Continuous Structural Parameterization: A Proposed Method for Representing Different Model Parameterizations Within One Structure Demonstrated for Atmospheric Convection

Abstract Continuous structural parameterization (CSP) is a proposed method for approximating different numerical model parameterizations of the same process as functions of the same grid‐scale variables. This allows systematic comparison of parameterizations with each other and observations or resol...

Full description

Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: F. H. Lambert, P. G. Challenor, N. T. Lewis, D. J. McNeall, N. Owen, I. A. Boutle, H. M. Christensen, R. J. Keane, N. J. Mayne, A. Stirling, M. J. Webb
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: American Geophysical Union (AGU) 2020-08-01
Series:Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
Subjects:
Online Access:https://doi.org/10.1029/2020MS002085
id doaj-b128f9c346d8450187d95b2c5d0d3858
record_format Article
spelling doaj-b128f9c346d8450187d95b2c5d0d38582020-11-25T03:13:17ZengAmerican Geophysical Union (AGU)Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems1942-24662020-08-01128n/an/a10.1029/2020MS002085Continuous Structural Parameterization: A Proposed Method for Representing Different Model Parameterizations Within One Structure Demonstrated for Atmospheric ConvectionF. H. Lambert0P. G. Challenor1N. T. Lewis2D. J. McNeall3N. Owen4I. A. Boutle5H. M. Christensen6R. J. Keane7N. J. Mayne8A. Stirling9M. J. Webb10College of Engineering, Mathematics, and Physical Science University of Exeter Exeter UKCollege of Engineering, Mathematics, and Physical Science University of Exeter Exeter UKAtmospheric, Oceanic, and Planetary Physics University of Oxford Oxford UKMet Office Exeter UKUniversity of Exeter Business School University of Exeter Exeter UKMet Office Exeter UKAtmospheric, Oceanic, and Planetary Physics University of Oxford Oxford UKMet Office Exeter UKCollege of Engineering, Mathematics, and Physical Science University of Exeter Exeter UKMet Office Exeter UKMet Office Exeter UKAbstract Continuous structural parameterization (CSP) is a proposed method for approximating different numerical model parameterizations of the same process as functions of the same grid‐scale variables. This allows systematic comparison of parameterizations with each other and observations or resolved simulations of the same process. Using the example of two convection schemes running in the Met Office Unified Model (UM), we show that a CSP is able to capture concisely the broad behavior of the two schemes, and differences between the parameterizations and resolved convection simulated by a high resolution simulation. When the original convection schemes are replaced with their CSP emulators within the UM, basic features of the original model climate and some features of climate change are reproduced, demonstrating that CSP can capture much of the important behavior of the schemes. Our results open the possibility that future work will estimate uncertainty in model projections of climate change from estimates of uncertainty in simulation of the relevant physical processes.https://doi.org/10.1029/2020MS002085statistical modelingconvectionparameterizationGCM modelinghigh resolution
collection DOAJ
language English
format Article
sources DOAJ
author F. H. Lambert
P. G. Challenor
N. T. Lewis
D. J. McNeall
N. Owen
I. A. Boutle
H. M. Christensen
R. J. Keane
N. J. Mayne
A. Stirling
M. J. Webb
spellingShingle F. H. Lambert
P. G. Challenor
N. T. Lewis
D. J. McNeall
N. Owen
I. A. Boutle
H. M. Christensen
R. J. Keane
N. J. Mayne
A. Stirling
M. J. Webb
Continuous Structural Parameterization: A Proposed Method for Representing Different Model Parameterizations Within One Structure Demonstrated for Atmospheric Convection
Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
statistical modeling
convection
parameterization
GCM modeling
high resolution
author_facet F. H. Lambert
P. G. Challenor
N. T. Lewis
D. J. McNeall
N. Owen
I. A. Boutle
H. M. Christensen
R. J. Keane
N. J. Mayne
A. Stirling
M. J. Webb
author_sort F. H. Lambert
title Continuous Structural Parameterization: A Proposed Method for Representing Different Model Parameterizations Within One Structure Demonstrated for Atmospheric Convection
title_short Continuous Structural Parameterization: A Proposed Method for Representing Different Model Parameterizations Within One Structure Demonstrated for Atmospheric Convection
title_full Continuous Structural Parameterization: A Proposed Method for Representing Different Model Parameterizations Within One Structure Demonstrated for Atmospheric Convection
title_fullStr Continuous Structural Parameterization: A Proposed Method for Representing Different Model Parameterizations Within One Structure Demonstrated for Atmospheric Convection
title_full_unstemmed Continuous Structural Parameterization: A Proposed Method for Representing Different Model Parameterizations Within One Structure Demonstrated for Atmospheric Convection
title_sort continuous structural parameterization: a proposed method for representing different model parameterizations within one structure demonstrated for atmospheric convection
publisher American Geophysical Union (AGU)
series Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
issn 1942-2466
publishDate 2020-08-01
description Abstract Continuous structural parameterization (CSP) is a proposed method for approximating different numerical model parameterizations of the same process as functions of the same grid‐scale variables. This allows systematic comparison of parameterizations with each other and observations or resolved simulations of the same process. Using the example of two convection schemes running in the Met Office Unified Model (UM), we show that a CSP is able to capture concisely the broad behavior of the two schemes, and differences between the parameterizations and resolved convection simulated by a high resolution simulation. When the original convection schemes are replaced with their CSP emulators within the UM, basic features of the original model climate and some features of climate change are reproduced, demonstrating that CSP can capture much of the important behavior of the schemes. Our results open the possibility that future work will estimate uncertainty in model projections of climate change from estimates of uncertainty in simulation of the relevant physical processes.
topic statistical modeling
convection
parameterization
GCM modeling
high resolution
url https://doi.org/10.1029/2020MS002085
work_keys_str_mv AT fhlambert continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT pgchallenor continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT ntlewis continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT djmcneall continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT nowen continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT iaboutle continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT hmchristensen continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT rjkeane continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT njmayne continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT astirling continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
AT mjwebb continuousstructuralparameterizationaproposedmethodforrepresentingdifferentmodelparameterizationswithinonestructuredemonstratedforatmosphericconvection
_version_ 1715274837361950720