The role of supportive supervision using mobile technology in monitoring and guiding program performance: a case study in Nigeria, 2015–2016

Abstract Background Supportive supervision is one of the interventions that fosters program improvement by way of imparting knowledge and skills to health workers. The basic challenge in supportive supervision is the availability of data in real time for timely and effective feedback. Thus, the main...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Sisay G. Tegegne, Faisal Shuaib, Fiona Braka, Pascal Mkanda, Tesfaye B. Erbeto, Aron Aregay, Oyaole D. Rasheed, Akpan G. Ubong, Njie Alpha, Ahmed Khedr, Mirghani A. Isameldin, Yared G. Yehushualet, Charity Warigon, Usman Adamu, Eunice Damisa, Bassey Okposen, Peter Nsubuga, Rui G. Vaz, Wondimagegnehu Alemu
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: BMC 2018-12-01
Series:BMC Public Health
Subjects:
Online Access:http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12889-018-6189-8
id doaj-a2ad4cb6ef2042d6aedf3d586a2da347
record_format Article
spelling doaj-a2ad4cb6ef2042d6aedf3d586a2da3472020-11-25T01:15:39ZengBMCBMC Public Health1471-24582018-12-0118S4758110.1186/s12889-018-6189-8The role of supportive supervision using mobile technology in monitoring and guiding program performance: a case study in Nigeria, 2015–2016Sisay G. Tegegne0Faisal Shuaib1Fiona Braka2Pascal Mkanda3Tesfaye B. Erbeto4Aron Aregay5Oyaole D. Rasheed6Akpan G. Ubong7Njie Alpha8Ahmed Khedr9Mirghani A. Isameldin10Yared G. Yehushualet11Charity Warigon12Usman Adamu13Eunice Damisa14Bassey Okposen15Peter Nsubuga16Rui G. Vaz17Wondimagegnehu Alemu18World Health Organization Country OfficeNational Primary Health Care Development AgencyWorld Health Organization Country OfficeWorld Health Organization, Regional Office for AfricaWorld Health Organization Country OfficeWorld Health Organization Country OfficeWorld Health Organization Country OfficeWorld Health Organization, Regional Office for AfricaWorld Health Organization Country OfficeWorld Health Organization Country OfficeWorld Health Organization Country OfficeWorld Health Organization Country OfficeWorld Health Organization Country OfficeNational Primary Health Care Development AgencyNational Primary Health Care Development AgencyNational Primary Health Care Development AgencyGlobal Public Health Care SolutionsWorld Health Organization, HeadquartersWorld Health Organization Country OfficeAbstract Background Supportive supervision is one of the interventions that fosters program improvement by way of imparting knowledge and skills to health workers. The basic challenge in supportive supervision is the availability of data in real time for timely and effective feedback. Thus, the main objective of this study was to determine the contribution of real-time data collection during supportive supervision for timely feedback and generation of evidence for health intervention planning. Methods We analyzed supportive supervision records collected through handheld devices employing the open data kit (ODK) platform from July 2015 to June 2016. Supervision was conducted across the country by 592 World Health Organization (WHO) officers. The availability of real-time data and the distance of health facilities to the community were analyzed. Results During the study period, 90,396 health facilities were supervised. The average time spent during supervision varied from 1.53 to 3.78 h across the six geopolitical zones of the country. The average interval between completion of the supervisory checklist and synchronization with the server varied from 3.9 h to 7.5 h. The average distance between the health facility and a ward varied from 5 to 24 km. Conclusion The use of handheld devices for supportive supervision provided real-time data from health facilities to state and zonal levels for analysis and feedback. Program officers used the findings to rectify process indicators in time for a better outcome.http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12889-018-6189-8Real-time dataSupportive supervisionTimely feedbackHealth facility distance
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Sisay G. Tegegne
Faisal Shuaib
Fiona Braka
Pascal Mkanda
Tesfaye B. Erbeto
Aron Aregay
Oyaole D. Rasheed
Akpan G. Ubong
Njie Alpha
Ahmed Khedr
Mirghani A. Isameldin
Yared G. Yehushualet
Charity Warigon
Usman Adamu
Eunice Damisa
Bassey Okposen
Peter Nsubuga
Rui G. Vaz
Wondimagegnehu Alemu
spellingShingle Sisay G. Tegegne
Faisal Shuaib
Fiona Braka
Pascal Mkanda
Tesfaye B. Erbeto
Aron Aregay
Oyaole D. Rasheed
Akpan G. Ubong
Njie Alpha
Ahmed Khedr
Mirghani A. Isameldin
Yared G. Yehushualet
Charity Warigon
Usman Adamu
Eunice Damisa
Bassey Okposen
Peter Nsubuga
Rui G. Vaz
Wondimagegnehu Alemu
The role of supportive supervision using mobile technology in monitoring and guiding program performance: a case study in Nigeria, 2015–2016
BMC Public Health
Real-time data
Supportive supervision
Timely feedback
Health facility distance
author_facet Sisay G. Tegegne
Faisal Shuaib
Fiona Braka
Pascal Mkanda
Tesfaye B. Erbeto
Aron Aregay
Oyaole D. Rasheed
Akpan G. Ubong
Njie Alpha
Ahmed Khedr
Mirghani A. Isameldin
Yared G. Yehushualet
Charity Warigon
Usman Adamu
Eunice Damisa
Bassey Okposen
Peter Nsubuga
Rui G. Vaz
Wondimagegnehu Alemu
author_sort Sisay G. Tegegne
title The role of supportive supervision using mobile technology in monitoring and guiding program performance: a case study in Nigeria, 2015–2016
