Change Detection Based on the Coefficient of Variation in SAR Time-Series of Urban Areas

This paper discusses change detection in SAR time-series. First, several statistical properties of the coefficient of variation highlight its pertinence for change detection. Subsequently, several criteria are proposed. The coefficient of variation is suggested to detect any kind of change. Furtherm...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Elise Colin Koeniguer, Jean-Marie Nicolas
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: MDPI AG 2020-06-01
Series:Remote Sensing
Subjects:
SAR
Online Access:https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/12/13/2089
id doaj-aa59bdc55d264b6eba6a1aa2562bd21e
record_format Article
spelling doaj-aa59bdc55d264b6eba6a1aa2562bd21e2020-11-25T02:13:45ZengMDPI AGRemote Sensing2072-42922020-06-01122089208910.3390/rs12132089Change Detection Based on the Coefficient of Variation in SAR Time-Series of Urban AreasElise Colin Koeniguer0Jean-Marie Nicolas1Onera, Université Paris Saclay, 91123 Palaiseau, FranceInstitut Polytechnique de Paris, LCTI, Telecom Paris, 91120 Paris, FranceThis paper discusses change detection in SAR time-series. First, several statistical properties of the coefficient of variation highlight its pertinence for change detection. Subsequently, several criteria are proposed. The coefficient of variation is suggested to detect any kind of change. Furthermore, several criteria that are based on ratios of coefficients of variations are proposed to detect long events, such as construction test sites, or point-event, such as vehicles. These detection methods are first evaluated on theoretical statistical simulations to determine the scenarios where they can deliver the best results. The simulations demonstrate the greater sensitivity of the coefficient of variation to speckle mixtures, as in the case of agricultural plots. Conversely, they also demonstrate the greater specificity of the other criteria for the cases addressed: very short event or longer-term changes. Subsequently, detection performance is assessed on real data for different types of scenes and sensors (Sentinel-1, UAVSAR). In particular, a quantitative evaluation is performed with a comparison of our solutions with baseline methods. The proposed criteria achieve the best performance, with reduced computational complexity. On Sentinel-1 images containing mainly construction test sites, our best criterion reaches a probability of change detection of 90% for a false alarm rate that is equal to 5%. On UAVSAR images containing boats, the criteria proposed for short events achieve a probability of detection equal to 90% of all pixels belonging to the boats, for a false alarm rate that is equal to 2%.https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/12/13/2089multitemporalchange detectiontime seriesSARcoefficient of variation
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author Elise Colin Koeniguer
Jean-Marie Nicolas
spellingShingle Elise Colin Koeniguer
Jean-Marie Nicolas
Change Detection Based on the Coefficient of Variation in SAR Time-Series of Urban Areas
Remote Sensing
multitemporal
change detection
time series
SAR
coefficient of variation
author_facet Elise Colin Koeniguer
Jean-Marie Nicolas
author_sort Elise Colin Koeniguer
title Change Detection Based on the Coefficient of Variation in SAR Time-Series of Urban Areas
title_short Change Detection Based on the Coefficient of Variation in SAR Time-Series of Urban Areas
title_full Change Detection Based on the Coefficient of Variation in SAR Time-Series of Urban Areas
title_fullStr Change Detection Based on the Coefficient of Variation in SAR Time-Series of Urban Areas
title_full_unstemmed Change Detection Based on the Coefficient of Variation in SAR Time-Series of Urban Areas
title_sort change detection based on the coefficient of variation in sar time-series of urban areas
publisher MDPI AG
series Remote Sensing
issn 2072-4292
publishDate 2020-06-01
description This paper discusses change detection in SAR time-series. First, several statistical properties of the coefficient of variation highlight its pertinence for change detection. Subsequently, several criteria are proposed. The coefficient of variation is suggested to detect any kind of change. Furthermore, several criteria that are based on ratios of coefficients of variations are proposed to detect long events, such as construction test sites, or point-event, such as vehicles. These detection methods are first evaluated on theoretical statistical simulations to determine the scenarios where they can deliver the best results. The simulations demonstrate the greater sensitivity of the coefficient of variation to speckle mixtures, as in the case of agricultural plots. Conversely, they also demonstrate the greater specificity of the other criteria for the cases addressed: very short event or longer-term changes. Subsequently, detection performance is assessed on real data for different types of scenes and sensors (Sentinel-1, UAVSAR). In particular, a quantitative evaluation is performed with a comparison of our solutions with baseline methods. The proposed criteria achieve the best performance, with reduced computational complexity. On Sentinel-1 images containing mainly construction test sites, our best criterion reaches a probability of change detection of 90% for a false alarm rate that is equal to 5%. On UAVSAR images containing boats, the criteria proposed for short events achieve a probability of detection equal to 90% of all pixels belonging to the boats, for a false alarm rate that is equal to 2%.
topic multitemporal
change detection
time series
SAR
coefficient of variation
url https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/12/13/2089
work_keys_str_mv AT elisecolinkoeniguer changedetectionbasedonthecoefficientofvariationinsartimeseriesofurbanareas
AT jeanmarienicolas changedetectionbasedonthecoefficientofvariationinsartimeseriesofurbanareas
_version_ 1724903325077340160