Enteric Fever in a Cross-section of Patients in Karachi: Current Correlation of Positive Blood Cultures with the Widal Agglutination and the Typhidot Immunoassay Tests
Objectives: A lab-based scrutiny to assess the correlation of current blood culture Salmonella isolates as the gold standard with matched Widal agglutinin titers and the EIA-based Typhidot immunoassay antibodies. Methods: 2,704 blood specimens were drawn for culture and Widal test in a private...
Main Authors: | , , , |
---|---|
Format: | Article |
Language: | English |
Published: |
Dow University of Health Sciences
2013-09-01
|
Series: | Journal of the Dow University of Health Sciences |
Subjects: | |
Online Access: | http://www.jduhs.com/index.php/jduhs/article/view/98 |
Summary: | Objectives:
A lab-based scrutiny to assess the correlation of current blood culture Salmonella isolates as the gold standard with matched Widal agglutinin titers and the EIA-based Typhidot immunoassay antibodies.
Methods:
2,704 blood specimens were drawn for culture and Widal test in a private clinical lab in Karachi City from subjects presenting with clinical signs of Enteric fever during April 2012 and March 2013. Of these, 1,497yielded Salmonella isolates; sera of these patients that were not accompanied with requests for Typhidot werealso subjected to dot immunoassay with informed consent solicited at the time of bleeding. All sera were storedat 40C until screened.
Results:
Blood from 802 males (53.6%) and 695 females (46.4%) yielded 61.85% S typhi (n=926), 31.26% S.paratyphi-A (n=468) and 6.88% S. paratyphi-B (n=103) isolates. Widal agglutinins were detected in 473 (31.5%)of the sera of these subjects. 'H' titers of 1:80 (n=264: 17.6%) without detectable 'O' antibodies were seen more frequently in children's sera (n=112; 7.4%). Widal 'H' with 'O' agglutinins were recorded in 209 (13.9%) of corresponding positive blood cultures, of which 104 (6.9%) yielded titers of 1:320 or more. A total of 1,024 sera(58.4%) lacked detectable Widal antibodies. The Typhidot immunoglobulin dots, negative in 856 sera (57.1%), were detected in 641 specimens (42.8%). IgM dots (n=314: 20.9%) without IgG were more commonly seen,as were IgM with IgG (n=296: 19.7%). Also noted were IgG dots with no detectable IgM in 22 sera (1.47%), and IgM dots with no IgG in specimens that yielded S. paratyphi-A (n=8) and one S. paratyphi-B isolate.
Conclusion:
S. paratyphi-A has increased in frequency during the last decade, possibly suggesting incomplete protective coverage employing monovalent vaccine. Widal agglutinins and Typhidot antibodies were detectablein 31.5% and 42.8% respectively in the sera of patients whose blood grew Salmonellae. The Widal can bemisconstrued due to possible “background†agglutinins in the unvaccinated, and the dot EIA immunoassay isrestricted in specificity for only S. typhi. An ICT-based gauge of the three Salmonella serotypes is desirable. |
---|---|
ISSN: | 1995-2198 2410-2180 |