title_short The role of supportive supervision using mobile technology in monitoring and guiding program performance: a case study in Nigeria, 2015–2016
title_full The role of supportive supervision using mobile technology in monitoring and guiding program performance: a case study in Nigeria, 2015–2016
title_fullStr The role of supportive supervision using mobile technology in monitoring and guiding program performance: a case study in Nigeria, 2015–2016
title_full_unstemmed The role of supportive supervision using mobile technology in monitoring and guiding program performance: a case study in Nigeria, 2015–2016
title_sort role of supportive supervision using mobile technology in monitoring and guiding program performance: a case study in nigeria, 2015–2016
publisher BMC
series BMC Public Health
issn 1471-2458
publishDate 2018-12-01
description Abstract Background Supportive supervision is one of the interventions that fosters program improvement by way of imparting knowledge and skills to health workers. The basic challenge in supportive supervision is the availability of data in real time for timely and effective feedback. Thus, the main objective of this study was to determine the contribution of real-time data collection during supportive supervision for timely feedback and generation of evidence for health intervention planning. Methods We analyzed supportive supervision records collected through handheld devices employing the open data kit (ODK) platform from July 2015 to June 2016. Supervision was conducted across the country by 592 World Health Organization (WHO) officers. The availability of real-time data and the distance of health facilities to the community were analyzed. Results During the study period, 90,396 health facilities were supervised. The average time spent during supervision varied from 1.53 to 3.78 h across the six geopolitical zones of the country. The average interval between completion of the supervisory checklist and synchronization with the server varied from 3.9 h to 7.5 h. The average distance between the health facility and a ward varied from 5 to 24 km. Conclusion The use of handheld devices for supportive supervision provided real-time data from health facilities to state and zonal levels for analysis and feedback. Program officers used the findings to rectify process indicators in time for a better outcome.
topic Real-time data
Supportive supervision
Timely feedback
Health facility distance
url http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12889-018-6189-8
work_keys_str_mv AT sisaygtegegne theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT faisalshuaib theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT fionabraka theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT pascalmkanda theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT tesfayeberbeto theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT aronaregay theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT oyaoledrasheed theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT akpangubong theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT njiealpha theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT ahmedkhedr theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT mirghaniaisameldin theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT yaredgyehushualet theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT charitywarigon theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT usmanadamu theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT eunicedamisa theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT basseyokposen theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT peternsubuga theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT ruigvaz theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT wondimagegnehualemu theroleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT sisaygtegegne roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT faisalshuaib roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT fionabraka roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT pascalmkanda roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT tesfayeberbeto roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT aronaregay roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT oyaoledrasheed roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT akpangubong roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT njiealpha roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT ahmedkhedr roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT mirghaniaisameldin roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT yaredgyehushualet roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT charitywarigon roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT usmanadamu roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT eunicedamisa roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT basseyokposen roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT peternsubuga roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT ruigvaz roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
AT wondimagegnehualemu roleofsupportivesupervisionusingmobiletechnologyinmonitoringandguidingprogramperformanceacasestudyinnigeria20152016
_version_ 1725152003810656256