precision exists at a flying speed of approximately 15 m/s for single-antenna GNSS/INS sensors. Additionally, a simple estimator for the expected heading precision of a single-antenna GNSS/INS sensor based on flying speed is presented. Utilizing UAS-lidar mapping systems with dual-antenna GNSS/INS sensors provides reliable, robust, and higher precision heading estimates, resulting in point clouds with higher accuracy and precision.
topic unoccupied aerial system
UAV
drone
GPS
inertial
heading
url https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/21/16/5382
work_keys_str_mv AT ryangbrazeal investigatingpracticalimpactsofusingsingleantennaanddualantennagnssinssensorsinuaslidarapplications
AT benjaminewilkinson investigatingpracticalimpactsofusingsingleantennaanddualantennagnssinssensorsinuaslidarapplications
AT adamrbenjamin investigatingpracticalimpactsofusingsingleantennaanddualantennagnssinssensorsinuaslidarapplications
_version_ 1721190184318402560